Mini 256 - Peanuts mafia - Game over

[Pinky]

Vote Count:

LyingBrian - 8 (Snap , Quailman , elvis_knits , Dragon Phoenix , Sotty7, Mr Stoofer, mlaker )
Mr Stoofer - 1 (Iammars )
Pickle, Boy Wonder - 1 (Quidgyboo )
Quidgyboo - 1 (Pickle, Boy Wonder )

Not voting (2): d_rouge , LyingBrian

And LyingBrian - Lucy (traitor) is lynched!

Night choices due by the end of the week! 10pm GMT

[Pinky]

The town awaken to find that no-one has been killed during the night!
Keep posting and remember to elect a new mayor for the day!

[Quidgyboo]

I see no reason we should not

Vote Snap for Mayor

for today. Seem like an alright idea?

[elvis_knits]

Good idea.

Vote Snap for Mayor

[Mr Stoofer]

Vote: Snap for Mayor

[Dragon Phoenix]

Vote Snap for Mayor

[Pickle, Boy Wonder]

Well, I have decided not sure how stupid this is, that I should come out. I am Charlie Brown and I am the cop and Night 1 I got that DP was guilty, Night 2 I got that Quidgyboo was guilty. Doc please protect me!

Vote: Snap for Mayor

Hope it was the right thing to do but in a mini how many mafia can there be?

[elvis_knits]

Pickles are sexy.

I guess the only thing to do is consider your sanity, Pickle. To me, it doesn't seem likely for Charlie Brown to be insane. I mean, isn't he our hero? Seems like a good cop role.

It's possible that Snap can back you up, depending on who he roleblocked last night (as there was no kill). Then there would be no question of your sanity, and the doc could protect you while you find out who the remaining mafioso is. There's probably, three, right? And maybe an SK?

First we have to elect a mayor though.

[Iammars]

Vote: Snap for Mayor

and wow Pickle, that's some good results there, and unless they provide a bona fide reason not to lynch them, they're dead...

[Pickle, Boy Wonder]

My problem is that if I'm insane we know that they are innocent, If I'm paranoid then we dont know or they are scum.
Other than that I'd like to hear from the accused.
Maybe a claim and then any other counter claims?

[Pickle, Boy Wonder]

My problem is that if I'm insane we know that they are innocent, If I'm paranoid then we dont know or they are scum.
Other than that I'd like to hear from the accused.
Maybe a claim and then any other counter claims?

[Mr Stoofer]

My guess is that Pickle is paranoid. First, because a cop hitting scum 2 nights out of 2 is just too good to be true. Secondly, because I think Quidgyboo is innocent. Although I do think DP is probably scum.

[Dragon Phoenix]

Paranoid or insane, you take your choice.

[Sotty7]

Vote: Snap for Mayor

My guess is that Pickle is paranoid. First, because a cop hitting scum 2 nights out of 2 is just too good to be true.

That was my inital reaction to Pickle's claims too, but who's to say we can't get lucky every now and then?

Secondly, because I think Quidgyboo is innocent. Although I do think DP is probably scum.

Any real reasons why you think this about either one, or are we talking gut feelings?

[Dragon Phoenix]

Anyone else bothered to check the day one voting pattern of Pickle, Boy Wonder? He never ever voted for me, although he got me allegedly guilty night one..... I smell a Lepton gambit.

[Sotty7]

In other news DP has been lying too low for my taste, care to explain why you think you can justify a vote with 1 line of text? FOS: Dragon Phoenix
I'm done.

This was all I found in reference to Dragon Phoenix. Maybe he was just trying to lay low on day one? Plus I can understand why he looked into Quidgyboo last night as they seemed to be arguing between themselves yesterday. However I remember that I was on Quidgyboo's side yesterday and was looking towards a Pickle lynch today. (Because Pickle wouldn't vote LB even though he found him scummy).

