Mini 447 -Game Over

[Relph]

I just got in quickly to report and

Vote: thethirdnail

[Arkest]

Vote: Y.C

For not posting on page 1. I don't care if it's a weekend!

[thethirdnail]

vote: ryan

[ryan]

Mod: Vote Count please

[pickemgenius]

hey thirdnail, you have to bold that vote for it to count.

I'll presume that's random aswell?

[Arkest]

Mod didn't specify votes have to be

bold

actually. It's a good habit to get into though, since many mods do require it.

And it's pretty obvious thethirdnail is just trying to bandwagon ryan. So,

Vote: thethirdnail

[blahgo]

pickmegenius:1 Blue Zebra,
Arkest:0
Poison Ivy:1 ryan
Blue Zebra:1 SpinWizard
thethirdnail:2 Relph, Arkest
Y.C: 0




Note:

Mod: Vote Count please

Ryan has been modkilled for breaking Rule 9:

Ryan was a Townie. Deal with it.

[pickemgenius]

Well, I'll be danged.

Vote: thethirdrail

Let's hope some discussion comes from this.

[ryan]

pickmegenius:1 Blue Zebra,
Arkest:0
Poison Ivy:1 ryan
Blue Zebra:1 SpinWizard
thethirdnail:2 Relph, Arkest
Y.C: 0




Note:

Mod: Vote Count please

Ryan has been modkilled for breaking Rule 9:

Ryan was a Townie. Deal with it.

WOW. Thanks for a warning, I appreciate it. Good luck townies.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Welp,

Unvote ryan

, I guess.

[Haschel Cedricson]

Okay, so myself, pickemgenius, and thethirdnail all voted for a now-confirmed townie. One of us is probably Mafia. I'm going to

Vote: thethirdnail

for bandwagoning without offering explaination.

[Arkest]

unvote

[Arkest]

Wow, thirdrail has only posted 2 words, putting him at lynch -1 on page 2 is a bit crazy.

Vote: Haschel Cedricson

FoS: pickemgenius

[pickemgenius]

Okay, so myself, pickemgenius, and thethirdnail all voted for a now-confirmed townie. One of us is probably Mafia. I'm going to Vote: thethirdnail for bandwagoning without offering explaination.

(Borat style)whoa whoa whoa whoa(end)


Hold up. He's got 4 now ( I think) and you got on the thirdrail for bandwagoning without explanation, is there an explanation you have besides

One of us is probably Mafia.

which screams WIFOM by the way. Also how were

any

of us supposed to know he was a townie, when we were still in random voting stage (hope we get out of it with this.)


Ewww....

Vote: Haschel Cedricson

[thethirdnail]

Haschel, myself, and pickem voted for ryan. I don't believe it's

good

logic to presume one of those who voted for ryan (a confirmed townie) is a definite mafia. When I voted, I had one vote against me and chose to vote for someone who already had a vote to increase my chances of survival. However, I do think a mafia member would use the same reasoning to vote for ryan knowing he was a townie.

Having said that, there is nothing I can do to convince anyone which of these motives I used to make my vote. I will say that after I am lynched (I am the most likely candidate at this point) and you find out I was a townie, heavy suspicion should fall on those who voted for me immediately after ryan was modkilled (pickem and haschel). Both could be understood to be using the reason a mafia member would vote for Ryan, which I explained above.

And I will thank Arkest for rethinking his logic about me "obviously bandwagoning."

Vote: Pickemgenius

[Haschel Cedricson]

Wow, thirdrail has only posted 2 words, putting him at lynch -1 on page 2 is a bit crazy.

Wait, I counted lynch -2. Who else voted

Also how were any of us supposed to know he was a townie, when we were still in random voting stage (hope we get out of it with this.)

Most of us weren't to know. But the Mafia WOULD know that ryan was not one of them.

Look, I know what my role is, and it's not Mafia. I think that either pickemgenius or thethirdrail is scum, and I'm not sure which. I chose thethirdrail because he appeared to be more suspicious.

[thethirdnail]

I agree with Haschel thus far, and his logic for choosing me follows.

