Everyone is an SK Mafia! 2 (All Die, 2 Win)

[phokdapolees]

This would've been much more fun if nacho were actually here

[PokerFace]

Vote count copy and paste

Day 1 has ended.

pirate mollie has been lynched she was an

SK

Night 1 has ended.

clammy has died he was an

SK

Night 1 has ended.

syndromeofadown has died he was an

SK

Night 1 has ended.

N has died he was an

SK

Day 2 has ended.

Nachomamma8 has been lynched he was an

SK

Outcome is inevitable

Night 2 has ended.

phokdapolees has died he was an

SK

Night 2 has ended.

Who has died he was an

SK

As they are the last alive, the both of them win^

[Who]

This would've been much more fun if nacho were actually here

Yeah, it sorta would.

Last time AD wasn't there so we had a similar party at his house, except one person did show up. I think 3 said they would.

[clammy]

Awesome, thanks PokerFace.
Not mafia, but quite a lot of fun.

[Who]

Thanks for running this again PF, I like this setup.

Why did nobody want to form an alliance with me?

[phokdapolees]

Yeah, that was quite fun, gg everyone

[N]

Who shot who?

[Who]

Who shot who?

No, Who shot Syndromeofadown

[clammy]

Who shot who?

No, Who shot Syndromeofadown

Me

[PokerFace]

Awesome, thanks PokerFace.
Not mafia, but quite a lot of fun.

thanks

considering the win condition thing was explained at the begining of this, I think the first running was more so mafia than this one was

With the happily ever after ending explained at the start I very surprised things played out as they did. I was expecting a group circle kill organization on night 1 for a moment there. But instead of that or a party at nacho's there was a list of unexpected kills/betrayals? that kept things interesting

Night 1
Clammy, who, N all killed syndromeofadown
syndromeofadown killed N
phokdapolees killed clammy

[Who]

Awesome, thanks PokerFace.
Not mafia, but quite a lot of fun.

thanks

considering the win condition thing was explained at the begining of this, I think the first running was more so mafia than this one was

With the happily ever after ending explained at the start I very surprised things played out as they did. I was expecting a group circle kill organization on night 1 for a moment there. But instead of that or a party at nacho's there was a list of unexpected kills/betrayals? that kept things interesting

Night 1
Clammy, who, N all killed syndromeofadown
syndromeofadown killed N
phokdapolees killed clammy

The group circle-kill would have led to a mass-tie. If we're going to group circle-kill, what's the point in playing? I half-heartedly suggested it but didn't expect anyone else to agree and didn't really want to myself. I was expecting more alliances though.

[clammy]

no we just kill whoever we like the least on the playerlist

This was the winning post for me.

[N]

Pf, there is no way this is Mafia.

[clammy]

The group circle-kill would have led to a mass-tie. If we're going to group circle-kill, what's the point in playing? I half-heartedly suggested it but didn't expect anyone else to agree and didn't really want to myself. I was expecting more alliances though.

More alliances needed more players.

[PokerFace]

I also expected more alliances. Having so few made this not mafia. Having a hidden win condition would have kept some info secret and made this more so mafia, but ultimately this running definitely was not mafia

A new mechanic will be needed to make 3 interesting or perhaps 3 will just be the final Version of "Killing Spree" mafia. Regardless of what happens, i am sure it will be fun

Thanks guys for helping me run this game and my other games so far. Really glad i pulled off and another all scum/ all sk game since that has been viewed as mostly impossible

[PokerFace]

Pf, there is no way this is Mafia.

this running of the game, I agree with you 100%

first running of the game I think I can make a slight argument for it being mafia given what occcured there and if you think of the moderator as the informed minority who got to watch the fray (20% mafia give or take)

I will argue Bad Reveal Mafia 100% as Mafia as there was scum hunting in that game and more info was held back there than what was held back in either "Everyone is an SK Mafia"

[Jingle]

Wish I didn't have to work and would have been able to play. I think the BP idea leads to a lot of fakeclaiming shots to try and actually kill people, and makes the lynch more interesting. Hence, more mafia-y.

[Who]

A one-shot activated PGO might lead to interesting things.

[clammy]

I want another one of these - it was short, sweet and to the point.