Now I agree with Iammars, unless there is a good reason I can't see how we can't lynch DP or Quidgyboo.
I'm very interested in who Snap blocked and what DP and Quidgyboo have to say for themselves

[Iammars]

Anyone else bothered to check the day one voting pattern of Pickle, Boy Wonder? He never ever voted for me, although he got me allegedly guilty night one..... I smell a Lepton gambit.

Of course, he also could've been wondering about his sanity...

Vote: Dragon Pheonix

to get some info out of him.

[Quidgyboo]

Well, I have decided not sure how stupid this is, that I should come out. I am Charlie Brown and I am the cop and Night 1 I got that DP was guilty, Night 2 I got that Quidgyboo was guilty. Doc please protect me!

Vote: Snap for Mayor

Hope it was the right thing to do but in a mini how many mafia can there be?

I can only assume you are lying or not a pure cop. If you got guilty on me, that also leads me to believe that DP is not guilty, cause I sure as heck am not.

How far would everyone like me to go in claiming? Would the name be enough or should I share my role too? There will be good and bad points to sharing my role and I will leave it up to you guys and girls to make that decision.

I would also like to hear if either someone is going to counter-claim Charlie, or reasoning as to why Charlie might be paranoid or whatever. It would be an interesting twist, would it fit with the Peanuts story?

[Iammars]

Well, I have decided not sure how stupid this is, that I should come out. I am Charlie Brown and I am the cop and Night 1 I got that DP was guilty, Night 2 I got that Quidgyboo was guilty. Doc please protect me!

Vote: Snap for Mayor

Hope it was the right thing to do but in a mini how many mafia can there be?

I can only assume you are lying or not a pure cop. If you got guilty on me, that also leads me to believe that DP is not guilty, cause I sure as heck am not.

How far would everyone like me to go in claiming? Would the name be enough or should I share my role too? There will be good and bad points to sharing my role and I will leave it up to you guys and girls to make that decision.

I would also like to hear if either someone is going to counter-claim Charlie, or reasoning as to why Charlie might be paranoid or whatever. It would be an interesting twist, would it fit with the Peanuts story?

WHOA! Where'd Charlie come from?

[Pickle, Boy Wonder]

I am Charlie Brown, at this point I think that I AM paranoid because I realize that the chances are slim. If any reason applies as to whether or not he would be paranoid is that he was always negative in the books, or maybe I'm insane I have no idea, but if either of that is true I'm no use to the town anyway.
Important to keep in mind though is that there is a slight posibility that I am not sane, how could there be NO sane cop in the game, it would be hurrendously unbalanced.
We still need to elect amayor though so perhaps we should do that first.

[Pickle, Boy Wonder]

Sorry for the double post.
In regard to why I did not vote DP was because I knew if I led a crusade against him then I would either get lynched or night killed.
Also I wanted to try and squeeze two maybe three investigations before I came out.
I have seen other games where the cop came out too early so the town was doomed.
That is all.

[Iammars]

I've done nor sane cop in a balanced setup. Not hard.
viewtopic.php?t=2541
And I would expect Charlie to have some sort of restriction on him...

[Sotty7]

I am Charlie Brown, at this point I think that I AM paranoid because I realize that the chances are slim. If any reason applies as to whether or not he would be paranoid is that he was always negative in the books, or maybe I'm insane I have no idea, but if either of that is true I'm no use to the town anyway..

After a little research I think Charlie Brown is most likely to be paranoid. Like Pickle says Charlie is always negative and always seems to be worrying about something, so it would make sense that he would find EVERBODY guilty.

If that is the case it seems that we are back to square one

[Pickle, Boy Wonder]

I don't think that there would be just a paranoid cop in this game unless it is seriously unbalanced or it is just plain insane just like having two roleblockers in the game is. Unless someone can think of someone else who could be cop instead of me I am inclined to think that I am insane not paranoid not because of reference to Peanuts but as reference to general game knowledge.
That is all.

[Mr Stoofer]

Have we elected a mayor yet? Can we start lynching?