Skruffs wrote:
This is the main reason you are voting for me? Because The Fonz voting him is one of the main reasons that I think Fonz was scummy.
Yes, and it's a really bad reason, hence it being suspicious.
For the record though, NOBODY else was going to be voting for Holy last night - they were all going to be voting for you. I voted QMan because, as I said, I couldn't vote for The Fonz because he was given immunity. Why was he given immunity? Because MGM and
QMan
gave it to him.
Holy wasn't alive yesterday. If you mean the day Holy was lynched, we've already established that
Farside is claiming to have cast her vote for Qman
and it was stolen by Shanba. Another two players indicated that Qman was in their top two suspects. Your statement that 'I wonder why Fonz voted Qman when it seems no-one else was going to' is
categorically false.
Also, you still haven't answered as to what you would expect a town player whose top suspect was Qman to do in that situation.
MGM and The Fonz were going into the night intending to be voting you; QMan was also going to vote you Farside. If The Fonz had voted you and not the fonz, the scum would have had a win immediately.
I assume you'd mean if I'd voted farside and not Qman. This is true, and a f***ing huge reason to believe me town.
However, The FOnz was testing MGM's thoughts shortly before deadline, TOO CLOSE to deadline, and he didn't get a good enough read on him to know if he was goign to follow through on voting you or if he would vote QMan, since hte case was stronger (I think) on QMan.
No he wasn't. He said was perfectly happy to vote Farside on my say-so. If I just continue pushing farside there, scum win. There is absolutely no explanation for my action there other than that I am town, and if you think otherwise you are frankly retarded.
So he hedged his bets, figuring that even if QMan was lynched and he helped lynch him he would have the perfect situation to get a lynch on you the next day. The risk of losing his partner but not being instant lynched was greater than the possibility of the immediate win by voting you.
That's fundamentally untrue- scum's chances in that scenario are clearly better in the scenario where I continue pushing farside. Also, and here's the kicker: since I'd been attacking farside all day, it would not make me automatically look like scum. I'd have had a half-decent chance of selling a skruffs lynch on the 'skruffs was bussing and trying to tie me to his partner' angle. (Which, to be honest, is a feeling that keeps coming back with every skruffs post).
That is primarily why I came into today thinking you were town, coupled with the reading I had started off with yesterday that suggested you were a regular town player. Your actions today, yes, they make me doubt myself a bit, but I guess that is normal.
Any chance of reading my actual case on farside, skruffs?
I am a little upset that you think I am scum because of something that actually happened *today* when you were also suspicious of me yesterday. I think it's impossible to have known I Would say that, so why else are you suspicious of me?
Fos
She's scum. It's as simple as that.
