NY135: Sexy Sedilla Semi-Open - Town Wins

[Ythan]

I said you made a fluff post. Which you didn't fix, by the way, you just started complaining about the scrutiny.

[Swag136]

Para, you've made a lot of unbiased posts, and not very smart moves. You're trying to cover yourself up too hard. Obvious scum is obvious. VOTE: Parabollocks

[Parabollocks]

a lot of unbiased posts

holy crap, i must be a terrible player.

[Hiraki]

Unvote

We lynch off of this wagon.

[Îdher]

That was completely idiotic.

I would like to see Swag's offsite games. Or possibly make Amrun read them, since there's the whole "not being around for a week" thing.

-Ether

[Îdher]

Question to Swag on his Hiraki read also stands.

-Ether

[Hiraki]

Even though Parabollocks is scummy, I can't see a town wagon forming this fast.

I need to analyze.

[Ethos]

Alright, had a discussion with Slaxx now and we've agreed on the following:

1. Sways eagerness to get the game started and constant observation of the thread as shown in post #23 reads as a town-tell. Mafia would have no instant need to rush into the gamestart as they would be much more interested in discussing thoughts and tactics in the mafia QT. I don't find his L-1 vote a scum-tell purely due to his lack of experience.

2. Oversouls claimage over the ownership of the Idher wagon reads as a town-tell, I don't see scum openely taking responsibility as an Idher town-flip would put them in an awful position, similary I don't see Oversoul bussing Idher.

3. Idher could you care to elaborate on what makes you believe Hiraki is scum because I'm not understanding the large suspicion cast against Hiraki. His play doesn't seem different from any of the games of his I've seen, if anything his reaction to the vote reads as town as does his unvote.

4. Parabollocks intial post #36 we read as a town-tell because it's where I would have placed my vote as well mainly due to Kaynes continual filler and fluff posts look bad. His recent backpedalling to a degree reads as very off though the speed of the bandwagon and his reaction towards it reads as geninuely frustrated town.

Vote: Kayne

Regfan.

[Ythan]

Your 1 and 2 are not logically..logical.

[kanyeknowsbest]

ythan is town. im getting frustrated town vibes from parabollocks despite his inconsistencies. hiraki is still scum, despite trying to laugh it off.

swag is possible scum, i believe the bookmarking bit, but refusing to give any explanation for scum sentiments followed by an L-1 vote with very fluff reasoning does not make town. claims that the L-1 vote can be written off as null for being a newb should also make the eagerness to start the game null as well.

[Untrod Tripod]

Ima let you finish, but the Parabollocks wagon was the best wagon of the year

also I really want to lynch swag simply so I can refer to it as a swagon or a swag-wagon. Oh please oh please oh please let him be scum.

[Hiraki]

hiraki is still scum, despite trying to laugh it off.

damn.

[SpyreX]

T-Bone is town *gasp*

GOD in heaven though:

Para, you've made a lot of unbiased posts, and not very smart moves. You're trying to cover yourself up too hard. Obvious scum is obvious. VOTE: Parabollocks

This I dont even

4. Parabollocks intial post #36 we read as a town-tell because it's where I would have placed my vote as well mainly due to Kaynes continual filler and fluff posts look bad. His recent backpedalling to a degree reads as very off though the speed of the bandwagon and his reaction towards it reads as geninuely frustrated town.

This I double dont even

ythan is town. im getting frustrated town vibes from parabollocks despite his inconsistencies. hiraki is still scum, despite trying to laugh it off.

swag is possible scum, i believe the bookmarking bit, but refusing to give any explanation for scum sentiments followed by an L-1 vote with very fluff reasoning does not make town. claims that the L-1 vote can be written off as null for being a newb should also make the eagerness to start the game null as well.

Hiraki isn't scum yo. Ythan is town though so 1 for 2 aint bad.

Is this already at L-1?

[Îdher]

Someone asked us to explain the scumread on Hiraki.

I am less sure that Hiraki is scum, but agree with Ether in this assessment: so far, Hiraki is the most likely to be scum.

His meta is shifting overall (and not in a good way), which makes it harder to evaluate his play shift in this game. However, Hiraki is posting an incredible amount of useless noise and I think he's smart enough to know that and is doing it intentionally, which is scummy.

I believe swag's bookmark mixup, but that doesn't make him town. Swag, please link us some scum games, as Ether requested. While you're at it, link some town games, too.

-Amrun

[Hiraki]

When you've only talked about 4 people in the game and are a hydra, you have no right to say that I spurt out noise.

[Ythan]

And if I say it, will you come up with another excuse to omgus me?

[Hiraki]

Depends on my mood, but yes. Probably.

[Ethos]

Sigh. Spyrex+Ythan please explain what is wrong with the logic in our posts.

-Slaxx

[Ythan]

You are not good to have in this game. Checking possible roles to see if we have a good alternative to lynching you.

[Ythan]

1. Sways eagerness to get the game started and constant observation of the thread as shown in post #23 reads as a town-tell. Mafia would have no instant need to rush into the gamestart as they would be much more interested in discussing thoughts and tactics in the mafia QT. I don't find his L-1 vote a scum-tell purely due to his lack of experience.

2. Oversouls claimage over the ownership of the Idher wagon reads as a town-tell, I don't see scum openely taking responsibility as an Idher town-flip would put them in an awful position, similary I don't see Oversoul bussing Idher.

1. You're exaggerating his activity and framing it as townish when there is no reason to take it that way.
2. You're making assumptions that you have no reason to be making.

[Ethos]

1. Yes, this is a bit of a stretch, but it is also the first town read we had, Reg actually pointed it out to me pregame.
2. Uh, no. What scum newbie comes in, RVSs someone, sees a bandwagon has formed on that player, and then totes about it. That isn't scum behavior at all.

[SpyreX]

4. Parabollocks intial post #36 we read as a town-tell because it's where I would have placed my vote as well mainly due to Kaynes continual filler and fluff posts look bad. His recent backpedalling to a degree reads as very off though the speed of the bandwagon and his reaction towards it reads as geninuely frustrated town.

Continual filler = 5 posts?
Backpedaling = not backpedaling and being obstinate?
Reaction = I hate this site = town?

------

Hot damn did we catch some kinda doom PR in bollocks?

[Ythan]

2. Uh, no. What scum newbie comes in, RVSs someone, sees a bandwagon has formed on that player, and then totes about it. That isn't scum behavior at all.

And you think it's town behavior? Just because it would be dumb for scum doesn't mean it's town. It's null at best.

[Ethos]

2. Uh, no. What scum newbie comes in, RVSs someone, sees a bandwagon has formed on that player, and then totes about it. That isn't scum behavior at all.

And you think it's town behavior? Just because it would be dumb for scum doesn't mean it's town. It's null at best.

Did I say it would be

dumb

for scum to do that? No, I didn't.

Think about when scum get on a bandwagon. Think about what they do. They need town cred to survive. There are two ways to get that:
1. Bus a scumbuddy
2. Argue against a townie's lynch

He is taking credit for what is probably a townie's lynch in that post that is all there is to it. The only way he is scum is with amrun.

[Ythan]

You're the one who brought his newbie status into this and yet the rest of your argument falls apart when you don't sweep that under the rug.