Open 488: Pick Your Poison [GAME OVER]

[Psyche]

I didn't think he'd hammer me. QQ

[xtopherusD]

Thanks for playing, all! Obviously this game would actually be nothing without people posting things. So everyone who did that is amazing!!

Also special thanks to RichardGHP for being available to take over for me. It turned out that it wasn't necessary, but knowing that things would continue to run was great!


This game was always so close. Two Mafia deaths before Day Two, and they end up with the win! Definitely made for an enjoyable modding experience.

Anyway. You're all great! Thanks so much for being great!

[uctriton00]

Is there a dead topic? I want to see what others would have chosen

[fuzzybutternut]

^There is x) Not gonna post it without mod's consent, though

[uctriton00]

Nvm just saw it.

I wanted DV all game and cast the most votes against him and walled him, but nobody liked his slot to be scum but I did decide to walk away on my own because I second guessed myself and thought the Siv troll read was much better

[RichardGHP]

Also special thanks to RichardGHP for being available to take over for me. It turned out that it wasn't necessary, but knowing that things would continue to run was great!

It was a little strange having a rule mentioning me by name, saying that I would be handling the game for a time, and it never materialised In any case, I'm always happy to be the safety net.

[uctriton00]

That LYLO setup was perfect though. Killing off Pim set up scum Siv easily.

[DeasVail]

I got a bit lucky with Psyche getting lynched. He seemed town to me, so I couldn't push his lynch without it probably being fake.

The PimHel kill was mainly because he was the IC.

[Antagon]

I apologize for replacing out, but real life had to get in the way...

[theslimer3]

I don't think I did much this game o.o

Most Hated Player.
Stop playah hatin T^T

[FuDuzn]

Man I thought we as scum were screwed after two days. Big ups to DV for just allowing the town to implode and holding it down.

Probably the most fun I have ever had after dying in this game.

[Bacde]

UCT TRUST YOUR READS YOU ARE REALLY GOOD AT THIS GAME NOW BELIEVE IT!!

Great game guys

[Psyche]

Well he was completely wrong with his first set of reads. That's kinda why I ignored him on the second iteration. :/

[FuDuzn]

BELIEVE IN THE PENGUIN!

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

WHAT IF HE DOESNT BELIEVE IN ME?

Dangit.

Also I totally called that pim thing.

[AngryPidgeon]

Dv is sexy and he knows it

[DeasVail]

I love you too AP.

I was actually really worried that you'd be groaning about how obvscum I was in the Dead QT.

[uctriton00]

If only Psyche wasn't forced to suicide, both he and I would have wasted the D4 lynch on Siv LIKE WE WANTED TO

BELIEVE IN THE PENGUIN!

THANK YOU!

jeebus!

[Psyche]

Okay, before uctriton's ego gets too huge, let me quote a post.

[Psyche]

Got it

64 and 65 give me bacde and AP as people who know each others alignments. This is too buddy buddy for two townies to automatically embrace each other without at least one of them knowing each other. I really get the feel AP just picked on kcudz after town opinion made him suspicious, and who better to set off a PL then a flailing player. FYI I have him as town as my gut says exactly that; kcudz is just bad at playing (and likely alt'd up) but that doesn't make him scummy and in fact makes him townie since he should have enough experience to not be so bad.

Fuzzy at 138 I get from a town motivation. Scum would push it as a hard accusation, but townies say hey we are just playing a game.

163 gives me Bacde as scum still. To me AP and Bacde are teammates who are now just joking around with each other like in any real life situation.

180 and 182 baboon look scummy. Pretending to join in on an argument, then finding any kind of reason to back it up, and comes up with "the last post tipped me". There was no reading in that, you just picked a reason. Baboon scum read.

212 silver looks terribad too. "Yeah I can sheep onto that" and votes him? Other than being wrong on me, I think Scott is figuring a few things out and is starting to be a threat. As of that post, baboon looks like the right answer, with now Bacde and a coin flip between AP and silver. Cause Scott's read is AP town, that p much puts me as the team being Bacde, baboon, silver. AP and Bacde jovial ness I referenced earlier in this post; it's looking like Bacde is the one who knows APs alignment and is trying to friend him.

250 is Bacde scum and AP town. Change my read on AP, he's townie now.

253 is Bacde protecting Silver.

The kcudz vig list isn't bad now that I read his reasoning for it. Although, I've seen vigs work with town and be wrong, and work solo and be right, so I don't think telling a vig what to do helps the vigs.

284 and 285 are fuzzy town. No hard omgus read or omgus attempt to try to fight against the vote or discredit him.

287 GNR just continues baboons scummy ness.

318, what townie jokes like that? Silver as a scum member still.

355 a kiss up because that post has two townies being misread by me (no I didn't misread them on purpose, it's just not as good as this actual retread of the entire game is going tonight). Bacde sees me pushing two town kills, so he tries to befriend me since I'm a scapegoat for him. And he says "you get scapegoated a lot huh", like he knows that I'm misreading townies as scum.

379 let's vote a lurker lol!

389 god damn Bacde loves it when a town gives a misread on another townie! Seriously everyone reading this post, this is a serious trend he has going.

Page 18 has Psyche pushing on Bacde who went from all bravado of thinking he ran the game, to civil discourse when pushed into serious discussion.

And for all the KBW talk? Hell yes that looks bad, but you have to have at least one bad town player in every game. No offense to you personally, it's just that in this game you are likely the token townie who makes himself look bad and is being served up as a PL, in addition to slimmer who scum would love to PL.

Bacde, GNR, silver.

Everyone else is a town, or at the very least a vanilla townie who has no,powers and thus no motivation to play in a game that's 20 pages long in day 1 and got completely lost and doesn't care anymore.

And THAT is how you reread a game. When we win this game I request the MVP award.

Vote: Bacde

Cut the head off, then GNR and Silver will fall.

This is how the game would have gone if we had listened to uctriton.

[uctriton00]

I was surprised I wasn't pegged as the 3rd mafia after that complete whiff and a miss. I thought I was easily going to be lynched after that.

[uctriton00]

p.s. i still did get that GNR read

I still hate how we couldn't take out Siv that day. There's no way he was a viable person to leave in lylo. Kill all trolls before you get to that point, you have to. Scum are never going to off them for you.

[Siveure DtTrikyp]

Or work out how to read a troll lol.

And, are you suggesting we lynch psyche in LyLo?

[Psyche]

That would have been pretty possible if we had lynched Siveure instead of me. >.>

[uctriton00]

I now have two trolls who flipped town, which sets me up for enough WIFOM for my future games.

If Siv went down, it would have been ofc DV, Psyche, Pim, Me, to which I don't think DV could have escaped any LYLO combination at that point.

Going to be so mad at myself for having a town LYLO hammer for the first time ever in Mafia and getting it wrong =(