Dynamite Stick Mafia! GAME OVER

[PokerFace]

Yay PEG should have done the kill and I think my voting system and push for majority hindered that. PEG was right about Surye and about Elvis. I should have listened to PEG, alot of people should have listened to him. I am glad him and you, Kuribo signed up. I am glad about alot of the people that signed up for this one. We had a pretty dang good cast of scummers for this game and I'm glad I was a part of it.

In worse idea mafia I was all about killing. Since there were no assholes or other players I wanted to instantyl kill AND also because your kill means you die I push for majority killings and other forms of order by Adel's example.

We still won though so I guess its all good.

[Adel]

I intended to kill UA with that post.
I was confident that Yos2 was scum at that point, but I felt that I had to set an example.

Thanks for winning the game for us NabNab!

[PokerFace]

Thanks for winning the game for us NabNab!

Hey don't I get anything? One of us had to be alive in order to win too despite the fact I shouldn't have been that one

[PokerFace]

GG NabNab and everybody else indeed

[Adel]

ok, here, have a Mario cookie for winning:

[The Fonz]

I intended to kill UA with that post.
I was confident that Yos2 was scum at that point, but I felt that I had to set an example.

Thanks for winning the game for us NabNab!

You were completely correct in your actions there, Adel. UA was wholly in the wrong.

[PokerFace]

ok, here, have a Mario cookie for winning:

That is awesome. Munch

[elvis_knits]

lol

I think my lurking got me into trouble here. Plus people were onto us from the getgo, even though mafia managed to make it to lylo.

I was horrified when quag replaced back into the game, and sad when BBM was modkilled. Both those things made it harder for me. If I knew quag was coming back to the game I would have NKed him that night.

It was a very interesting problem for me -- how to make someone else look scummy AND get out of doing the killing yourself. I just tried to make my best case against NN and cross my fingers. I think I should have been more proactive all game. But I was sorta scared because every time I talked there were people like quag and PEG who wanted to kill me ASAP.

Anyway, GG all, and thanks super-mod STOOF!

[Claus]

It was a very interesting problem for me -- how to make someone else look scummy AND get out of doing the killing yourself.

I guess this was the main theme of the game. I hadn't noticed it until here.

[Yosarian2]

Elvis, you did great. For a long time, when it looked like we were totally screwed, the plan became "get elvis to endgame and give her a chance". And it might have worked, too, if it wasn't for that random modkill. Ah, well. Good game, everyone.

[elvis_knits]

OMG did you crap your pants when quag came back into the game?

I did.

[Yosarian2]

Oh, yeah. So unfair; we killed him off for a reason, lol.

But, yeah. Best pro-town people this game probably were:

Elmo: Good instints there. I had thought I had just about talked myself out of trouble too, heh.

Quagmire: All around solid play.

Adel: The biggest contrabution she did to the town wasn't just the stratagy, it was that she sucessfully created a lethally effecitve pro-town block of her, Quagmire, and PEG, and that block then gave us no end of problems for days until we finally managed to kill them all off. Although I will mention that we deliberatly left her alive because I was completly confident she would end up killing some random townie for striking a light.

[Yosarian2]

I think my lurking got me into trouble here. Plus people were onto us from the getgo, even though mafia managed to make it to lylo.

Also, I don't think you really did anything wrong there. You were quite delibratly hanging out in the spot of being "not the worst lurker" but otherwise staying below the radar. That modkill was the main reason you lost that endgame, I think.

[elvis_knits]

Damn BBM and his lurking!

[Quagmire]

Yahoo! Win!

[PokerFace]

Oh, yeah. So unfair; we killed him off for a reason, lol.

But, yeah. Best pro-town people this game probably were:

Elmo: Good instints there. I had thought I had just about talked myself out of trouble too, heh.

Quagmire: All around solid play.

Adel: The biggest contrabution she did to the town wasn't just the stratagy, it was that she sucessfully created a lethally effecitve pro-town block of her, Quagmire, and PEG, and that block then gave us no end of problems for days until we finally managed to kill them all off. Although I will mention that we deliberatly left her alive because I was completly confident she would end up killing some random townie for striking a light.

Quag and Peg's suspicion were dead on for the most part. I didn't quite understand them in respect to Elvis but I guess gut is all that matters as Elmo proved.

[PokerFace]

EBWOP: Quag and Peg's suspicion

s

were dead on for the most part. They suspected the right people mostly

[Quagmire]

Oh, yeah. So unfair; we killed him off for a reason, lol.

But, yeah. Best pro-town people this game probably were:

Elmo: Good instints there. I had thought I had just about talked myself out of trouble too, heh.

Quagmire: All around solid play.

Adel: The biggest contrabution she did to the town wasn't just the stratagy, it was that she sucessfully created a lethally effecitve pro-town block of her, Quagmire, and PEG, and that block then gave us no end of problems for days until we finally managed to kill them all off. Although I will mention that we deliberatly left her alive because I was completly confident she would end up killing some random townie for striking a light.

