Mini 1787: Peruvian Nightclub Mafia (Game End!)

[Jaack]

Last is Jaak - his eh why the hell not attitude really rubs me wrong. With so much time in the day there's no reason to give up his top scum reads and vote his 4th.

I've been pushe'd all three of my better scumreads. The game stagnated and I saw no traction, so I moved my vote to where it would be most useful.

When I pushed Robert you just told me to shut up because I was being stupid. For the sake of not allowing the game to fall into endless bickering, I stopped pushing there. I could go back to pushing robert, but you'll just yell at me, and it'll go nowhere.

I pushed xyzzy. I'm still pretty sure their scum. I would love to lynch them today, but all the people interested in this lynch would rather lynch someone else. That actually makes me feel that this is even more scummy, but everyone seems to be stuck on zakk and dunn.

No one seems to be talking about bins at all. Well I guess dunn brought up the rollfishing thing. I wasn't really seeing that, but I have other concerns with bins that I have already addressed.

Nothing I've been saying seems to be swaying people much. I've kind of come to terms that that's how it's gonna be right now. Floof/zakk is definitely not my preferred lynch, but I'd rather rather that be the lynch than dunn, who is not reading scum to me at all.

If you wanna actually discuss someone aside from zakk or dunn, I'm more than willing, but that's all anyone seems to care about.

[Robert2424]

You can Chime in on Zach, Jaack. I'd actually be more comfortable with a Zach lynch then Zakk lynch. If your still reading my posts that is.

[Bins]

Bins who is mafia

I don't think zakk is


And if he is replacing out like that as scum it's pretty much rule breaking

[Bins]

/ :

If scum the replace out was only for town points and that's wrong

[Bins]

Sry on mobile tired sleeping now pls don't lynch

[Jaack]

You can Chime in on Zach, Jaack. I'd actually be more comfortable with a Zach lynch then Zakk lynch. If your still reading my posts that is.

Zach is probably town. I don't exactly see some larger plan in what he's doing--he seems to base everything on whims and gut, which doesn't read as scummy to me at all.

I also think its worth noting that HA only really pushed a Zach lynch even after being counterclaimed by ira. My gut reaction is that he wouldn't be so blatant about lynching a scumbuddy, but I have no logic/evidence to back this up.

[Bins]

More often I've seen scum do it right before they are lynched, then I'm a sucker for being, oh, he just replaced in with a bad hand, got to give him time, and they turn up being scum. So, its going to rub me the wrong way. It may be nothing and he could be town, but he certainly isn't going to gain any points for trying to be replaced now.

Like I just straight up disagree w this



Ok to be fair zakk did yell at us for scum reading him b4 he even got his role pm lets just say he isn't the best model player
But still replace outs like that should b illegal :/

[Tyler the Creator]

im bored

unvote
vote:xyzzy

[Robert2424]

I'm opinion is based upon my passed experience. Your Experience may be different.

I don't think he should be able to replace out at l-1 either, but its the mod's decision, not ours.

[Tyler the Creator]

And if he is replacing out like that as scum it's pretty much rule breaking

no it isn't?

[Tyler the Creator]

it's cowardly and bad sportsmanship for sure
but those things are both alignment neutral

[Bins]

And if he is replacing out like that as scum it's pretty much rule breaking

no it isn't?

Yes it is

L-1 replace outs like that are generally regarded as town
Any replace out that isnt related to commitment problems / personal problems w some asshole in the game are unfair imo

I think I've seen Zor or someone mod kill someone for it

[Robert2424]

tbh, emotions shouldn't be mixed into mafia too much. everybody playing to win. At least you should be, but that dosen't prevent people from letting there emotions get involved. zakk isn't the only one guilty of letting there emotions get too involved. I seen posts this game that I didn't find appropriate to any mafia game, but I've let them slide for now.

It DEFINITELY don't make him town bins. Why you defending him like that?

[Bins]

brb replacing out cause this is stupid

Is something we can speculate allignment from and is therefore unfair


It's unsportsmanlike and horrible from scum
There most people think "only town would do that because they're being genuinely frustrated"

[Tyler the Creator]

why are you talking about "most people"

what is your opinion on his replace out?

[Bins]

I'm not saying at all that it definitely makes him town

Tbh it's more that I can't respect a player who does that as scum and I like assuming people aren't awful sports

I don't think that zakk was that emotional
Again here I'm trying to find motive behind a replace out
And I think that's a stupid position and unfair position to be in

[Tyler the Creator]

then just call it null, move on, wait for readable content from the replacement

in the meantime help me light some actual fire under xy's ass

[Bins]

:/

Like
Here I'll make it super clear what I'm trying to say

It's more that I hope he's town and just from experience I read a replace out like that as town
And from experience most people I see read replace outs like that as town


If zakk is MAFIA
I honestly believe the only reason for his replace out would be to gain town points



And that's why I think it's unlikely but also extremely unfair and shouldn't be allowed in a game

[Robert2424]

It more likely he asking for a replacement because he's about to be lynched. Witchis immature. If you play the game of mafia, your going to get lynched. Hell, I was lynched the very first time I played mafia.

That is so silly bins. I rather he be lynched now.

Vote zakk

[Jake from State Farm]

And if he is replacing out like that as scum it's pretty much rule breaking

no it isn't?

Yes it is

L-1 replace outs like that are generally regarded as town
Any replace out that isnt related to commitment problems / personal problems w some asshole in the game are unfair imo

I think I've seen Zor or someone mod kill someone for it

It's not rule breaking. It sucks but it's not violating any published rules.

[Bins]

Tyler what do u think of Zach
Esp in regards to H_A's posts about him?

[Jaack]

im bored

unvote
vote:xyzzy

This is a better choice that I can wholeheartedly endorse.
UNVOTE:
VOTE: xyzzy

[Bins]

Fuck



It's rule breaking cause I think it's similar to trust telling

[Robert2424]

L-1 again by the way

[Tyler the Creator]

you're also acting like there haven't been 2 slots that have posted content to go off of

and are just hyper magnifying one event and waffling all over it and if you think that his replace out looks town then im wondering why that's making you frustrated