Mini 1859: D&D Curse of Strahd Mafia - Game Over

[culted]

Don't really like the entrance in 803 all in all like, looks like he's white knighting pine here because he's not taking an entire appreciation of the push that happened and then literally scumreading shadow just for voting pine, who's been posting more town content than a lot of people, while not acknowledging shadow's specific hangups there.

Also towards the end it's mostly bad shade-commentary. Cherry picking posts from a few of his scumreads looks less like solving them and providing examples to fit his reads.

Why this over kuroixhf or Persivul?

Because kuroi might just be annoying terrible town and persivul is among my stronger townreads.
Like, he's made more pushes (strong ones) with actual convictions than everyone in this thread. Whether misreps happened along the way or not it doesn't look like scum letting the game play itself looks like town pushing this shit along.

Where did you get the impression I had a scumread on persi?
What do you think of kuror0's case on persivul + lack of vote?

[culted]

Drealmerz waggon is bad. Pine wagon is bad. Persivul jasson would still be my top 2 scum suspects. I skimmed most of whats new due to time constriction. I will read carefully when I get home by monday we will have 4 days let of day phase so it should be enough for everyone to be active and get a better idea who to lynch.

Btw I'm still waiting for creature to explain why he said I was only fluff posting. I'm not on board on his wagon but that has been bugging me.

Scumpost.

[culted]

Seriously don't know why there isn't more votes on Drealmerz.

I can sort of understand the Pine wagon, but i'm still meh on it.

what is the case on me exactly that makes it so baffling as to why I don't have more votes?

pretty awful wagon, if you're town you should be offended to be a part of it and if you're scum you should be ashamed you couldn't come up with something better - AtE intended because ffs it's silly I'm being considered here today with what has gone on

and I'm scum because I disagree with that view? your arguments are continuously awful

UNVOTE: Creature

I should have kept it here all along, definitely the stronger scumread, no matter how much creature was pinging me

VOTE: persivul

I'M ASKING A FUCKING QUESTION TRYING TO UNDERSTAND YOUR VIEW OMG

lynch this guy pls

@People townreading this

What am I missing here?

[drealmerz7]

I'm not entirely sure, I know you're not asking me, but I'm totally town and this is me going after someone I see as scum for the reasons I've detailed in those posts.

the better question is, why are you scum-reading me?

[drealmerz7]

kuror is the towniest player in the game by SO MUCH, I can't help but think people are scum trying to discredit his sound-ness

[Andrius]

looks like he's white knighting pine here because he's not taking an entire appreciation of the push that happened and then literally scumreading shadow just for voting pine, who's been posting more town content than a lot of people, while not acknowledging shadow's specific hangups there.

No, I'm defending a townread of mine.
Also, if you look at my 803 again you'll notice that you and shadow both occupy a second group that isn't scum.
Yes, I didn't like his vote on Pine.
But I'm not scumreading him, you both are in a secondary tier of TOWN.

Town
Sly
Pine
Shaziro
Kuror0
Drealm
Dunnstral

Culted
Shadow


Scum
Creature
Jason
Kuroixhf
Persivul

TOWN is first.
Then *space* left open.
Then TOWN GROUP B which is basically here to denote they are townreads but not as strong.
Then SCUM.

Also towards the end it's mostly bad shade-commentary. Cherry picking posts from a few of his scumreads looks less like solving them and providing examples to fit his reads.

Uh, no.
I lost alot of content when I lost my post with the first 17-18 pages of reading.
Also no one wants to read an old-school replace-in wall of text so I changed my style.
I might throw things together later depending on how committed I am to read this game again. lol

kuroi could be annoying terrible town. Still a scumread.
Especially since a potential vig already has their hands full killing Dunnstral?
Never played with either of them before but ok.

I don't think I said you had a scumread on persivul.
I wanted to know why you prefer drealmerz over two options I listed. Both scumreads of mine.

Will have to look back at kuror0's case again.

I have come to expect a bit of eccentricity from drealmerz.

