your point is exactly that. you are suggesting that uctriton "knew" sala replaced out in anger because he's scum with sala(me), which implies sala replaced out in anger, which implies he was angry about... what? a town lynch? how does that even make sense?
Yes, that doesn't make too much sense. Unless Salamence was raging on the Mafia QT about something else and Uctriton slipped it unintentionally – but that hypothesis contains too much "if"-s and "unless"-es.
By "Back" you mean saying hello and then continuing to not do much? I'm getting really really irritated by this game every time I check in or think about it at the moment, at this stage in the game normally I have 1-2 people I'd bet a lot on being scum or 5-6 people I'd bet the game on being town (I only have 2-3 I'm that confident about) here I'm not and it's largely because this game isn't really being played by majority of the room; scum are being allowed to hide inside a huge pool of lurkers.
town read on him is dying, he's thrown his vote around without any sort of reasoning attached for the entire day then when questioned about it or anything just states he doesn't care and isn't bothered to do anything, he's making it impossible to work with him.
sorry i didn't have time to address this yesterday
In post 931, zMuffinMan wrote:if you're talking about stuff sala did that was supposedly scummy, then i don't know what you're expecting here
I'm sorry bro but stuff Sala did contributes to my read on your slot. So if you're going to say my read isn't "well thought-out" you can't ignore 75% of my reasoning
(For example you are going on about how the vig potentially being role blocked draws interference away from other PRs but ignore my argument that an
unclaimed
vig could draw the night kill away from other PRs
and still use their power
)
Besides I think the vig shot is just as (if not more) useful as any single night action from a different PR.
And are you really trying to tell me that giving scum an extra night kill (taking it away from town) and then outing a whole bunch of PRs to find the redirector is actually a favourable scenario for town come on
In post 948, Siveure DtTrikyp wrote:Heph, just because all we see is gameplay being a total VI doesn't mean there's more to read for other players.
Do you have any tells that aren't based on anti-town behaviour?
No I just think there's a noticeable difference between a VI and scum making a mess because a VI will behave/reason illogically but there will still be some consistency to their play and what they're saying.
Also the fact that gameplay is calling himself a VI now confirms he's hiding behind his bad play to say he's not scum especially since he's told Anatole to kill himself for calling him an VI earlier, but now that he sees people are assuming he's town because of it he's intentionally exaggerating it and making himself "unreadable"
In post 958, hephaestus wrote:Also the fact that gameplay is calling himself a VI now confirms he's hiding behind his bad play to say he's not scum especially since he's told Anatole to kill himself for calling him an VI earlier, but now that he sees people are assuming he's town because of it he's intentionally exaggerating it and making himself "unreadable"
If you flip town at any point in this game I'm going to consider this
"Also the town owes uctriton an apology for throwing him under the bus." - RXK
"I hate whoever shot triton." - Bumi
Gameplay's posts have made very little sence recently. I still don't think he's scum but I might be wrong. I think he's just bored and randomly accuses players. According to my reads both FlubberNugget and Uctriton would be better lynchs. I think we should consider these options too. My Hephaeustus read has been weakened because of his recent posts.
I'm unsure about Elmo, Muffin and Siveure – but, I don't think they're scum. Regfan, Hershey and Saki are probably town. (I know I haven't given too much new information here, check my previous posts for more arguments or feel free to ask.)
My hepha read doesn't really say scum.
More importantly, the game stalled with him being the biggest wagon... As things are, it's likely we all lurk into being forced to heph deadline-lynch. The thing is, if he were scum I don't think his buddies would leave things like this. At the least they'd probably push the wagon b/c bussing. There's definitely been no move by anyone to make sure heph doesn't die. Not even by heph.
Also LOL that reasoning can't apply to anyone else
flubber is potentially scum and not a town read. that's as much as i can really say about him. :/
he's not doing anything that particularly stands out one way or another and none of his posts really give me much of a sense of his alignment. at least not a solid sense. i get minor vibes that certain posts are more indicative of one alignment over another but really, his ISO is just a sea of null posting. i suppose this is a long and round-about way of saying that even though there's a picket riding up my ass, i'm still on the fence with him
as for uctriton, i've been deliberately staying out of commenting on him because i want to see how this uctriton vs regfan/anen thing plays out naturally without my intervention. i have thoughts, but i'm not particularly inclined to mention them right now unless the heph wagon dies and other options are being considered atm
this probably wasn't the answer you wanted, but i don't particularly care
