Mafia 96 - Murder in Emerald City (Game Over!)

[molestargazer]

Hi there.

Lucky (or not!) for me, I'm finishing college on thursday, so I should have plenty of time for catching up starting from then - in the meantime, I'll try and skim the last few pages, but don't expect anything of any size.

Looking forward to the game!

[iamausername]

-=Vote Count #24=-

MafiaMann (7) - SerialClergyman, Wickedestjr, roflcopter, Lowell, Faraday, Empking's Alt, Mufasa
Kublai Khan (2) - ZazieR, Namttam
VP Baltar (2) - Kise, Mastin
Mufasa (2) - curiouskarmadog, VP Baltar
Mastin (1) - Kublai Khan
ckool5000 (1) - fallen angel

Not Voting (6) - Achilles, dvdkid13, Redith, Hayker, MafiaMann, ckool5000

11 to lynch.

CLICK HERE FOR DEADLINE CLOCK

-=Hayker has been prodded=-

[ckool5000]

@ckool--read the thread and you should be able to very easily understand why I voted for Mufasa.

Oh cheese! I've read through a little more closely and that's probably the only scummy behavior I can 100% think of as scummy!

Vote: Mufasa

[ckool5000]

...Unlike me, of course.

in a sentence or two,

I want to hear

why you are considering Kub, , VP, or MM....

I also want to hear why you believe Mastin's claim and are completely not considering that it is a pre thought out fake claim.

Kublai- For reasons already stated before, thank you.

VP- Something just doesn't seem right about his posts to Mastin, and it seems like he's purposefully leaving out important info... Like the one's that Mastin bolds and increases in size.

MM- Um... To be honest I don't know. For some reason there's a bandwagon... And it all sounded like he was scummy...

Are you saying that you don't think that these three are scummy at all? Please explain.

Mastin- Meh. I believe his claim to some extent, but am willing to lynch him. It does seem like at least a somewhat realistic claim though...

Your post sounded kind of... hostile, karmadog...

if anyone has played with me..they know I hate the term "to be honest"....up until recently I thought it was a scum tell....rofl I guess proved me wrong months ago...

at any rate, what part of my question seemed hostile? Also, so what?

I bolded the parts that seemed hostile.

I guess it seems to me that you're scum trying to take control of at least an aspect or two of discussion.

[VP Baltar]

Hi mole!

pre-emptive hi Kmd!

Have fun with that reread, it's full of awesomeness and win.

[Kmd4390]

Hmm. I've got some work to do. I think I'm just gonna get into whatever discussion goes on starting now and read as I discuss so I don't do what I did in Mafia 91 (lurk because I have no clue what is going on).

If anyone has any questions for me or anything they'd like me to discuss, it can only help.

[Mastin]

Right, so I've been busy. (For once, NOT as a player! )
Now, where'd I leave off...

[Wickedestjr]

@Mastin - Can you tell me what games you have been scum and were not a replacement? Just so you know, I found games where you were town, so that't why I didn't ask for any.

[Namttam]

Also, the following people need to post something of substance: Empking, Lowell, dvdkid13, fallen angel, Faraday, Hayker, Namttam, Redith, roflcopter, and Kise.

I take a day off from posting and am called out for it.

It seems like either no one agrees that KK is obvscum or they feel like hoping a NK is used on him. Since this is the case I'll reluctantly move on.

Unvote. Vote: VP Baltar

. SC already hit the nail on the head. I was suspicious of your play when you were pushing your Mastin wagon. Now your inconsistency in behavior towards your MM wagon is suspicious as well. You then side step this issue rather than addressing it with this post.

Ok, so you agree that his reasoning is bad. The fact is that you're really buzz killing any kind of pressure that was being put on him to make him explain his actions, SC. This is really the point of my vote and it's useless now because you're sidetracking it into my reasoning for voting MM and Mastin. The fact is (which I was forced to state thanks to your questioning) that I am still am going to vote MM for today's lynch. Pressure votes don't mean anything if you say they are there for pressure. So thanks for that.

That argument is ridiculous. Fact is you didn't add anything new against MafiaMann when you switched your vote to him and afterwards. Pressure does something if you are asking questions and looking for responses, which you gave no indication of doing. That entire post was just you trying sidestep the issue which SC raised.

[Kmd4390]

Emerald City First Post

FoS:

Seryna

Kise,

Nadroj15

ZazieR

,

For being the last to confirm. It's a scum tell. (Sure, they replaced the last two to confirm, but still...that doesn't mean the tell doesn't apply.)

With that out of the way,
I'd like to do some real scum hunting, here!

Mastin Votes: Mastin.

I'm a member of Mafia A, along with...hmm...let's say...Roflcopter, Mufasa, MafiaMann, and...hmmm...Ah, yes. Kublai Khan.
Fallen Angel is also a neutral mafia traitor, who we failed to recruit last night for reasons we shalln't reveal.

