Camn wrote:I don't think Hascow was killed for lobotomy. . . no offense intended, but there are some pretty heavy hitters on the playerlist.
Unless they are ALL scum, I think hascow was picked for a different reason.
VP? what is your opinion of Hascow as a player?
He had to be picked off by someone who knows him, unless the scum were submitting a completely random kill (extremely doubtful).
Kai wrote:Hmm. My first Large Normal, and my first Night Start all in one. Mmk. I do believe that I'll follow Mastin and alexhans' lead.
Wow, I didn't know I was that popular.
Mastin: Does not know hascow, so would not be too keen on killing him.
Technically, I don't know him, but I've seen him around. (Read: browsing first eighty pages of Medieval Mafia, GD threads, etc.) Don't think that'd count, though.
Myself: I know hascow from one ongoing game, but would put Sens, BM, and Mastin much higher on the "to kill" list than I would put him.
Aye. As would I. Plus EM players, Alex, and instead of me, you.
(One of these days, I so totally want to ask a mod if I can nk myself as scum to create confusion and for the hilarity, but, well, I'm not scum this game and that'd do no good.
)
DDD was scum, and hascow was town and an IC. hascow was not NKed until the Night after DDD was lynched (D3 and N3 specifically) so it is highly unlikely that DDD would find hascow to be a good target now when he didn't back then and hasn't played with him since.
Valid point.
camn: His last post suggests that he would view other players as higher priority kills than hascow.
Her. Her last post, unless Camn's profile is lying about gender.
And, well, Camn's actually at spot #2 on my scumspect post; something seems off already and Camn definitely has played with has.
That leaves Sens and BM.
I did a metagaming read on Sensfan and am familiar to some extent with his Newbie Game meta, but outside of Newbie games, I am not, and so, need to do research on that as well.
I do, however, think BM would submit said kill. He's good at wifom and all of that stuff.
Then again, he has a history of killing good players. I've seen him twice as scum. 688, it was the pro-town player, no-kill, kill of person attacking the player (Need a term for that. OMGUS+Chainsaw NK?
), and then a no-kill again.
763, it was me (pro-town player, nailed the other scum), and then, he was lynched.
It all depends on the links I gave where BM played with has, I guess; did he think that has was a good player then?
I'll have to do some more research on both of them (tomorrow, as it's reeeally late right now) before I choose, but the likelyhood is high that at least one of those two is the scum who picked out hascow for the N1 kill.
Aye. I agree mostly, but I'd place camn on that list as well and disagree with that read of yours.
Jammer wrote:For what it matters, I know Mastin, GIEFF and Spyrex from EM.
Replace Mastin with Jammer, you've got mine.
We've got a little EM cult going around these days.
Spyrex to long ago to remember his playing style. :/
Yea, I remember Spy from EM, but know him better for MS.net.
Mastin you plan using meta to see who killed the cow,
Yup. Good plan, no?
while you already made clear scum can easily wifom the meta.
And where'd I say that, Jammer?
With that, there only has to be one that played with hascow, to know him and kill him.
Still doesn't eliminate the fact that one of the people who knows him had to have killed him.
You think(and others?) talking about meta, is a better way to find scum, then simple scumhunting?
Better than the RVS. We essentially skipped it with the metagaming scumhunting. Relying on scum hunting is what we'll eventually do. But for now, Meta rules.
And anyone who gets rid of metagaming as an argument with our current kill is going to instantly be labeled more likely to be scum from me.
Ignores the supposed killing of RVS of Mastin.
I *hate* the RVS, Jammer. I do my best every game to kill it as quickly as possible. Ask...*looks at player list*
Battle Mage,
alexhans,
VP Baltar,
or
Kairyuu.
And I dislike those who try to extend it when it is clear we've already begun to leave it already.
Vote: SensFan
For replacing out in comfirmation stage in my other game.
Something in this post screams "bussing" to me.
Scumspects:
Battle Mage,
Camn,
SensFan,
Jammer.
I think I might've gotten the quickest scum-read yet! Yay for scum hunting; I found four scum!
