Okay readslist time:
Town:
Keyser
Tyler
Dunn
xyzzy
zach
tool
Bins
JFSF
Floof
Robert
h_a
ira
:Scum
Keyser - Like most of Keyser's observations and questions. In fact, sometimes I'll read a post, note something down only to find that Keyser already said exactly what I was going to say.
Tyler - Tyler's basically been at the top of my townlist since the beginning. Most of his concerns seem well-founded.
Dunn - Feeling more and more confident that Dunn is town. His suspicion of me felt more like it was coming from town misunderstanding where I was coming from instead of scum trying to manipulate what I had said. Despite receiving a significant ammount of attention in the early game, I never felt as if Dunn was acting particularly survivalistic which gives him a couple of town points.
xyzzy - Has less content than I remembered, but the more recent stuff is pretty good. I do have a couple of questions for you that I'll plop at the end of the post where I like to put my questions.
zach - Annoying but mostly harmless. Seems like a possible mislynch target to look out for.
tool - Reread makes me feel a lot better here. Lingering scum feelings mostly gone. Like the questions in
316 in particular.
Bins - Like some of his observations, particularly
217 which highlights some of the many problems with ira. Still have some hesitance about his early behavior in relation to dunn, but still decently town
JFSF - Is very wrong about readlists, but nothing else about him strikes me as bad. Has been a bit abrasive, but that is a bit of a towntell for me. Not sure about
298 as I don't like h_a much at all, but Jake has a general town feeling about him
Floof - Has posted almost nothing, both in terms of quality and quantity. Calls me scum with minimal reasons, then flops over to h_a for even fewer reasons. Seems to think zach is town. That's about it. 4/9 posts have no game related content at all.
Robert - Like floof, he has little content. Still have the bad feels from his first post (I know, I know, let's not rehash this again). Seems kind of sheepy in the few posts he does have. Don't really like how he has 4 scum reads and only 1 town read in
331. Also don't like how he's mostly ignored all the hubbub about his slot from the early game when he wasn't here.
h_a - Do not like his reads in
281 like at all. Says he doesn't have enough content to judge me fully (?), but feels everyone on my wagon is scummy. Reads to me like someone who knows I'm town and wants to leave as many option open in terms of a future lynch on me. (Keyser saw a similar thing in
311) If he doesn't participate on hypothetical future wagon, then he can point back here and say 'told you so' while also not committing to a full town read on me. Also don't like how he doesn't give reads on ira, dunn, or keyser in that post. He did give a read on ira earlier so I can kind of understand leaving that one out, but leaving out dunn and keyser is weird, as neither are exactly inactive, and h_a had even interacted with dunn significantly before that. If one of {h_a, dunn, keyser} flips scum its probably worth going back and checking out the other two based on this post alone, even though I'm townreading the other two players here pretty hard.
ira - Still think this reeks of scum. Have not seen one town-looking post from ira.
That's most of my thoughts right now, but I have a few questions:
@xyzzy - It might be hidden in one of your longer posts and I just missed it, but what are your thoughts on h_a? And could you explain your zach-scum thinking a little more.
@floof - Tell me about tool and JFSF