UPick

[Who]

flavour was good, role names were terrible

like the main reason I didn't suspect Who's role was because I figured the ambiguous role names balanced out the role cop brigade, I didn't think scum would have a hard counter like that

I agree with this, some of them were practically impossible to tell what they were from what the name was.

What even was the "French Miller"? I don't think it was in the posted list of role PMs.

[Empking]

flavour was good, role names were terrible

like the main reason I didn't suspect Who's role was because I figured the ambiguous role names balanced out the role cop brigade, I didn't think scum would have a hard counter like that

I agree with this, some of them were practically impossible to tell what they were from what the name was.

What even was the "French Miller"? I don't think it was in the posted list of role PMs.

The'French' part of 'French Miller' was simply that he had a scrap of info; he knew there were no third parties. It was like a French Vanilla, but instead if being Vanilla he was a miller

And I get Umbrage's point now.

[Umbrage]

it's an interesting setup, just needs a bit of tweaking

I do like the idea of giving town a lot of information roles, but keeping the information ambiguous. around midgame there was a balance between scumhunting and setup speculation that was really unusual and fun