Chuck Season 1 - GAME OVER

[Empking]

Unvote

Vote: Dana

[mikeburnfire]

I don't like MoS's claim. Magua gives me bad vibes. Ant seems scummy. Delibird never contributed. And yet, Dana gets lynched. Whatever.

unvote, vote danakillsu

That's lynch. Good night.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Also, Magua, dana hasn't been around to stop using you and switch to me since my random wagon formed. It still stands to reason that this wagon is scum-driven, though, since no one has presented a case against me yet.

You say dana and I are the scum. That's fine. But if dana and I are the scum, and the wagon is scum driven, who else are the scum who are currently voting you? You can say "Magua", but I'm curious who of (PeregrineV, mikeburnfire, ooba, Empking) you suspect.

Also, we've got a claimed cop. You softclaiming when we've got a claimed cop, I do not like.

I have not had time to do a solid reread, so I couldn't tell you. It is just my gut feeling, because I have a hard time seeing this as a pure town wagon when not a one of you has posted a case against me yet.

I am softclaiming to try and minimize the damage done by today's wagons. I don't see how us having a claimed cop has makes you apprehensive about my claim. If anything I have more reason to softclaim *because* we already outed the cop...

[Magua]

I have not had time to do a solid reread, so I couldn't tell you. It is just my gut feeling, because I have a hard time seeing this as a pure town wagon when not a one of you has posted a case against me yet.

No matter how you slice it, if you think dana and I are scum, then when you were at L-1, the majority of people voting you must have been town. I find this argument to be entirely illogical.

I am softclaiming to try and minimize the damage done by today's wagons. I don't see how us having a claimed cop has makes you apprehensive about my claim. If anything I have more reason to softclaim *because* we already outed the cop...

Scum softclaim for wiggle room. For you to softclaim instead of hardclaim is for you to say that you, claimed, would make a more attractive NK target than a cop. I find this hard to believe.

[Magua]

Danakillsu should've been lynched by MBF in #926. Just in case:

UNVOTE: Mastermind of Sin
VOTE: danakillsu

[Thor665]

That got exciting. I just showed up to be potential Mjolnir on anything.

I'm actually fine with the softclaim - a claim of verifiable PR is a pretty potent claim, and isn't all that soft. He'll either verify and be cleared or fall short and be dead. yeah, we might be leaving a scum PR alive for a bit but I'm more than willing to roll the dice on that as I'm pretty meh on the lynch of MoS anyway - most of the flap about him appeared to be centering on Ant, and his refutation of the Ant connection case was solid and was never addressed.

I'm clinging to my Magua as town read though, I really doubt scum would behave like that all things considered. I am reminded yet again why I hate Empking. The fish avatar is apropos as he's just flopping around and I feel no connective reasoning for any of his votes. MBF can remain town. I'm happy with the dana lynch, apparently I'm the only one, but since happiness is a fungible resource so much the better for me.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I am happy with the Dana lynch, Thor. I have been trying to lynch him since day 1

[xRECKONERx]

danakillsu (6): Thor665, Ragnarokio, Ant_to_the_max, Mastermind of Sin, Empking, mikeburnfire
Magua (1): danakillsu
Mastermind of Sin (3): Magua, PeregrineV, ooba

Not Voting: ChannelDelibird

Lynch has been reached!

[xRECKONERx]

danakillsu:

Stavros Demetrios (Mafia Roleblocker)

Lynched Day 2

It is now Night 2. Night ends in (expired on 2011-06-06 00:00:00).

[xRECKONERx]

Magua:

General Beckman (Vanilla Townie)

, assassinated Night 2
ooba:

Anna Wu (Vanilla Townie)

, killed Night 2

It is now Day 3! Deadline is (expired on 2011-06-27 01:00:00).

