Mafiascum.net

Had to do it.

Ms Piggy wrote: unvote, vote somestrangeflea

Had to do it.

You hammered him without a claim. Just wow. I really hope you are not protown after that.

If SSF is protown and I'm dead overnight, obviously look heavily at Ms Piggy. I know it pretty much goes without saying.

*points Patrick at the rules.* No talking in twilight (mod, I hope this is ok).

Sorry, honest mistake. Most games permit it.

It was getting pretty cold, and everyone was feeling kind of irritable. So when turned up, and started singing about a blue sky on the hill, everyone quickly tired of it, and pushed him down the hill.

He rolled down, forming a massive snowball before sailing away down the valley.

Did I mention the snow was still vanilla?

It is now .

Day resumes in 72 hours.

Remember rule [15].

It's been brought to my attention that yellowbounder is currently MIA. If I haven't gotten him within 24 hours, I'll have you send your nightchoices to me, and I'll sub in for a while. Thanks!

yellowbounder has told me he has a backup mod who can step in and has nightchoices ready and processed, but hasn't sent them to me. I'll take over in case he doesn't come back. Thanks!

Day 2 breaks, revealing the tragic death of Mert.



With 10 alive, it takes 6 to lynch.

Go town!

Meh. I hardly remember anything from this. I do remember a pretty scummy looking hammer by Ms Piggy. Ms Piggy, explain why you felt the need to hammer him, when certain people were still talking to him and he hadn't claimed.

, who is being replaced?

Patrick wrote:

Mod

, who is being replaced?

Ms Piggy.

Hi.

my thoughts as I read through the thread:

On reading the setup, I would say obviously the mafia will pick roleblocker and doc. No way they choose cop.

Mert seems pro town, calling for a claim that early seems bold for scum. Oh wait he died so this is right. Patricks vote on him for it being too early seems a bit like an obvious town post ie slightly scummy.

xyzzy play seems poor so far (at post 77 here)

I can see why ssf got lynched I think (thinking of post 90 here)

oh and post 95.

Jdodge vote on ssf seems legit, shanba's I don't like. From the wording.

Don't like patricks post 100. avoiding the ssf wagon, wishy washy wording there.

Rishi's post 103 is a townie type post.

Don't like schismatized post 110 with vote for mert.

dylan is lurking?

not liking mneme's vote on ssf, from the wording. i.e. jdodge is very eager in his pursuit of ssf, but scum who know ssf is townie get a little antsy about lynching someone on page 6.

dylan is scummy, asking if it's ok to switch to ssf. schismatized points this out, townie points for schismatized.

Whoops, looks like my predecessor hammered without a claim. This is something I've been guilty of too as townie though not usually in a mini. Patrick is making too big a deal about it.


hmmm

For further explanation, dylan's play looks a lot like "newbie playing scum doesn't want to mess up and become suspect".

My biggest problem with day 1 being cut short like that is that we didn't get enough substantial bandwagons for my liking. I'm willing to give Jack a little leeway: Ms Piggy was a noob, and noobs do stupid things occasionally. Still worht keeping an eye on him though.

OTOH, I completely agree with his assessment of dylan (not so much with his assessment of mneme, or Patrick, or, well, me). The whole incident where he asks whether he should vote somestrangeflea or not seems so scummy.

I also dislike the way Rishi attacked a whole bunch of people without ever voting them. It did seem a bit like throwing things out and seeing what would stick. If SSF had come up scum I would be voting him now, as he often seemed to be looking for an alternative bandwagon while keeping his vote on SSF. But that's moot now.

Uh. I forgote.

Bah.

Go my team!

I'll have to reread the game before I have much of a clue, but I'll answer a couple of points for Jack now:

Jack wrote:Mert seems pro town, calling for a claim that early seems bold for scum. Oh wait he died so this is right. Patricks vote on him for it being too early seems a bit like an obvious town post ie slightly scummy.

I voted him because it seemed pretty much the only scummy thing that had happened. Xyzy's play was bad and annoying but not really scummy. As well as attacking Mert, I did want to make it clear xyzzy shouldn't claim. I don't see how you can say it was the obvious town post to make, as far as I remember nobody else mentioned it until I did, even though some posted before me.

Jack wrote:Whoops, looks like my predecessor hammered without a claim. This is something I've been guilty of too as townie though not usually in a mini. Patrick is making too big a deal about it.

I guess I didn't necessarily have to FoS her for it yesterday, as it was obvious. I don't see how I'm making too big a deal out of it; I haven't even FoSed her or voted her today, I just asked for her to explain what was going through her brain, which unfortunately won't happen now. It's easy for you to just say, "Oh it was obviously a noob mistake". Obviously the whole reason I pointed it out was because I thought it would be slightly more likely coming from noobscum than noobtown. Not going to lynch you over that but I see no reason to just ignore it. =

Need to do a re-read, which is tough to do while at Gen Con. But I will try and make the time. Don't expect anything super-useful before Sunday or Monday though.

This is a fairly dry game. Shanba is acting similarly to when I played with him last, where he was scum, but with everyone being equally lazy it probably doesn't say much.

Dylan's post number 5 looks scummy and insincere especially when I look at his/her next post about 40 minutes later.

I also don't like HH here, I don't like the manner in which he pushed the xyzzy wagon forward, and I don't like that he FoSed Mert for votehopping when Ms Piggy was votehopping more at the time. I don't see anything particularly wrong with Rishi. I think dylan, mneme and xyzzy all need to post more content.

dylan41985 wrote:I'm not asking anyone's permission schismatized.

unvote, vote: somestrangeflea

Why did you have to prove that you werent asking for anyones permission. You also said earlier that you didnt want a faster lynch...

Can we get a prod on Dylan?

I want to check on dylans other games. Has anyone played with him before?