Mafiascum.net

Mmm. I think you're town, you at least seem to really believe in what you're saying.

I really hope I'm right because that'll be fun postgame

I like Tere's case on Heartache, makes me more confident they're scum. I will sleep on it, but I think I still prefer a BYF lynch today.

Why would town Heartache mean scum Tere?

Town Heartache may not mean scum Tere, it just means it's something to consider as Tere was rather inconsiderate in that push.

I'm not going to policy lynch someone for impoliteness.

In post 353, Leonshade wrote:I'm not going to policy lynch someone for impoliteness.

It feels like a scummy push because of the opportunistic feel.

Opportunistic in what way?

In post 355, Leonshade wrote:Opportunistic in what way?

Tere ignored the fact she stated she would be gone and decided to push her on the fact she was gone. Reeks of opportunism to me.

Reads as playstyle to me. I believe Tere when he says he ignored Heartache's absence because there was no V/LA tag, and I think town Tere would be just as likely to push his top SR to do more work.

You all better lynch Gamma and Heartache after I die, or you'll lose.

What happened to your scumread on me?

I need to put in some work on this and re-read. Not sure when the 24 hours until the hammer ends but give me a few hours, need to do a couple of RL things then I'll come back and see what I can come up with. I'm just finding myself without much of an opinion at the moment, I think as I stand I'd lynch BYF over Heartache if those are the only two options, not thrilled with either of those lynches though.

I quite like Gamma's unpacking of his read on me. Feels natural.

BYF's comments re Heartache feel like distancing.

In post 360, Sgz13 wrote:I need to put in some work on this and re-read. Not sure when the 24 hours until the hammer ends but give me a few hours, need to do a couple of RL things then I'll come back and see what I can come up with. I'm just finding myself without much of an opinion at the moment,

I think as I stand I'd lynch BYF over Heartache if those are the only two options, not thrilled with either of those lynches though.

Can you unpack this a bit for me? Do you have a townread on them, if so, why? I know you've talked about Heartache's read on you previously but personally I don't find that compelling. Is there anything else about her you find towny?

If you think BYF and Heartache are town, who could be scum? I know you have a scum read on Gamma, can you talk about that a bit more?

Let me do my re-read Tere, I'll make a lot more sense then I'm sure, I'll unpack everything and you'll know where I stand. Time has gotten the best of me though, I only have 50 minutes and I need to cook and eat, so you'll have to give me until tonight now (sorry for dragging this out, unforeseen circumstances).

Sweet.

Hey Leon, I'd really like for Sgz to do his catch up - we have three days to deadline.

Sure, I'm in no rush.

Am I losing it or are the Lion's eyes doing something funny? Just noticed that...

Anyways, that was my way of announcing I'm here and doing all the homework I should have done first time around.

Re-reading D1 makes me feel a bit better about Gamma. I mean who would you protect after that D1? Of course Jaaaaaaaaaaack could have been the NK, but we don't have the luxury of absolute certainties here.

In post 162, Tere wrote:Um, because it's a really terrible idea because maths?

We had a lolhammer and a successful NK, so now at 2 scum 5 town. Jaack might have bodyguarded Leonshade (it's what I would have done with that role) but can't prove that. Whatever.

Policy lynch now and if he's a VI we are at 2:4. Successful NK and 2:3. Lylo tomorrow.... It's been a while but I think that's the maths.

Are you happy to vote reso and if not why not? Be specific

Missed this on first read. Which of Leonshade's 2 D1 posts made him protection worthy for you?

Heck, you're right. He obvtowned later. I keep forgetting exactly how short Day 1 was, lol.

I don't get why Jaack would have protected me. I don't get why Jaack would have protected . Day 1 was so short that no solid reads were likely formed. I believe Jaack was the nightkill choice, and the only thing that will change my mind is the scum telling me differently at some point.

Well I'm feeling better about you based on #368 now.

Too little information to really tell either way, I don't think there's much point in analyzing N1.

I didn't really care about this at the time, doubt I will now, but for thoroughness's sake, what's an Amished tell?

I believe I covered the Amished tell in-thread. I'll look and tell you if I didn't.

And yes, the lion's eyes are flashing.

I will say that during N1, I thought I was going to pressure Jaack first thing D2, as I didn't like the way he jumped onto the Ari wagon. Not really game-relevant as it ended up not mattering, just a fun fact.

In post 373, Leonshade wrote:I will say that during N1, I thought I was going to pressure Jaack first thing D2, as I didn't like the way he jumped onto the Ari wagon. Not really game-relevant as it ended up not mattering, just a fun fact.

Stop reading the game the exact same way as me! It's freaking me out.

That's why I don't think Jaack was the kill, as he was likely to come under some pressure.