[Ant_to_the_max]

Ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah

Empking is not a threat to the town (assuming there is no GF)
Pere is the lynch for today?
After the flip I thought a vig would know who to shoot >__________>

[PeregrineV]

@Ant- you do realize that the cop being "left alive" looks bad for you. Your results from last night.

And for now

Vote:Rag

I remember some sort of connection between the two from competing wagons day1. And since ooba and Magua were both town, I think their interactions will provide a lot of fuel.

@Mod: OP, oboe s/b ooba.

[Ant_to_the_max]

LOL

Did you spend a lot of time planning that first post of yours?

[PeregrineV]

No, why should I?

[Thor665]

Could you outline where you see Pere defending dana in Day 1 so I can get a feel for the case there? I seem to recall him helping sell dana Day 2. Also - since you're a proclaimed fluff nut for this, how "high ranking" is Stavros in the scheme of the villain team?

I'm leaning MoS at the moment, I think. He was definitely lobbing some mud at the dana case on Day 2 during the early stages and trying to pick at the logic while it was just me sort of standing in a corner.

Killed has to be anti-town considering Ant cleared ooba (and ooba was fairly obv. town anyway).
I'm guessing assassinated is too as I can't buy a Vig being dumb enough to shoot both RC and Magua.

I guess they're both doc hunting.

13 alive to start. 1 scum flip thus far, 8 alive now. I'm guessing an SK (assassinated?) and scum (killed). Certainly due to the lack of a kill Night 1 one of the scum factions (killed) was on top of the doctor situation. This bears out with their chosen kill of ooba, as they're recognizing fear of a Doc. Odds are two scum left, plus SK third party, which means we're functionally in a pseudo mylo *right now*.

Ant is highly unlikely to be scum unless scum is the assissinated team, and kill is the SK. I'm sticking to trusting him for now.

@EP - please be useful, you're confirmed town now, I expect a mega explosion of awesome from you!
@CDB - I expect a replace out or a mega explosion of awesome from you too - unless you'd like to claim scum.

I'd like to get some feedback thoughts on my mylo mutterings. Something feels janky here and I'd like some more thoughts, I'm not happy with my current conclusions.

[Thor665]

No, why should I?

Why'd you ask for his night results?

[Thor665]

I guess I could feel better if it's a two man scummorz and a single SK. I still feel janky, but less scared at that thought.

[PeregrineV]

No, why should I?

Why'd you ask for his night results?

Why woulnd't I? If he's alive he "investigated". That gives us a "confirmed" town, right?

Since he lived through the night to do it, and some top "suspects" such as ooba and Magua were killed instead.

[Thor665]

....go read his first post of the day and then come back and tell me your answer again.

[Ant_to_the_max]

I'll give you a raincheck for tomorrow because sleep beckons.

At this point I am fairly certain it is obvious who the killer is. Now to figure out what side.
Also, I have come across another interesting twist that I will keep you informed about once I figure out what is going on o.O

[Thor665]

[PeregrineV]

Ahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahah

Empking is not a threat to the town (assuming there is no GF)
Pere is the lynch for today?
After the flip I thought a vig would know who to shoot >__________>

Yeah, you're right.
Weird how I missed it between the laughter, asking about me as the lynch, and chastising the vig.

P-edit: @Ant-look forward to it.

[Ant_to_the_max]

But I am in bed ready to go to sleep...
That would involve me getting up, turning my computer on, and cranking out a case this late :'(
:sad puppy face:

You can gooogle his name and the first result is a chuck wiki page on him (I believe)

[ChannelDelibird]

OK, massive, massive apologies for failing my own ultimatum yesterday. I got back from staying with the girlfriend the night before last and just didn't find time while I was there. I'll be reading and posting thoughts tonight after my exams, I promise. If that doesn't happen, I'll replace out, but I wanna be in this game so I shall make the effort.

[Ragnarokio]

Why is ant probably town, thor?

A serial killer and a scumteam in a 13 player game seems too fast. I think LyLo would be day 2 under those conditions.