Mini 1040 - Everyone's A Critic! [Game Over]

[Jack]

Scorp you still happy with your vote on stef?

He's not giving any reason for voting me, so yeah I like my vote.

Yeah but you hadn't really been giving any reason for voting him. Works both ways.

[mykonian]

Don't want to insult you scorpion. It probably has already become a selffulfilling profecy that you are an easy lynch

I haven't played with anyone on my wagon except danakillsu and stef (who i haven't finished a game with). How many of them do you think are voting me based on my reputation?

and here I was thinking you played a lot of games with a lot of players...

just remember this for the next game everyone: mykonian likes to bandwagon xscorpion if mykonian thinks there isn't enough discussion, or if he wants to gain quick townie points (depending on role)

[XScorpion]

A RVS excuse is better than no excuse.

[Haschel Cedricson]

A RVS excuse is better than no excuse.

See? I knew you knew it was the RVS!

[Haschel Cedricson]

Hey danakillsu, what do you think of Mykonian's play?

[mykonian]

Scorp get's just a fos for now but we got bigger fish to fry right now.

this is stef's first mention of scorp. This is page 2. Scorp hasn't done anything scummy, however is the first BW. this FoS... is terrible!

anyway, the same FoS is converted into a vote when Stef his argument against me fails (he backs off after scorpion and Jack state he is wrong). it is still terrible!


Run, scum, run!

[mykonian]

Hey danakillsu, what do you think of Mykonian's play?

what do you think of my play?

[Haschel Cedricson]

I disagree with your handling of the XScorpion wagon (and this isn't OMGUS; I would have asked these questions regardless of who the first XScorpion voter was), but your clarifications make sense and I don't think you're scummy. I'm particularly intrigued by post 11 and think it's an interesting point. For now, you check out.

Post 80 is also really good.

Unvote, Vote: Stef

I have a meeting with my wedding caterer, so no more from me until later this evening.

[Stef]

Scorp get's just a fos for now but we got bigger fish to fry right now.

this is stef's first mention of scorp. This is page 2. Scorp hasn't done anything scummy, however is the first BW. this FoS... is terrible!

anyway, the same FoS is converted into a vote when Stef his argument against me fails (he backs off after scorpion and Jack state he is wrong). it is still terrible!


Run, scum, run!

Nah, voting for players who you suspect crack under pressure is not terrible. Also, terrible =/= scummy but hey, everyone's a critic. - makes the vote worthless.

Before I unvote though, Scorp, something jack noticed does strike me as a lil bit odd. I know that I initially voted you to add some pressure, however, you seem to be fine parking your vote on me without me giving any reasons and adding pressure is obviously not it. Why not ask if I don't give any reasons? Would it be because it gives you an excuse to park your vote?

[Stef]

Jack: Why would you think the town needs more leeway as to nerf down the mafia to two scum?

[Jack]

Jack: Why would you think the town needs more leeway as to nerf down the mafia to two scum?

It doesn't matter at the moment.

[XScorpion]

however, you seem to be fine parking your vote on me without me giving any reasons and adding pressure is obviously not it.

Oh really? If RVS votes aren't meant for discussion through pressuring, what are they meant for?

Why not ask if I don't give any reasons? Would it be because it gives you an excuse to park your vote?

Sorry bout that, I still have to wash the bad taste of Open 231 out of my mouth. I sometimes forget that people might actually answer me when I ask them why they're voting...

[Antihero]

Jack: Why would you think the town needs more leeway as to nerf down the mafia to two scum?

So, how's the rolefishing going?

[Stef]

How could that be considered fishing? What jack said could not be based on the knowledge possessed by a town PR but either a theory or scum knowledge because town would not know how strong/weak the town is.

[Stef]

Or town could know how strong the town is but that would imply a stronger mafia, not a weaker one so... It's really not related to any PR Jack may or may not have.

[jelly jiggler]

In a way that could be considered role fishing because a power role could indicate a bigger scum team.

[DavidParker]

Town:
Jack
danakillsu
Stef
Jelly Jiggler
Haschel

Scum:
XScorpion

Antihero

RedCoyote

Take your pick out of those 2 for our lynch. Let's get this moving.

[XScorpion]

Posting a list of people doesn't mean anything unless you actually explain why they're there.

[MagnaofIllusion]

It appears kunkstar didn't note my weekend V/LA.

I'll be able to comment on the schenanigans so far Monday night but based on my quick read so far -

VOTE: DavidParker

Not how Town DP plays by a longshot.

[Antihero]

Posting a list of people doesn't mean anything unless you actually explain why they're there.

Yes, that should be obvious to everyone. Why are you pointing this out; does it strike a chord with you?

[XScorpion]

Clearly it isn't obvious to everyone because DP keeps doing it.

[Jack]

It means

something

, but it's a weird list, why is danakillsu in the town list?

[XScorpion]

By the way, you still haven't unvoted or explained to me why self-voting is pro-town.

[kunkstar7]

:: VoteCount 1x2 ::

Antihero (1) -

DavidParker

MagnaofIllusion (1) -

RedCoyote

RedCoyote (0) -
danakillsu (0) -
Jack (1) -

Jack

Haschel Cedricson (0) -

jelly jiggler (1) -

Antihero

XScorpion (2) -

danakillsu, Stef

Stef (3) -

Xscorpion, mykonian, Haschel Cedricson

imaginality (0) -
mykonian (0) -

DavidParker (1) -

MagnaOfIllusion

Not Voting (2) -

imaginality, jelly jiggler

With 12 Alive, it takes 7 to lynch.

September 19, 2010 5:00PM EST.

Scum may NOT pass the Vigilante Ability to their partners. This is not a change in the setup or mechanic, it has been in effect since the beginning, but I missed it in the Special Section. My apologies.

Sorry MOI, I noted your V/LA personally but failed to announce it publicly.
Way to ruin my streak of a votecount every page already >_>.

[Jack]

Scum may NOT pass the Vigilante Ability to their partners. This is not a change in the setup or mechanic, it has been in effect since the beginning, but I missed it in the Special Section. My apologies.

Oh very interesting. I will have to rethink that stef/myk debate now.

hmm.

No, it doesn't make a difference, scum still can't possess it to start. Because if they did they would pass it to a townie and kill that townie...well the rule is a bit confusing, but there is still no way scum started with it.