No. I would expect cult to discuss/coordinate their actions each night, but not necessarily to discuss all the plays/posts they make in game.iLord wrote:Would 1 not be just as unlikely as 4, considering the excuse that Ani used?
What happened to your lack of faith in your scumhunting ability?Ani wrote:I thought it was helping,although it wasn't as passive as I wanted, by getting rid of what I thought would be a big threat if he's cult. I hid it because of that I was afraid what was going to happen (what happened to me when I hid it up).
Lying about your night actions + preparing to murder a player N1 = murderer in the making/cultist fake claiming night actions ~animorpherv1 wrote:I give up. I stalked Adel.
Reasoning:
Adel is a good player -> What if he's cult -> If he is we're all screwed.
I think that we can now be certain of his honesty. He's lied already, who's to say he's not lying again now?semioldguy wrote:@Chaco (and animorpherz1 too I guess)
That explanation makes a lot more sense than laundering (but only because any explanation would make more sense than laundering). If he did stalk, then he MUST be town currently. I am still not certain of his honesty now though.
Despite him now claiming that he in fact did #3, I still believe this to be #1. Either way, it's lynch worthy.semioldguy wrote:@iLord
Of the options I see, I'd put them in the following order of likeliness from most to least:
(1) Cult lying to explain a future insanity gain.
(2) Town that made a horrible Night Zero decision.
(3) Stalked night one in hopes of going Murderer.
Are you trying to say that they set this up together? Seems like a bit of a reach.Iecerint wrote:Cue obligatory "That was awfully convenient..." @ Ani/Sajin. O_O
I know!Ellibereth wrote:Why are people claiming noises and wards on the first page?
Wickedestjr in 71 wrote: Adel, can you explain why we should wait until later to claim. I don't get it.
Vote: AdelIt seems odd to me that you are making such a big deal about us claiming, yet didn't start trying to change people's minds until many players had already claimed.
~~~Adel in 72 wrote:lolWickedestjr wrote:Vote: AdelIt seems odd to me that you are making such a big deal about us claiming, yet didn't start trying to change people's minds until many players had already claimed.
it is much more odd that people started claiming before consensus was reached, or conversation even began. They started claiming before I had a chance to post.
Obviously, a person who played in the first game is cult in this game, and they decided to go with the full claims pronto.
I was planning to take Taboo next.Nicodemus wrote:Lying about your night actions + preparing to murder a player N1 = murderer in the making/cultist fake claiming night actions ~animorpherv1 wrote:I give up. I stalked Adel.
Reasoning:
Adel is a good player -> What if he's cult -> If he is we're all screwed.Vote: animorpherv1
I'm not accusing you of scummy intentions, but it is typically a bad idea to tell people what their reasonable explaination should be.Iecerint wrote:Eww. The only way out was if she somehow thought that Stalk was a form of tracking. Then it would make sense to Stalk a perceived skilled player. How obnoxious.
I'll leave my vote, anyway. I don't like being naked, and I don't yet see an obvious alternate target.
That is horrible reasoning adel.Adel wrote:animorpherv1 wrote:I give up. I stalked Adel.
Reasoning:
Adel is a good player -> What if he's cult -> If he is we're all screwed.vote:animorpherv1
Good. Tonight there will only be one grave (the lynch) to rob. We shall see how many people are foolishly going murderer. You still agree to do this, yes?animorpherv1 wrote:I agree. And just to make sure, it's only lynches, or is it a lynch, then the kill of the same day?
You speak like you have a list of the scum players in this game. It is hard for Investigators to make such bold assumptions.Adel wrote: 2. they have players from the last Sars game
I believe he didn't Launder and that he stalked.iLord wrote: You believe him?
If Adel gets killed and flips scum, why kill Ani? It takes 2 murders to be forced to become a murderer. All investigators, in a sense, have a 1 time free pass Vig. It just cost a night and an insanity to do it.Chaco wrote: Obviously, yeah. Laundering would be stupid. So, if Adel gets killed, kill Ani? But for today leave him alone?
Hmm. That's actually quite valid. Do you believe that Ani is crafty enough to preemptively excuse insanities? Cause from what I see, I'd be quite surprised that CultAni held off on claiming cultistsemioldguy wrote:No. I would expect cult to discuss/coordinate their actions each night, but not necessarily to discuss all the plays/posts they make in game.
Case in point, Percy's last game. Daytalking scum made a boneheaded move and didn't consult their scumbuddy in their quicktopic prior to making it.
.Adel wrote:I believe that it is essential to lynch ani at this point. Riculaulsly anti-town play requires dicipline and punishment by lynch.
Giving people a pass for being "too scummy to be scum" isn't going to help us win.
I'm for currently looking elsewhere. I am against making a solid statement of what to do with Animorpherv1 if Adel is or is not successfully/unsuccessfully murdered. The bridge will be crossed when we come to it. Deciding those things now or in advance is speculative and not beneficial to town.Chaco wrote: So, if Adel gets killed, kill Ani? But for today leave him alone?
I guess it's of no use that I've chasnged my plan to search tomorrow?semioldguy wrote:I'm for currently looking elsewhere. I am against making a solid statement of what to do with Animorpherv1 if Adel is or is not successfully/unsuccessfully murdered. The bridge will be crossed when we come to it. Deciding those things now or in advance is speculative and not beneficial to town.Chaco wrote: So, if Adel gets killed, kill Ani? But for today leave him alone?
I'm for lynching him quickly and moving on to night before this spam fest leaves us with 75 pages of nosie.semioldguy wrote:I'm for currently looking elsewhere. I am against making a solid statement of what to do with Animorpherv1 if Adel is or is not successfully/unsuccessfully murdered. The bridge will be crossed when we come to it. Deciding those things now or in advance is speculative and not beneficial to town.Chaco wrote: So, if Adel gets killed, kill Ani? But for today leave him alone?
Read my posts. Its an extremely easy lynch for cultists. And no its not strictly anti town to stalk.Ellibereth wrote:Anyone who's against lynching Ani is crazy.
Using stalking as your action in this manner is anti-town, he poses a constant murderer risk, he needs to die.
As long as you grave rob as well.animorpherv1 wrote:I guess it's of no use that I've chasnged my plan to search tomorrow?semioldguy wrote:I'm for currently looking elsewhere. I am against making a solid statement of what to do with Animorpherv1 if Adel is or is not successfully/unsuccessfully murdered. The bridge will be crossed when we come to it. Deciding those things now or in advance is speculative and not beneficial to town.Chaco wrote: So, if Adel gets killed, kill Ani? But for today leave him alone?
I so totaly missed it. Becuas ei wasn't willing to take a risk.iLord wrote:You still didn't answer my question - why did you decide to stalk Adel even though you said that you have no faith in your scumhunting abilities?ani wrote:I guess it's of no use that I've chasnged my plan to search tomorrow?