433: Dry, bland, generic mafia: Game Over

[creampuffeater]

BAH!

[Off the Mark]

D'oh!!! I knew PJ's long posts were smokescreens, but of course I was helpless to do anything about it. Very nice job, PJ, especially considering you replaced in.

Also sorry to gorckat... I also was really convinced you were scum. In my defense, you

were

voting along with a mafioso and an SK, against a townie, so you can understand... Anyway, if pete d intentionally setup the connection between himself and gorckat back on day 2... dang, that was smooth. Because either way, it would screw us up. If we

had

changed from lynching SSF to lynching gorckat, all hell would have broken loose. SSF or myself would have certainly been lynched and town would be done for.

I would really like to know how scum knew Dasq was the SK. And, for that matter, how Dasq knew to kill Pete D, rather than gorckat.

[Thestatusquo]

Pie has been lynched. He was

Scum

town.

SCUM WINS!

[Simenon]

Was this setup reviewed?

[Thestatusquo]

By thok, meme, and Kellychen. What exactly are you implying?

[Simenon]

R@G was mountainous with an sk, and ended with a town win.

This also has a gunsmith, a watcher, a doctor, and a one-shot vig.

I'd love to see what kelly's comments were.

[Simenon]

Or am I missing something, which is likely.

[somestrangeflea]

This thread needs more Nightchoice list...

[pete d]

mafia killed IH and dasq, kilm presumably killed MBL, so dasq killed fonz and I

Anyway, if pete d intentionally setup the connection between himself and gorckat back on day 2... dang, that was smooth.

It wasn't really like that at the start of day 2, I was just waiting to see which way things went. I realised the situation a few days before OtM drew the connection iirc. All the power roles taken out on night 1 was pretty sweet.

[pete d]

btw thanks to the mod and all the replacements

[Dasquian]

Good game! Thanks TSQ, I enjoyed it (although I did get stressed out on D2).

I killed Fonz N1 because he was asking awkward questions and looked like he was about to lay into me D2, but by the end of D1 hadn't actually done so yet so I took the opportunity to off him. I also thought he was a good scum/cop candidate.

I killed pete d N2 because he was a much better candidate for scum than gorckat who I genuinely believed to be town. My choice would've been very different if ssf had turned up as scum, which I really expected to see!

I was genuinely scum-hunting for the majority of this game; I wanted to get to an end-game where I was in control (I had a one-shot night protection too, but

someone

forgot to apply it *stares* ). OTM really got me riled on D2, and I'm sure that contributed to me standing out as a potential SK... I was on the verge of claiming just to rub it in his face that he was wrong. This is meant as a compliment; as SK scum my job was to remain cool and not a mafia target.

It's a shame this game had so many replacements/flakes/etc. It made it very difficult to follow. Is this a common theme of games on this site? I like the volume and variety of games here and the experience of people playing them, but it seems like no game gets through to even day 2 without about three people bailing out.

[gorckat]

Good game.

OTM and pie- I could have played better and avoided all your suspicions, so no apologies needed

@pie- you mentioned some tell you thought I was making? What was it?

[IH]

= \

[Thestatusquo]

I also made one mistake this game which I will post when I post all the night choices around 9 tonight.

[pete d]

I also made one mistake this game which I will post when I post all the night choices around 9 tonight.

I had a one-shot night protection too, but someone forgot to apply it

o_O
So dasq... who would you have taken out n3? pie, PJ or OtM? (presuming gorckat would have still gotten lynched...)

[Thestatusquo]

I also made one mistake this game which I will post when I post all the night choices around 9 tonight.

I had a one-shot night protection too, but someone forgot to apply it

o_O
So dasq... who would you have taken out n3? pie, PJ or OtM? (presuming gorckat would have still gotten lynched...)

Yeah, that was it. He PMed me the next day, and was a very good sport about it, but I felt like a total tool.

[Dasquian]

I think my days would've been numbered anyway, the mafia would know who I was and either kill me the next night or contribute to getting me lynched

It's hard to say who I would've NKed next. As soon as pete d showed up scum, I guessed (assuming a three-person scum party) that gorckat and OTM were the remaining scum. I would almost certainly have been eating humble pie and helping lynch gorckat, and then I would probably have thought OTM was the villain of the piece and NKed him.

The irony is that earlier on, from even a few pages in, I had Eletriar pegged as probable scum, and thought Nanook looked hella scummy too when he replaced in - I should've trusted my gut more.

[somestrangeflea]

Who did the Watcher attempt to watch, who did the Gunsmith attempt to smith, and who did the Doc attempt to Doc N1?

[Off the Mark]

I think my days would've been numbered anyway, the mafia would know who I was and either kill me the next night or contribute to getting me lynched

It's hard to say who I would've NKed next. As soon as pete d showed up scum, I guessed (assuming a three-person scum party) that gorckat and OTM were the remaining scum. I would almost certainly have been eating humble pie and helping lynch gorckat, and then I would probably have thought OTM was the villain of the piece and NKed him.

The irony is that earlier on, from even a few pages in, I had Eletriar pegged as probable scum, and thought Nanook looked hella scummy too when he replaced in - I should've trusted my gut more.

Man, that would have been fun to see how that worked out. My best guess: Pete D (scum) still dies, of course, then Day3 we lynch gorckat (town) and then Night3 Dasq NK's me (town) and PJ (scum) kills Dasq. So we end up in the exact same spot, right? Day 4 has PJ, Pie and CPE.

Interesante!

[somestrangeflea]

Who did the Watcher attempt to watch, who did the Gunsmith attempt to smith, and who did the Doc attempt to Doc N1?

Seriously, this interests me somewhat...

[MeMe]

last post