Open 32 - Pick Your Poison Mafia (Game Over!), before 470

[Patrick]

I haven't played with dylan before. I did mod the open setup Roleblocker C9, where dylan was the roleblocker and got lynched on day 1, although I didn't actually read the game while modding it, because it was so boring. I might do that now though.

[Thesp]

Day 2 Vote Count

Dylan

- 3 (Jack, Shanba, Patrick)

Not Voting

- 7 (Jdodge, Honary Hitchhiker, schismatized, mneme, xyzzy, Rishi, dylan41985)

With 10 alive, it's 6 to lynch.

[Jack]

unvote

I don't think the evidence is so strong on dylan after all, I did some reading.

in mini 469: he hammered without giving reason and unvoted in next post. Turned up town. generally lurks and posts little comment

vote:shanba

[Shanba]

Patty, in response to the claim that I'm playing how I played last time when I was scum I would reply that this game I simply forgot about and didn't post at all in whereas the other one I was lurking proper.

Jack, are you seriously voting me because of the wording of one of my posts? I stand by what I said here, the wagon did need more support.

I checked 469 and I don't agree with you, tbh. The big part of the case against him is the way he asked for permission then denied it, which is not similar to the way he played in 469.

[xyzzy]

For further explanation, dylan's play looks a lot like "newbie playing scum doesn't want to mess up and become suspect".

This is a very accurate analysis.

Vote: dylan

[Shanba]

/bump from page 2

Xyzzy, do you realise he has turned against his own analysis there?

[Jack]

I don't think it's so clearcut as the wagon on him implies, and I don't like the way my next two suspects jumped right on. I want to hear from dylan.

[Patrick]

I don't think it's so clearcut as the wagon on him implies, and I don't like the way my next two suspects jumped right on. I want to hear from dylan.

I read dylans posts in newbie 387 where he was town and got lynched day 1. The majority of those posts were a close variation of, "I'm a townie, don't lynch me!!". The amount of content he posted in that game is similar to this one, so that doesn't mean much for his alignment, but he seems more self conscious in this game, in posts 5-6.

I certainly don't think it's clearcut at all, and if dylan comes close to being lynched, I'll unvote, heck I might change my vote anyway soon. About half the players were able to cruise through day 1 without doing anything at all, and xyzzy was one of them. Today all he's done is voted dylan without any kind of analysis or content at all. So yes, we're certainly not going through today with only a focus on one person.

I think your suspicions of my day 1 play are poor, or at best poorly explained.

[xyzzy]

/bump from page 2

Xyzzy, do you realise he has turned against his own analysis there?

Yes; I agree with the analysis; not with the switching off of it.

[Rishi]

I would like to hear from dylan about this game.

As for Patrick, no one mentioned his post in twilight. I never like posts in twilight and it's awfully convenient to criticize someone for dropping the hammer. Yes, the hammer was way too fast, but there was no need to point it out. I dunno...

[Thesp]

Day 2 Vote Count

Dylan

- 3 (Shanba, Patrick, xyzzy)

Shanba

- 1 (Jack)

Not Voting

- 6 (Jdodge, Honary Hitchhiker, schismatized, mneme, Rishi, dylan41985)

With 10 alive, it's 6 to lynch. If you'd like anyone prodded, please let me know in bold. Thanks!

[Patrick]

As for Patrick, no one mentioned his post in twilight. I never like posts in twilight and it's awfully convenient to criticize someone for dropping the hammer. Yes, the hammer was way too fast, but there was no need to point it out. I dunno...

So... you're saying that the hammer was indeed way too fast, whilst critisising me for pointing it out. Ok. What difference does it make that it was in twilight?

[Rishi]

So... you're saying that the hammer was indeed way too fast, whilst critisising me for pointing it out. Ok. What difference does it make that it was in twilight?

It makes a difference that it was in twilight because we didn't know the result yet. Only Mafia would have known for sure that somestrangeflea was a townie.

[Patrick]

I didn't know anything for sure. I said that if SSF was town, the hammer was suspicious. Even if SSF had been scum, the hammer would have been suspicious to some extent.

[Rishi]

Fair enough. I think dylan is more suspicious than you are anyway, so I'm waiting to hear from him.

[mneme]

I'm curious as to what Dylan has to say here.

[Rishi]

*bump*

Prods on dylan and HH, please?

[Rishi]

Oh, and JDodge too.

[Jack]

unvote,vote:mneme

lurking while trying to make it appear otherwise.

[mneme]

Jack: huh? Mostly, I'm waiting for there to be a game here.

[JDodge]

I am waiting for dylan/dylan's replacement.

[Shanba]

btw, I recently had to replace Honary Hitchiker in my game so he'll probably need replacing here too.

[Thesp]

Prodding Honary Hitchhiker, schismatized, xyzzy, dylan41985. Will replace people based on longest since last post.

[Thesp]

Thin Man replaces Honary Hitchhiker, effective imediately. Thanks!

[Thin_Man]

vote mneme