Mini #534 - Vegetable Mafia (Game Over!)

[soupfly]

bah, i wasn't really all that suspicious of crub...gg!

curious why oman got killed by mafia on N2.

[Y]

I got you the godfather D1 and that's how you thank me?

I actually told soupfly I don't think I'll survive the night.
I told you Crub was scum D1!

[Crub]

curious why oman got killed by mafia on N2.

gorckat wanted to kill des, I convinced him that Oman was better because the "Green" thing would relieve some pressure from gorckat, and because I got the feeling he was onto me Oh we also knew that he was a power-role of some description.

des got the bullet because gorckat convinced me that he was the doctor when I was thinking he was the vig. gorckat was convinced that kitty was the SK We also thought that des was pretty close to figuring it out, another reason why I'm really surprised that gorckat didn't get the vig's bullet on night 3.

I also thought very hard about whether or not I should kill soup or kitty night 4. I was thinking that soup was leaning more towards phate as the scum than kitty was, but I was thinking that a close examination of day 1 would hurt me if it came down to convincing soup that Phate was scum and I was town. I thought with Kitty and Phate alive there was the possibility that they would both go after each other, but I was very surprised to log on this morning and find that kitty had voted.

[destructor]

Oh and Destructor, NO!

Yeah, sorry about that. lol

I suppose I should explain why I killed who I did.
Night 1 was a bit of a wild card for me. Oman's scum-buddy comment to ryan really confused me, but I wasn't willing to kill him because I wasn't convinced enough. So, I went with thinktank, who I hadn't been getting town-vibes from... also I felt like if he was town, he hadn't been terribly helpful. And a I figured a second night kill was good for the town, information-wise.

Night 2, I killed Oman because of the scum-buddy WIFOM point and didn't feel great about his vote on the WhoMe wagon. His comments to WhoMe after the self-hammer sounded a little contrived as well, and I felt like he was WIFOMing us again. Turns out I was wrong. =/

Ironically, in Night 2 I was seriously considering Crub as an alternative because of how scarcely he'd been posting. If he hadn't claimed Spinach, I probably would have shot him. I thought right up until my vote on gorckat that he was a Doc because of his claim, which also made some sense with why he'd be trying to stay out of the spot light. I suppose I shouldn't have read into the flavour so much and just called him out for it much early.

The town self-hammers broke my heart, especially tdp's. I was fuming over that.

I am so surprised that des didn't nk night 3. I had him pegged as one-shot at that point, but I should have realised that he also targetted Oman night 2.

If I'd hit town, that would have been game over. I wasn't willing to take the risk and after targeting the Cop, I wasn't feeling too hot about my instincts.

Also, I thought the events of Day 2 and 3 should have put Crub under more scrutiny mostly by the fact that gorckat had been avoiding him way more than was warranted.

After gorckat was lynched, I sent Patrick a PM asking if the final scum was one of Crub or Bookitty. He sent me a reply, but I decided not to read it until the game was over or I couldn't handle the suspense anymore!

Here's a bit of lol from me to Patrick after Bookitty's Day 4 post.

I just saw Boo's latest post and am pretty sure she's scum because the post of Oman's she's pointing to is from Day 1, yet she's claiming he had an investigation result...
That, along with her claim make me sure enough.


I'm going to go and check that PM now. =D

So I went and checked it and replied with this.

Oh god.

I hope she realises what she's just done. =S

lol. It was a heart sinking moment. But I guess that's a sign of a good game. =)


Well done scum! I had a lot of fun with this one. Thanks to Aimee for putting it together and thanks to Patrick for taking it over.

[Y]

I wonder if you (Mafia) had other candidates for the N1 kill...

[gorckat]

I don't think so. At that point, I figured it'd be a three day game with you around

[Y]

I asked Patrick for the roles after I died and it was interesting to read the game, knowing who's who.

[destructor]

I'd be interested to know how our two scum really felt about my half-claim on Crub. gorckat eventually tried to use it against me and Crub shrugged it off in thread. What were you guys really thinking?

[gorckat]

I don't think it came up during the night at all. You just seemed like a ballsy player, with the fake vote early and then the fake half-claim.

[destructor]

I meant at the time. Clearly, it didn't really reveal the information I hoped it would but I'm wondering if it ruffled any feathers. Did you think that I really could have had a guilty on him? What if I hadn't eventually admitted to not being the Cop?

Actually, I just remembered this post.

destructor: Did you get a guilty on Crub?

You

were

rolefishing! And if I'd said yes, I'm guessing you were preparing to bus him and score some town creds. heh

[Y]

It was funny, because at the time I knew that you weren't the cop and that Crub is scum.

[gorckat]

Oh, yeah- I was concerned in the moment

I was not looking forward to going it alone.

[Crub]

I was very concerned at the time, mainly because the power-role pool was small and you were in it

I think it would have ended worse for you if you hadn't of retracted it though

[destructor]

Yeah, I was concerned myself! I figured I should get out of it before it went too far. Anyway, good game. Many lessons and interesting moments came from it. =)

[MeMe]

last post