Mafia 64: The New "C9" - Game over!

[The Central Scrutinizer]

Only average!

I'll show you average:

vote:Albert

[Glork]

Only average!

I'll show you average:

vote:Albert

This man is very obviously pro-town.

[MrBuddyLee]

Glork's hyper-protection of Guardian noted.

Guardian, my vote on you would be OMGUS if there wasn't a solid reason behind it. Solid, at least, for page 2.

[Glork]

Glork's hyper-protection of Guardian noted.

You're cute when you do this.

[Glork]

Mod: When exactly did Battle Mage replace DanMonkey in this game?

[beanbagboy]

Wow. Sorry if I seem inactive, the pool just opened. ^^.

Hey... I made a question that someone needs to answer! I feel special! ^^

The night kill thing is stupid, agreed. Any kill that scum makes is a good kill. Killing off strong townies is better. The fact that they didn't kill Glork doesn't mean anything. Again, we don't know what happened last night.

Yeah, BM, come on. Random voting = jokey. IMGMEOY (lol I stole this one from bob: I maybe got my eye on you.)

[~N9V~]

Hey all. I really didn't like ABR's reasonfor voting johhan.

Vote ABR

[LoudmouthLee]

Mod: When exactly did Battle Mage replace DanMonkey in this game?

Prior to day 1.

~Vote Count~

Albert B. Rampage – 5 – HackerHuck, Johhan, Jack, The Central Scrutinizer, ~N9V~

Johhan – 2 – Albert B. Rampage, Nik Zero
MBL – 2 – Glork, Guardian
Guardian – 2- MrBuddyLee, Battle Mage
Jack – 1 – beanbagboy

With 18 alive, it takes 10 to lynch!

Not Voting – 6 – Billy Twilight, Coron, Haut Boy, HungryJoe, Shteven, Yogurt Bandit

Please remember, this game is a fun game! No personal attacks…

[Albert B. Rampage]

Only average!

I'll show you average:

vote:Albert

lol sorry

I was being generous

[HackerHuck]

I think SV was picked so that we would have someone to replace back in later on down the road.

The night kill thing is stupid, agreed.

Any kill that scum makes is a good kill. Killing off strong townies is better.

The fact that they didn't kill Glork doesn't mean anything. Again, we don't know what happened last night.

Yeah, BM, come on. Random voting = jokey. IMGMEOY (lol I stole this one from bob: I maybe got my eye on you.)

Are you some kind of scum cheerleader or are you just scum yourself?

[Shteven]

Shteven's noob summary #1:

Guardian is definately in love with glork and this is kind of scummy.
BM is way too concerned about guardian for day one.
TCS's voting for albert for calling him average is an absolutely perfect reason to vote for someone on day 1.

Remember, I have no idea what's going on.

I just laughed when I saw point #3, so I'm tossing out a mostly random vote to help him out:

Vote: Albert

[Battle Mage]

i got the pm at the start of the day. so, no-if you are wondering, i wasnt here for last night

Post 59 made me ROFL.

Mod: When exactly did Battle Mage replace DanMonkey in this game?

[Battle Mage]

dont change what he said Glork. he said he expected you to play well here as town. i dont know why you are defending him, when his obvious intention was to set you up for a lynch tomorrow.
trying to get him off the hook on semantics is a poor show...

You're kidding, right? You mean you think that Guardian actually believes that I am the perfect mafia player and that I know all of the scums' identities without everyone even having posted yet? You think that language like "I demanded that he find all five scum" and "Tsk tsk Glork" is "far from a joke"?




Please stop talking, BM. You're just making yourself look like a fool.

[Glork]

1)

MOST

players who are somewhat familiar with me expect me to play reasonably well as town. It's something that I'm used to and I can tell you that it doesn't mean a damned thing
2) If Guardian had

actually

pursued a lynch on me for not finding scum,

then

we would know that he was not joking and that he was scummy.
3) It does not change the words that Guardian said, but it changes the

meaning

or

significance

of what he said. If I said "HAY GUYZ, I AM SCUM!!!!" it would be obvious that I was

joking

. Thus, while I would still have said that I was scum, the fact that

I was not being serious about claiming scum means that the statement holds no weight whatsoever

.

Unvote, Vote: Battle Mage

[beanbagboy]

@HackerHuck: Er... no. That was from an objective point of view, I'm saying that to an extent they don't care who they kill as long as they kill SOMEone and that person is a reasonable threat to the town, so JDodge and SV getting killed tells us, like Glork said, nothing. I was saying what their intentions would be going into the first night.

Glork, I don't think BM is scum. Granted, he is acting very stupid, but metagame wise he's like this in other games I'm in with him. (Well, we're both still alive, so it is possible, but still.)

I do that all the time, saying I'm scum (as a joke.) Sometimes I'm not lying when I say it, though.