That's all I can say.

[Andrius]

Again, I'm also ok lynching Persivul.

You had me at the bottom of your reads list and you reiterate that you would lynch me...yet your vote is on Jason. What's up with that?

I had a bigger post which got lost so my commentary for the first 1I pages is now MIA.

Scum
Creature
Jason
Kuroixhf
Persivul

Sly I'm willing to vote any of my scumreads who do you want to die first?

VOTE: Jasonwazza
Until Sly and I sort out what we're gonna do.

Sly I'm willing to vote any of my scumreads who do you want to die first?

[Persivul]

Yes, I get that you're willing to vote anyone on your scum list. But, as your list seems to be ordered and Jason is only second scummiest out of 4, it doesn't make sense for you to start there while you wait for sly to respond to your buddying.

[JasonWazza]

Because why contribute to a real wagon when you can pretend your contributing?

[Andrius]

My scumlist isn't ordered

[drealmerz7]

wow, pers and jason so scummy wtf

can we consolidate on 1 or the other pls?

[Pine]

Okay.

VOTE: Persivul

I prefer this one. While I can see a possible Town perspective for Jason, I don't see one for the manipulating and bullying attitude Persivul has displayed.

[JasonWazza]

Remember how scum have day chat?

[drealmerz7]

even more reason for such arrogance in pers's attitude/agenda pushing

[Persivul]

Okay.

VOTE: Persivul

I prefer this one. While I can see a possible Town perspective for Jason, I don't see one for the

manipulating and bullying

attitude Persivul has displayed.

even more reason for such

arrogance in pers's attitude/agenda pushing

Yep, coordinated attack.

[drealmerz7]

yeahhhhh

[Pine]

Yes, how clever of us to coordinate right out in the open, when we have daychat.

[drealmerz7]

it would be the lamest scum-push in history I think, hahaa

[Persivul]

Yes, how clever of us to coordinate right out in the open, when we have daychat.

Point being that the nature of the attack - AtE - appears coordinated.

Bullyin

g and

arrogance

coming out like that seems like more than coincidence.

[drealmerz7]

projection of you and jason there, pers

[Pine]

Yes, how clever of us to coordinate right out in the open, when we have daychat.

Point being that the nature of the attack - AtE - appears coordinated.

Bullyin

g and

arrogance

coming out like that seems like more than coincidence.

Neither of those are AtE. If I'd said "Persivul is being mean to me!" it would be AtE. Both of those are behaviors. You're exhibiting unwarranted confidence not in line with being in the uninformed minority, coupled with disdain for those who disagree - that's arrogance. You are also attacking those who disagree with you and intimidating them into doing what you say, rather than convincing them - that's bullying behavior. There's a difference between schoolyard give-me-your-lunch-money bullying and argumentive bullying, you're doing the latter.

[Clumsy]

Lynch Votecount 1.6

(4) drealmerz7 - JasonWazza, Culted, Persivul, Dunnstral
(2) Pine - Shaddowez, KuroiXHF
(2) Persivul - drealmerz7, Pine
(1) Creature - Shaziro
(1) JasonWazza - Andrius
(1) Andrius - Creature

Not Voting:

kuror0, SlySly

With 13 alive, Majority (50%+1) is 7.

Day One Deadline is

(expired on 2016-12-16 19:00:00)

Mod notes: KuroiXHF and Kuror0 on V/LA until the 12th.
Prodding SlySly.

Happy Birthday Creature!

[/area]

[SlySly]

I am catching up. Busy weekend. Substance soon.

[Andrius]

I am catching up. Busy weekend. Substance soon.

He lives!
*fanfare*

[Persivul]

See the BP claim isn't a BP claim and its straight up Pine.
I mean. I see where has coming from but it just sounds like scum making a big fru fru over nothing.

Claims are generally analyzed. This one was unnecessary and, if true, it would have been much better for town if it had not been made. Pine himself has admitted it was an error. So, how do you conclude that it was "a big fru fru over nothing"?