Mini Normal 1854: Game Over

[Gamma Emerald]

People that are Conftown/probtown
TwoFace - fitz push
Lil Uzi Vert - mason
Frankjaeger - backup BG
Gamma Emerald - fitz push
Nachomamma8 - mason
Joshz - predecessor Eric townslipped

[Gamma Emerald]

Left that there so you don't have to catch up p much.

[Joshz]

and the reason i want you to read aj/hiraki is that i cant decide which is more likely scum because both have compelling cases and it is likely only 1 is scum

frank is only conftown if you think the setup is likely to have a backup bg (bg and masons being only other prs afaik) or not, though i think most people agree hes prolly telling the truth.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

People that are Conftown/probtown
TwoFace - fitz push Lol.
Lil Uzi Vert - mason sure.
Frankjaeger - backup BG ehhhhhhh okay
Gamma Emerald - fitz push Lol.
Nachomamma8 - mason sure.
Joshz - predecessor Eric townslipped Where?

[Aj The Epic]

Lol I didn't see the mod note and got really confused

Hi Sonia. Maybe you'll be done your read through before aj!

In my defense, I am both half way caught up and in finals week for college.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

and the reason i want you to read aj/hiraki is that i cant decide which is more likely scum because both have compelling cases and it is likely only 1 is scum

frank is only conftown if you think the setup is likely to have a backup bg (bg and masons being only other prs afaik) or not, though i think most people agree hes prolly telling the truth.

Just coming out of a game with masons it's def a "wait a minute" flag.
Did he claim under pressure or was there a massclaim type of thing going on.

[Gamma Emerald]

The leftovers
Vedith - not really scummy, but Joshz thinks so
Hiraki - opted to not vote fitz after stating he would
Aj - this is a small issue, but has thrown shade on Eric after the consensus decided he was town
Aristo - softed a PR early Day 1

[TwoFace]

There's way too many masons lately. Need some new game reviewers.

[Joshz]

ROFL .. I like how you guys change your vote so easily when a dark horse suddenly appears ... Too easy

I am a townie and not mafia ... Dont regret it when the KP comes out ... This is my first time playing here, do you really think a mod would make a newbie here a scum? I think not

i think this is what he means


erics whole iso (u can read if u have time its not long) is oozing with newbtown, though i obviously know hes townie so i cant make that read objectively

[Gamma Emerald]

People that are Conftown/probtown
TwoFace - fitz push Lol.
Lil Uzi Vert - mason sure.
Frankjaeger - backup BG ehhhhhhh okay
Gamma Emerald - fitz push Lol.
Nachomamma8 - mason sure.
Joshz - predecessor Eric townslipped Where?

Eric stated newbies don't get to be scum. He'd have to be a fucking mastermind to fake that.
fitz push means that me and TF were pushed by fitz for shaky reasoning

[TwoFace]

Vedith - not really scummy, but Joshz thinks so

Disagree here

[Joshz]

and the reason i want you to read aj/hiraki is that i cant decide which is more likely scum because both have compelling cases and it is likely only 1 is scum

frank is only conftown if you think the setup is likely to have a backup bg (bg and masons being only other prs afaik) or not, though i think most people agree hes prolly telling the truth.

Just coming out of a game with masons it's def a "wait a minute" flag.
Did he claim under pressure or was there a massclaim type of thing going on.

under pressure, he was being lynched. fwiw me and the masons were also on his wagon and scum reading him. i am too new to assert whether or not the setup made sense with a backup bg so i let them decide.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

kk just read Eric w/e slot that is seems town to me he's adorable "can we role claim?" "what is d1" awwww <3

[xSoniaNevermindx]

If there's another pr I'd assume they'd have claimed already cause I doubt there'd be masons bg/backup / 5th pr.

[Joshz]

The leftovers
Vedith - not really scummy, but Joshz thinks so
Hiraki - opted to not vote fitz after stating he would
Aj - this is a small issue, but has thrown shade on Eric after the consensus decided he was town
Aristo - softed a PR early Day 1

NACHO I THINK THIS IS THE THIRD TIME IM ASKING YOU EXPLAIN YOUR ARISTO READ OR SAY ITS NOT A TOWN READ ANYMORE AAAAAHHHHHHHHHH

aj disappearing after our short interaction and still not being back is concerning af too

[TwoFace]

If there's another pr I'd assume they'd have claimed already cause I doubt there'd be masons bg/backup / 5th pr.

Agree here. Essentially said this already myself

[xSoniaNevermindx]

and the reason i want you to read aj/hiraki is that i cant decide which is more likely scum because both have compelling cases and it is likely only 1 is scum

frank is only conftown if you think the setup is likely to have a backup bg (bg and masons being only other prs afaik) or not, though i think most people agree hes prolly telling the truth.

Just coming out of a game with masons it's def a "wait a minute" flag.
Did he claim under pressure or was there a massclaim type of thing going on.

under pressure, he was being lynched. fwiw me and the masons were also on his wagon and scum reading him. i am too new to assert whether or not the setup made sense with a backup bg so i let them decide.

I'd have felt better if it was said out in the open cause it seems like a save my ass claim.
If it was said in the open I'd stay back for a sec

VOTE: Frank

I'll just leave that for now.

[xSoniaNevermindx]

I could trigger happy cause my scum buddy claimed bodyguard and won in a game with masons just the game before but it just seems meh.

I'll prob be able to get more from interactions with the scum iso

[Gamma Emerald]

IMO Aristo needs to fullclaim

[Joshz]

Nothing to rly claim, if he was a pr he'd have ccd frank

[xSoniaNevermindx]

Only 5 days jeez I was praying for a bit more time but meh

Top wagon makes sense if what everyone says is true (said they'd vote scum and didn't) What was there defense to this? If they made one that is.

[Aj The Epic]

Aj - this is a small issue, but has thrown shade on Eric after the consensus decided he was town

I did so after reading the first few pages of his. They were not good by any measure.

[Gamma Emerald]

Aj - this is a small issue, but has thrown shade on Eric after the consensus decided he was town

I did so after reading the first few pages of his. They were not good by any measure.

Thoughts now?

[Aj The Epic]

Walk me through the logic of how him believing new players don't get scum when he claims to have played for 7 years. I think I get what you're going for (he's new, thought new can't get scum, ergo isn't scum) but I'm not really seeing it, especially when he claims to have a lot of experience.

[Joshz]

Have you finished reading then?