Zazie is a Mafia B traitor, who can be recruited by the Mafia B faction. We want Zaz dead as soon as possible because of that.
And Kise...oh, right, did I mention Khan's a rolecop and we have daytalking abilities? Yea, we do, and Khan has revealed to us that Kise is a Mafia B godfather. Yay!

Discuss.

Ok, a Mastin game. XD.

Well first, the "last to confirm" scumtell doesn't apply here. The tell says that scum will discuss before they confirm. But why would players strategize and then be replaced in confirmations. I just don't see it.

<Insert "OMG you suck for self-voting" comment here>
<Insert "scumclaiming is retarded when you do it like this" comment>

Serious question- Why assume two scumgroups over scum/vig/SK?

[Kmd4390]

More seriously, I'm a miller. So if any cops investigated me, adjust your sanity accordingly.

Khan gets judged the same as normal. I'm ignoring the claim in any analysis on his play.

[Kmd4390]

kublai khan is town, and wins the common sense award for knowing what to do as a miller

mastin needs a new start-the-game-up gag. mastin has also committed a real scumtell, policy voting the guy who claimed miller in his first post.

vote: mastin

for great justice

whoever killed elvis has earned my eternal ire and i miss her already

Rofl would have been my first serious vote in this game.

-Declares Khan town on next to nothing
-buddies to Khan by giving him and award for "knowing what to do".
-Wrong on Mastin's vote. He called it OMGUS, not a policy miller vote.
-Takes the easy Mastin vote, apparently knowing his meta
-Comment on the NK

[MafiaMann]

KMD because of it distinctly saying cerulean mafia

[VP Baltar]

Pressure does something if you are asking questions and looking for responses, which you gave no indication of doing.

So you would say I asked no questions to Mufasa? Sure you want to stand by that one?

[Kmd4390]

KMD because of it distinctly saying cerulean mafia

And the town PMs distinctly say Emerald.

[MafiaMann]

KMD because of it distinctly saying cerulean mafia

And the town PMs distinctly say Emerald.

It also doesnt matter according to most people

[Kmd4390]

What doesn't matter?

[MafiaMann]

What doesn't matter?

Wether or not we have two mafia factions scumhunting is scumhunting

[Kmd4390]

Some reads from the first 6 pages:
ckool5000-scum
fallen angel-slight scum
Faraday-town
Hayker-town

Johnny Rotten

VP Baltar-town
Kublai Khan-town
MafiaMann-town
roflcopter-scum

[Kmd4390]

What doesn't matter?

Wether or not we have two mafia factions scumhunting is scumhunting

I agree, but I don't see why he assumed 2 scum groups before he assumed an SK.

[Namttam]

Pressure does something if you are asking questions and looking for responses, which you gave no indication of doing.

So you would say I asked no questions to Mufasa? Sure you want to stand by that one?

Wow apologies for that. I was actually talking about your previous vote on MM. I admit you did ask questions to Mufasa and the pressure vote in that case makes sense. However there is still a problem with your view on questions.

@ SC--well I think I explained my reasoning for getting off the MM wagon for now. The fact is we have 5+ days until deadline and judging from how fast people where joining it without saying much, I would rather unvote for now and come back to it. My main problem is that no one is asking him any questions or really hashing out points against him, but is just going 'I agree with Baltar, let's kill him'.

You state that you don't like how no one was asking any question of MM when you yourself didn't. You reposted a case which MM had already responded to so you hadn't really raised anything new for MM to respond to either.

[Kmd4390]

Mod

, I apologize for the smaller text in Post 918. Copied and pasted from the OP and didn't realize I left it as small text. Feel free to edit.

[VP Baltar]

You state that you don't like how no one was asking any question of MM when you yourself didn't. You reposted a case which MM had already responded to so you hadn't really raised anything new for MM to respond to either.

I completely agree that I hadn't, which is another reason why I wasn't as excited to rush toward his lynch. I need some time to look him over in iso, as well as look over his responses to my original case, to make absolutely sure I think he is the right lynch. The problem also is, however, that people seem to want to put this onus solely on me. I have no problem asking him questions, but I don't think I should be the only one doing it.

[ckool5000]

Some reads from the first 6 pages:

ckool5000-scum

fallen angel-slight scum
Faraday-town
Hayker-town

Johnny Rotten

VP Baltar-town
Kublai Khan-town
MafiaMann-town
roflcopter-scum

Please say that that's only the first six pages.

[Kmd4390]

Some reads from the first 6 pages:

ckool5000-scum

fallen angel-slight scum
Faraday-town
Hayker-town

Johnny Rotten

VP Baltar-town
Kublai Khan-town
MafiaMann-town
roflcopter-scum

Please say that that's only the first six pages.

10 pages now and those reads pretty much stand.