Newbie 792--Mafia Island ~ Mafia win!

[Papa Zito]

hmmm... i just thought of something, this game is starting to split itself into some groups, suspected scum and accusers

under the suspected theirs

Wicked, Mitey, Agar, and Box

under the accusers are

Papa, Dark, Indigo, and Thesp

what to do with this i'm not sure yet

I saw that too, and I'm not sure what it means either.

[MiteyMouse]

hmmm... i just thought of something, this game is starting to split itself into some groups, suspected scum and accusers

under the suspected theirs

Wicked, Mitey, Agar, and Box

under the accusers are

Papa, Dark, Indigo, and Thesp

what to do with this i'm not sure yet

How is it that I have fallen in amongst the 3 people that I have named as possible suspects?

[Darkstrike_11]

perhaps because you make posts like that which shows how much you care if you are suspected or not. The scum care a lot about how they are seen.

But don't be downheartened mitey, I think you are neutral/scum, and I'm not thnking that you are scummy enough to deserve a vote, at least not today.

[AGar]

@Thesp: I think that given the situations of IH's roleclaim and the potential outcomes, we should leave him be for the night. If things start going awry, then we have a lead. If not, then it turns out we just have one more townie. I've never been in such an open roleclaim scenario though soooo I could be dead wrong.

@Someone who asked my thoughts on boxman (and wickedestjr iirc?): The way I see it is Boxman is way too back and forth on his opinions. The PBPA by Papa Ziti's House of Ziti was pretty well conclusive. Granted, I'm not in the best position myself, but w/e. BTW: loved the image Papa :p

Vote: Boxman

TO THE BANDWAGON!

[Papa Zito]

BTW: loved the image Papa :p

Oh sweet it's working now.

[tracker]

mitey i was going to leave you out but when i saw this,

I'm disinclined to think MiteyMouse is town, also - I would be happy to see her lynched.

thesp wants you lynched so i concluded that he suspected you to be scum so i included you in.

[Khelvaster]

@Mod: During the night, what happens if the doctor successfully saves someone? Is the town told of who was targeted during the night

No. The doctor is told that his commands were carried through, that's all.

[Indigo Heron]

I"ll be V/LA for 24 hours to study for a test.

[Wickedestjr]

@Papa Zito - I have a few ideas of who the mafia pair is. The idea that I am most sure of does not include AGar in it. I still don't see why you guys are voting for him. I just get a gut feeling that he is not mafia. I do think that he is lurking and he also seems to be agreeing with all the things that I said. I think that the chance of him being in the scum pair is half/half leaning towards definitely.

I think that Papa Zito's PBPA was a good one, and I agree that Boxman is lurking and agreeing with everything we say in an attempt to blend in.

Vote: Boxman

The problem with the above post is that you did intend to lynch me. You voted for me to make a dusk appointment with the gallows, remember?

You voted for me to get lynched earlier, remember?

This was before you claimed cop, so I changed my opinion.

I was just explaining how I thought IH's cop role would not help us at all, and that if Indigo Heron starts acting really suspiciously then we should give him a few votes, because we wouldn't have much to lose. But I am all for keeping him in the game another day at least.

You want to lynch me anyway if I act suspiciously, and you're all for keeping me for another day? Just what exactly do you anticipate happening on Day 2? I detect a hint of in-game coaching here.

You've also turned being disengaged into a Zen-like thing when it concerns AGar. You honestly don't have an opinion about AGar?

vote: Wickedestjr

unless he can satisfyingly explain.

I am all for keeping you another day

unless

you do something scummy. I have a link to a mafia game that I played in which I was mafia and ended up claiming cop;

http://www.artofproblemsolving.com/Foru ... &start=300

This does not necessarily mean that you are scum but IGMEOY. Even if you were cop, and we lynched you because we thought you were scum, it would not be much of a loss, because your abilities don't work anyway. You claimed cop, so if I had to decide whether you stay in the game or not for another day, I would choose to keep you.

[Papa Zito]

^^^ Box is at L-1.