[BillyTwilight]

Hey, guys, sorry for the late start, I was out of town this weekend.

Vote: BattleMage

. Something about post #16 bothers me. It sorta says "I

can't

be scum, I just got into the game right now!" which I think is pretty preemptive. His attack of Guardian for joking on page 2 could just be bad BM play. But all in all, it's enough to warrant a vote, for now.

[Battle Mage]

the difficulty with your play is that you always throw a poorly thought out vote on me at the start of a game, and i find it hard to work out whether you are scum or town as a result.
what i will say is that your logic is weak here. I mean, all i said in Post 16, was that people were discussing me, before i even knew i was replacing in. i guess the mod put me down on the roster before sending me the pm.
all in all, i hardly think you can criticise my relatively random vote, when you have made another on even less sturdy foundations.

@BBB-whilst i appreciate your sort of defence of me, id still like an explanation as to how i have "acted very stupid". I dont mind getting quicklynched, as most of the time it is scum who wagon me, which is par for the course. people who criticise my intelligence on the other hand, will be treated with disdain if they dont back up such comment with evidence.

@Glork-you are making no sense. Guardian made a comment that you were good at catching scum. you say this is TRUE, yet you also say he was JOKING. Please can you make your mind up about what defence you are going for here?

BM

Hey, guys, sorry for the late start, I was out of town this weekend.

Vote: BattleMage

. Something about post #16 bothers me. It sorta says "I

can't

be scum, I just got into the game right now!" which I think is pretty preemptive. His attack of Guardian for joking on page 2 could just be bad BM play. But all in all, it's enough to warrant a vote, for now.

[Guardian]

OK guys, first off I don't know why BM thinks I am scummy, buy I wasn't joking. I thought about this all day, and here is the plan. Glork voted MBL so we need to get off this stupid Albert wagon and all vote MBL. He will likely be scum, since Glork voted him. If he's not, then Glork is obvscum.

Any docs/cops out there, please target Glork n1 to make sure he is not scum and tricking us. This plan cannot fail. Thx.

ps: Glork find 4 more scum or u die.

But apparently that post would have been taken seriously. Lol. Thanks for the laughs .



In seriousness, what has Albert done to deserve such a wagon? Are 6 player wagons normal for this size of a game? I am of the opinion that wagons are inherently good to get discussion going, but am reluctant to put Albert at -2 so early.

MBL, it's odd that you are taking me seriously, but I am more suspicious of BM for the extent and furvor with which he has attacked me for an (imo) obvious joke.

unvote vote: BM

seems appropriate.

[Glork]

@Glork-you are making no sense. Guardian made a comment that you were good at catching scum. you say this is TRUE, yet you also say he was JOKING. Please can you make your mind up about what defence you are going for here?

He isn't joking about me being a capable scumhunter. He's joking about the "if he doesn't find us all of the scums, he is probably scum himself" comment.

[Haut Boy]

@Glork-you are making no sense. Guardian made a comment that you were good at catching scum. you say this is TRUE, yet you also say he was JOKING. Please can you make your mind up about what defence you are going for here?

Perhaps you didn't actually catch it when you read that post again, or maybe you did and you're just twisting Glork's words around.

I'll say that after I *gasp* went to bed and looked at this game again fter I got up, the humor was much more apparent, so I let it go. BM, though...well, I'll let my action summarize my thoughts.

Vote: BM

[beanbagboy]

@BM: Sure. You're twisting his words, as Haut boy just said, yes, he said it's TRUE that he's good at hunting scum, but Guardian was JOKING that he gets all the scum, all the time. I don't see how that's contradictory.

(More later, I'm busy...)

Also, Glork not getting all the scum, at least from what I've heard, is a sign that he's protown, as he usually seriously busses his scum buddies. (This is just what I've heard, I don't think I've ever played with Glork before.)

[YogurtBandit]

Hey all, I was gone most of Today and Yesterday, but I'll read over the posts..

[beanbagboy]

HI! *flaps hands frantically in Yogurt's direction* LOL

[HungryJoe]

Well, BM, I hate to be harsh on you in both games, but you're kind of bringing it upon yourself here.

dont change what he said Glork. he said he expected you to play well here as town. i dont know why you are defending him, when his obvious intention was to set you up for a lynch tomorrow.
trying to get him off the hook on semantics is a poor show... Rolling Eyes

I think you're trying to take this joke way too seriously to be a pleasant vanilla townie here. I think it might behoove you to make a defense here, rather than attack, so that I might have a reason to take this off you...

Vote : BM

[HungryJoe]

Bleh. I'm feeling wierd and that last bit doesn't make sense to me anymore. What I mean is: Defend yourself solidly, and I will rethink my vote on you if you are logical and persuasive. =b