Quag and Peg's suspicion were dead on for the most part. I didn't quite understand them in respect to Elvis but I guess gut is all that matters as Elmo proved.

I had elvis pegged because Elvis was the lone player who seemed scared to have any attention brought onto her throughout the game, which is a proper tactic among mafiosos to not be placed in a position where they have to blow themselves up. Think about it: the most active of players, with PF being the lone exception, were the ones who exploded. elvis "talked," but wasn't really 100% there and active the whole time.

[PokerFace]

Yay I kinda understand what you were getting at Now, but I didn't while I was playing. Maybe I wasn't paying antention to her well enough. I guess that's really it. Did she lurk or hide when she got suspected? Elvis did recently post something that hinted she did hide until she was more out of the light as you suggested. Wish I had noticed that while playing.

My suspicions in this game were off for the most part so it is probably a good thing that I didn't go off and Elmo did. I almost messed up this game beyond repair with a few of the cases I made and defended. Sorry I got you killed Quag, sorry I got Sarc and a lightly contributed to others deaths too.

[Elmo]

Elmo: Good instints there. I had thought I had just about talked myself out of trouble too, heh.

You were really good. I can see why you got that scummy now, hah, it would have been torture trying to get you lynched normally I can't believe CES called you 'confirmed town', lol. There was no big thing, it was just lots of little things strung together iirc.. AIM me if you're curious

Elvis was good, too. FWIW I would have picked her & Flameaxe to blow up (with slight townish read on FA) at the end, but she seemed quite natural when I was alive... I had her in a sort of 'slightly townish to neutral depending on skill' category. And that's better than most scum do

I did feel that Marmalade was obv town and it was unlikely that CES and Yos were both scum, so I didn't approve of CES - Marmalade blowing up. But I did feel that NabNab and PF were fairly obviously town, and that was good play from them, staying up, heh. But then good enough is the enemy of perfect, right?

I do think we got lucky inthat Surye made it kinda obvious that skitzer was town; without that, Elvis would have killed probably PokerFace(?) and the endgame would have been something like {NabNab|PF}, Flameaxe, Skitzer, Elvis. And if you looked over the game as a whole, Skitzer - Flameaxe blowing up is quite tempting. I thought town might lose when CES blew up Marmalade.

gg

[Quagmire]

Elmo: Good instints there. I had thought I had just about talked myself out of trouble too, heh.

You were really good. I can see why you got that scummy now, hah, it would have been torture trying to get you lynched normally I can't believe CES called you 'confirmed town', lol. There was no big thing, it was just lots of little things strung together iirc.. AIM me if you're curious

Elvis was good, too. FWIW I would have picked her & Flameaxe to blow up (with slight townish read on FA) at the end, but she seemed quite natural when I was alive... I had her in a sort of 'slightly townish to neutral depending on skill' category. And that's better than most scum do

I did feel that Marmalade was obv town and it was unlikely that CES and Yos were both scum, so I didn't approve of CES - Marmalade blowing up. But I did feel that NabNab and PF were fairly obviously town, and that was good play from them, staying up, heh. But then good enough is the enemy of perfect, right?

I do think we got lucky inthat Surye made it kinda obvious that skitzer was town; without that, Elvis would have killed probably PokerFace(?) and the endgame would have been something like {NabNab|PF}, Flameaxe, Skitzer, Elvis. And if you looked over the game as a whole, Skitzer - Flameaxe blowing up is quite tempting. I thought town might lose when CES blew up Marmalade.

gg

yos's string of death posts owned

[Cogito Ergo Scum]

Yeah, me calling Yos confirmed town to get him killed in the long run probably wasn't a smart idea. Glad we won, though.

Thanks for the game, Stoof and everyone.

[Yosarian2]

Also, Quag, it wasn't your fault you got killed there at the end; I had earlier tricked Pokerface and others into thinking there was a link between me and Marmalade, so you were already in a bad position when you replaced in.

[Surye]

Yay I'm sorry I tried to stop you Claus. I saw you get on that night and I should have switched my vote so at least you would have got Surye.

Surye's overreaction to my suspicion and constant throwing about of WIFOM was what got me convinced. Everyone was pressing for him to blow up, and he kept saying that he wouldn't until the town all agreed on it, but that point had clearly come and gone. Fortunately, in this game, we didn't have to wait for a lynching majority.

Haha, I was just trying to piss you off as much as I could so I didn't have to look like I was avoiding blowing up Yos. I knew I was dead, I just needed one of you to blow me up.

[PokerFace]

I think I was the only one you truly tricked considering the voting. I think I might have tricked myself more than you tricked me, but yay you did fool me. The others were mildly fooled since they prefered a CEScum lynching. I can't believe anyone voted him after Yos2 came up scum. I told you guys that he was much more likly to be town if Yos was scum.

I think I wasn't entirely thinking straight with that conspiracy idea. I got it becuase I suspected CEScum and he just did a major opinion change saying Yos was confirmed. I wish I could have convinced others that he was likly Town despite being a little scummy at points