Box, claim please.

[Wickedestjr]

Unvote: Boxman

Sorry, I was unaware of the vote count. Please don't claim boxman.

@Papa Zito - Wth? Why would you want a second player to say their role? Personally I would rather finish this day without letting mafia know all the power roles.

[MiteyMouse]

@Papa Zito - Wth? Why would you want a second player to say their role? Personally I would rather finish this day without letting mafia know all the power roles.

It is customary to claim when you're at L-1 here.

[Papa Zito]

Unvote: Boxman

Sorry, I was unaware of the vote count. Please don't claim boxman.

@Papa Zito - Wth? Why would you want a second player to say their role? Personally I would rather finish this day without letting mafia know all the power roles.

What a fascinating post.

[Darkstrike_11]

unvote

this wicked/agar/boxman triumvirate thing is incredibly interesting. I was suspicious when they both jumped on the wagon. I'm going to look into the three of them after my FINAL EXAM WOOP tomorrow.

until then

vote Wickedestjr

I'm putting the earlier suspicious activity les and less down to newby swayedness, he is eager to jump on any wagon and refuses to call agar scum.

[Darkstrike_11]

and also how he seems to know that there are more than one power roles, which right now only the mafia will know...

[Wickedestjr]

I am sorry, but I forgot that we were not positive about whether there was a doctor or not, but either way, I think two claims is too much to digest so early in the game.

[Papa Zito]

Wickedestjr's panicked unvote looks like scum trying not to get his partner killed.

That said, I still believe Box is the best lynch today.

[tracker]

Unvote: Boxman

Sorry, I was unaware of the vote count. Please don't claim boxman.

@Papa Zito - Wth? Why would you want a second player to say their role? Personally I would rather finish this day without letting mafia know all the power roles.

I am sorry, but I forgot that we were not positive about whether there was a doctor or not, but either way, I think two claims is too much to digest so early in the game.

vote:Wickedestjr

@wicked, why don't you want boxman at L-1? Why are 2 claims to much to digest? and why don't you want him to claim?

[Papa Zito]

Guys, we're supposed to be voting Boxman here.

Don't tell me I made that big ass yellow table for nothing.

[Indigo Heron]

I'm back.

Papa Zito, the 'big ass yellow table' wasn't for nothing. It will be used in future lynches, that's all. Also, wicked's case has grown a lot recently.

@Wicked: Meta-ing is a very vague field and should be only fleetingly considered at best while playing the game. What you saw in one game doesn't mean that it will show up in another.

I am sorry, but I forgot that we were not positive about whether there was a doctor or not, but either way, I think two claims is too much to digest so early in the game.

Two claims is too much to digest?! Why are you so concerned with this? We want as much information as possible to make informed, learned discussions.

[Indigo Heron]

EBWOP: If I could vote twice, I'd vote for you again.

[Wickedestjr]

Wickedestjr's panicked unvote looks like scum trying not to get his partner killed.

That said, I still believe Box is the best lynch today.

If me and boxman were partners I most likely wouldn't have vote him in the first place. I didn't want the mafia to have to have two half determined townies. But fine, I obviously don't speak for anybody else when I say that box shouldn't claim so

Vote:boxman.

[Papa Zito]

^^^ WIFOM defense. Also, voting your partner is called bussing and it's standard mafia operating procedure. Also also lol@voting Box once people unvoted him.

Looking forward to hearing Dark's take.

@Thesp: I don't think you're going to get any traction on Mitey today. There's not enough time.

I think a Box lynch will give us more info than a Wicked lynch but I'll swing over if necessary.

[Indigo Heron]

Oh, now you're calling me a half-determined townie, and are daring us to force a claim from boxman?

Also, your WIFOM defence is vague at best. If boxman and you were partners you would have voted for him anyway knowing that if we enquired you would have used the WIFOM defence.

[tracker]

wicked answer my three question please

@papa, why will a box lynch tell us more than a wicked lynch?

i think i should be able to get back on tonight and tommorow morning, probably not until sunday after that