Open 51 - Texas Justice Mafia - Over, before 515

[Tobiassen]

I've got a baaad feeling about this :/

[Tobiassen]

so sorry 'bout the 2 posts after each other,
but,

Can't we all live in peace?

[JDodge]

I don't like it here in Texas, to much macho bull crap,
lets kill no one the first round.
atleast 4-5 will die the first night anyway :p

Lynch the bastard and all shall kill

[Thin_Man]

so sorry 'bout the 2 posts after each other,
but,

Can't we all live in peace?

That's not the smartest idea. Regardless of what happens, there's going to a be a dumpload of killing tonight. Having one person and their alignment on the table before the shitstorm strikes me as fairly useful.

[Draux]

I have an idea.

Tobiassen
Draux

Jdodge
UltimaAvalon

Erg0
Oman

Flameaxe
Thin_Man

Aimee
Crub

VitaminR
isuquinndog

We go No Lynch today. Get the pairs in colour to shoot each other (if they can). This would most likely kill all Mafia, and leave the Town with three living people (assuming there are three Mafia), possibly two due to the Nightkill. Unless of course, one pair is made up of two Mafia, in which case the Town is screwed. Okay? =3

[JDodge]

No. I want this done with as few losses for the town as possible.

[Thin_Man]

I'm sure there's a very compelling reason why that doesn't work, despite the fact I am at present failing to think one.

(I mean, I know it plays the odds, but the odds are pretty hot regardless)

No. I want this done with as few losses for the town as possible.

what

[JDodge]

I'm sure there's a very compelling reason why that doesn't work, despite the fact I am at present failing to think one.

(I mean, I know it plays the odds, but the odds are pretty hot regardless)

No. I want this done with as few losses for the town as possible.

what

I want to win without killing too many people, as all "breaking strategies" could easily be screwed by paired scum or the lone person out (We need to lynch today).

[Thin_Man]

I'm sure there's a very compelling reason why that doesn't work, despite the fact I am at present failing to think one.

(I mean, I know it plays the odds, but the odds are pretty hot regardless)

No. I want this done with as few losses for the town as possible.

what

I want to win without killing too many people, as all "breaking strategies" could easily be screwed by paired scum or the lone person out (We need to lynch today).

But if we follow this plan, then we don't need to lynch a guy today, and I can't work out the odds for a normal 'go for who you think is scummiest' night, but I'd be surprised if the chances of us winning via that are better than the chances of two scum being in the same pair on that group. I think it's massively against the spirit of the game, but it looks to me like a very solid way to win.

[Tobiassen]

I have an idea.

Tobiassen
Draux

Jdodge
UltimaAvalon

Erg0
Oman

Flameaxe
Thin_Man

Aimee
Crub

VitaminR
isuquinndog

We go No Lynch today. Get the pairs in colour to shoot each other (if they can). This would most likely kill all Mafia, and leave the Town with three living people (assuming there are three Mafia), possibly two due to the Nightkill. Unless of course, one pair is made up of two Mafia, in which case the Town is screwed. Okay? =3

I'm soooo in for that!

[Flameaxe]

I'm sooooo against that, mainly for the reasons JD posted.

It seems very risky to me, personally. How do we know you didn't pair yourself up with your scumbuddy Tobi?

[Erg0]

I usually disagree with the spirit of "breaking" strategies, and this one's no different. It basically reduces this to a game of chance at best or an instant loss at worst (if Draux is scum). If we wanted the best result over, say, ten games then this would give it to us, but I'm only interested in winning

this

game.

Interesting that Draux paired himself with Tobiassen in his list, btw.

FoS: Tobaissen and isuquinndog

It's not time to push for a lynch yet.

[Oman]

No its not interesting. Everyone who says that that list is interesting loses.

The concept is interesting, the list is the player list from the OP.

[Erg0]

So it's not possible that Draux deliberately went with that order knowing that it was in his favour?

[Oman]

its is possible, but saying that its interesting (read: points to someones alignment) is an overreaction.

I do however approve of the list as it allows me to kill erg0

[Flameaxe]

Player list or no player list, I don't believe its a good play for this game. It's risky at best.

[Erg0]

Like you weren't going to do that anyway.

It probably is a coincidence, I just found it notable that writer of the list was paired up with the player with the largest bandwagon on them - a wagon that was steaming along until he posted the list and moved the conversation in another direction. It seems a little

too

perfect for things to work out like that, though, so I'll leave it in the realm of "interesting" rather than "suspicious" for now.

[Draux]

I'm sooooo against that, mainly for the reasons JD posted.

It seems very risky to me, personally. How do we know you didn't pair yourself up with your scumbuddy Tobi?

If you're so sure about that, why don't you hammer him? =D

My Vote on Tobiassen stands. I'm not expecting everybody, if anybody to agree with my plan. Such a situation requires that every single person co-operates, and that's virtually impossible. I was just interested to see what reactions people would have about it. One more thing, I didn't write the list. It's the list from the Mod's first post.

[Draux]

Oh wait, he only has 5. My mistake.

[Draux]

I MEANT 4.

SHUT UP. UNVOTES ARE INVISIBLE TO ME. =(

[FeRnAnDo]

Vote count:

4 Tobiassen - (VitaminR, JDodge, Draux, UltimaAvalon)

3 UltimaAvalon - (Oman,Tobiassen, Flameaxe)
2 Oman - (Erg0, Crub)

1 JDodge - (Thin_Man)

Not Voting: Aimee and isuquinndog.

Activity Check PMs sent to Aimee and VitaminR.

[Aimee]

Still here.

After a few kills, Draux's list will be interesting.

I am, however, noting how Draux put himself with tobiassen, who is completely for the plan.

[UltimaAvalon]

All Aboard the Fail-Bus. Next Stop: Draux's plan

[Flameaxe]

Better yet...All aboard the Failboat!

[JDodge]

Still here.

After a few kills, Draux's list will be interesting.

I am, however, noting how Draux put himself with tobiassen, who is completely for the plan.

Read the player list in the first post

Read the pairs

See the similarity?