Open 199 - Friends, Enemies, and Enemies - OVER

[SaintKerrigan]

Unvote: xRECKONERx. Vote: Danakillsu.

Post #24 feels off to me.

[danakillsu]

What? You're telling someone else to do something that you immediately do the opposite of? Whatever. How does it "feel of to you"? That's a pretty sad reason to vote for me, if you aren't still RV'ing.

[SaintKerrigan]

What? You're telling someone else to do something that you immediately do the opposite of? Whatever. How does it "feel of to you"? That's a pretty sad reason to vote for me, if you aren't still RV'ing.

You treated xReck seriously. That's what feels off.

[xRECKONERx]

EXACTLY nobody treats me seriously duh

[danakillsu]

You treated xReck seriously. That's what feels off.

Absolutely not. I did not treat him seriously. Some of the possibilities were that he did not really want to be lynched (in other words, he wasn't serious). And the possibility that he was trying to confuse us is my number 1.

[SaintKerrigan]

You treated xReck seriously. That's what feels off.

Absolutely not. I did not treat him seriously. Some of the possibilities were that he did not really want to be lynched (in other words, he wasn't serious). And the possibility that he was trying to confuse us is my number 1.

You treated xReck's post as if he was actually trying to accomplish something with it. In other words, you took it seriously. It was obviously a joke inspired by the escapades of RVS.

[evilsnail]

Bleh, danakillsu is so obviously inexperienced that it seems weird to jump all over that.

Unvote,
Vote: SaintKerrigan

[SaintKerrigan]

But look how quick he is to deny that he treated xReck's questions seriously. Doesn't that feel slightly off to you?

How is it weird that I "jumped" on DKU?

[RayFrost]

unvote, vote: evilsnail

chainsaw defense on his scum partner (dannakillsu) with a really flimsy and weak excuse to vote.

obv scum.

[Flareonage]

Unvote

VOTE: SaintKerrigan

Dana brought up valid points thus your vote is pointless

[SaintKerrigan]

Unvote

VOTE: SaintKerrigan

Dana brought up valid points thus your vote is pointless

SERIOUSLY?!? Doesn't it bother you that DKU took seriously what xReck put forth as a joke?

[Flareonage]

I don't see how it hurts the town. It's not like there was much going on anyway

[RayFrost]

It's not "hurts town" so much as "taking something seriously that is so completely obvious in its lack of sincerity and then pretending that you didn't in order to avoid suspicion that has been placed upon you rather than attempting to actually defend yourself from the reasoning put forth"

thinking about it...

unvote, vote: dannakillsu

[evilsnail]

But look how quick he is to deny that he treated xReck's questions seriously. Doesn't that feel slightly off to you?

Not really. It sounds like he's saying that he didn't treat xReck as being serious about wanting to be lynched.

How is it weird that I "jumped" on DKU?

Well, it could be scum trying to go for an easy newb lynch by treating something innocuous as something revealing. So, better than my random vote.

[RayFrost]

Joined: 07 Dec 2009

Totally a newbie

[evilsnail]

Considering that most mafia games take longer than that, I don't see what your point is.

[Fate]

This seems really strange to me. There are a few possibilities here:
1)He actually wants us to lynch him. This could mean:
a)He doesn't want to play this game. Seems very unlikely
b)He wants the other side to win. Also unlikely

c)He has a role that wins if it is lynched. Is there such a thing?

2)He doesn't want us to lynch him.
a)Reverse Psychology. A little blatant for that.
b)He wants to confuse us. I find this most likely.
I find 1c a scary possibility, and the second most likely possibility if there is such a role.

The role is Jester, nice try. You know this is an open setup right?

Vote: danakillsu

[RayFrost]

DKU would have, at minimum, some experience.

Also, experience, in this case, would increase the likelihood of this being true

It's not "hurts town" so much as "taking something seriously that is so completely obvious in its lack of sincerity and then pretending that you didn't in order to avoid suspicion that has been placed upon you rather than attempting to actually defend yourself from the reasoning put forth"

[evilsnail]

Some experience does not mean much. And I read that post. I just don't see it that way. Deal with it.

[RayFrost]

Some experience does not mean much. And I read that post. I just don't see it that way. Deal with it.

Suspecting others for not reading it the same way as you makes the above post hypocritical.

Either you can be suspect for reading it differently as well as us or it's a null tell.

Anyway, DKU is scum, woohoo.

evilsnail is possible alt-scumbuddy, woohoo. (sure on alt, not guaranteed scum, though)

[The Tracker]

Dana, I honestly don't see how the heck that couldn't be an RVS joke. Maybe the one trying to confuse the Town is you. Those questions seemed serious enough to me.

unvote

Since RVS is over.

[evilsnail]

Either you can be suspect for reading it differently as well as us or it's a null tell.

Obviously I can be suspect for reading it differently too. You started arguing with me! I never attacked you for suspecting me. There's no hypocrisy here at all.

[RayFrost]

Unvoting purely because the RVS is over is pointless. If you have somebody you think is scum, vote them.

[RayFrost]

Either you can be suspect for reading it differently as well as us or it's a null tell.

Obviously I can be suspect for reading it differently too. You started arguing with me! I never attacked you for suspecting me. There's no hypocrisy here at all.

You suspected sainty for suspecting DKU's post.

I was pointing out that you suspecting sainty for something but saying you aren't suspect for it was hypocritical.

Nothing to do with you arguing with me.

[The Tracker]

Unvoting purely because the RVS is over is pointless. If you have somebody you think is scum, vote them.

I always unvote after RVS, friendo. I don't like to vote unless at least some part of my mind is convinced someone's scum.