[pickemgenius]

Haschel, myself, and pickem voted for ryan. I don't believe it's

good

logic to presume one of those who voted for ryan (a confirmed townie) is a definite mafia.

When I voted, I had one vote against me and chose to vote for someone who already had a vote to increase my chances of survival.

However, I do think a mafia member would use the same reasoning to vote for ryan knowing he was a townie.

explain the bolded part please....

Having said that, there is nothing I can do to convince anyone which of these motives I used to make my vote.

I will say that after I am lynched (I am the most likely candidate at this point) and you find out I was a townie

,

heavy suspicion should fall on those who voted for me immediately after ryan was modkilled (pickem and haschel).

Both could be understood to be using the reason a mafia member would vote for Ryan, which I explained above.

Umm what (in reference to underlined part)???


My vote was to spar discussion, and HC came in, gave no reasoning to put you at L-1, and my vote is on him now, and we've got discussion.

[thethirdnail]

For my reference if no one else's...

SpinWizard: Blue Zebra
Y.C: NO VOTE
Blue Zebra: pickemgenius
Relph: thethirdnail
thethirdnail: pickemgenius
Poison Ivy: NO VOTE
Haschel Cedricson: thethirdnail
pickemgenius: Haschel Cedricson
Arkest: Haschel Cedricson

[thethirdnail]

sorry if that is confusing, i'll attempt to rephrase.

My original motive for voting for ryan was to increase my chances of not being lynched. I did not want to random vote. I had one vote against me. I chose to vote for someone who had a vote against him, thus making it ryan -2, me -1...I have less votes, I get to keep playing.

I said that I was the most likely candidate to be lynched because:
I had the most votes against me at the time.
Any mafia member could add to the vote and kill a townie during the day.
Any townie had reason to suspect me via Hachel's logic.


Is this clearer?

[pickemgenius]

My original motive for voting for ryan was to increase my chances of not being lynched

.

I did not want to random vote

.

I had one vote against me.

I chose to vote for someone who had a vote against him

, thus making it ryan -2, me -1...

I have less votes, I get to keep playing

.

Underlined-Explain how voting decreases your chances of being lynched?
Italics-Also, one vote on you isn't close to being lynched.
You need to be worried about finding scum, not staying alive, sucm worry about staying alive.
Bolded- Why?

vote: ryan

dude it can't be much more random then that.

I said that I was the most likely candidate to be lynched because:
I had the most votes against me at the time.
Any mafia member could add to the vote and kill a townie during the day.
Any townie had reason to suspect me via Hachel's logic.

You just said you had one.
True

[pickemgenius]

EBWOP: The Italics should start with the top line, the underline is the quote about your vote.

[Arkest]

Wait, I counted lynch -2. Who else voted

With 9 left, it's only 5 to lynch now.

[Arkest]

And I will thank Arkest for rethinking his logic about me "obviously bandwagoning."

I was partly joking and partly needling you for giving

no word of explanation whatsoever

for your vote. But this:

When I voted, I had one vote against me and

chose to vote for someone who already had a vote

to increase my chances of survival.

is pretty much the definition of bandwagoning.

I had the most votes against me at the time.

You had

one

random vote on you. That's hardly cause for concern, and I don't know about

your

role, but townies don't need to survive to win this game. Your only concern should be lynching scum, getting another townie lynched to save yourself does not help at all.

I agree with Haschel thus far, and his logic for choosing me follows.

You agree with Haschel voting for you??? Is this some scum free-for-all busing strategy?

FoS: thethirdnail

pickem, why did you put the third vote on thirdrail anyway? Seems odd you are complaining about the bandwagon when you were right in the middle of it.

Man, this game went from 0 to crazy in 2 pages, we haven't even heard from two players yet.

[pickemgenius]

Well, I'll be danged.

Vote: thethirdrail

Let's hope some discussion comes from this.

I wanted discussion, which has come, and at that time ryan was still in the game, my third vote was only half of what was needed for a lynch.

Seems odd you are complaining about the bandwagon when you were right in the middle of it.

I may be tired crapless, but I don't get where i'm complaining about the bandwagons.