Post #117: Ross is oddly concerned about an unexplained vote on Untrod Tripod. Note that he did not show the same concern when, for example,
nhammen voted ender without explanation.
Post #145: Ross then proceeds to make an unexplained vote himself, as well as completely ignoring me asking him to consider for himself why I might be voting for UT. I think this is ample evidence that Ross has no actual problem with unexplained votes in general, which suggests to me that it must be the fact that I voted UT specifically that he had a problem with.
Post #178: Weird how Ross is the only name in bvoigt's "Not Sure" list that gets any notes. Almost like he felt Ross really belonged in the scumlist, but didn't want to bus.
Post #180 (et al): Really don't see this hydra argument happening between scumbuddies. I remember someone else suggesting it was contrived in order to distance from each other without anything game relevant, but I don't see it that way. The way Calcifer acquiesces to DH's demands strike me as trying to appease a townie he wanted to keep on side.
Post #233: Westerns killed DGB N1, and I doubt they were intending to hit Eastern. They killed DGB because they thought she was a threat, perhaps because two of their three members agreed that she was clearly town-looking?
Post #360: FoS buddy, vote townie, what a tell. Especially when it is literally the only time in the entire game that Calcifer actually uses a FoS.
Post #370: But then Calcifer calls UT "a valid vote", and yet never ever pursues him in any way. Hmm.
Post #371: Winking emoticon scumtell.
Post #380: bvoigt gives up on his tyler vote rather too easily, I think.
Post #389: No mention of either bvoigt or UT in Battle Mage's replacing in posts, so that's no help.
Post #420: DRK had bvoigt as a top suspect, and was one of the only people to do so. This could be the cause of his death.
Post #431: bvoigt posts a pretty baseless suggestion that "most of the scum are lurking". Note that Calcifer was maybe the most active player in the game.
Post #437: bvoigt not actually caring who gets lynched.
Post #489: bvoigt kicks off D3 by hunting exclusively for Eastern mafia.
Post #496: This made me lol. But Shark's series of posts there, while very wrong, as exemplified by this one, do read as town to me.
Post #527: Calcifer makes a couple of long-ass posts setting up Parama/bvoigt as the Western team, and votes Parama at the end of it, leaving him free to dissolve his suspicion on bvoigt when his Parama case turned out wrong. I don't think this implicates bvoigt particularly in itself, but it certainly doesn't clear him.
Post #532: In retrospect, I wish you hadn't made this vote, Empking. There could have been useful info in seeing whether the lynch landed on Calcifer or Parama after your claim, and how that came about, but this really decided things right away.
Post #585: While everyone else is content to just vote Calcifer without further comment, bvoigt is already trying to set up future mislynches.
Post #593: I still think that paying any attention to what outed scum are saying and using that to clear people is a terrible idea, and I don't understand how it's supposed to be scummy to point that out. But I also think that DH wouldn't be this quick to clear people if he was scum.
Post #622: Yeah, I think if Shark was faking the belief that there were two scum remaining, he'd have made a much bigger deal about it. Definitely seems like an honest mistake, and obviously not one that scum would make.
Post #637: Final nail in the coffin. bvoigt playing the long game because he knows he needs to get two mislynches to win, so he's looking to keep me around for tomorrow.
VOTE: bvoigt
Lynch me first if you must, but bvoigt is your last scum. My final request is a bvoigt lynch tomorrow.