Open 576.1: The Enemy of my Enemy is my...Enemy? (Game Over)

[droog]

VOTE: riddleton

Sorry bro
It's makes sense associatively
And 2birds seems to agree

[droog]

Actually astonished has even less on Dino that tgs

[droog]

Astonished ffs

[droog]

Astinus

[droog]

With people apparently being cleared through the nighttime investigations, I am going to

VOTE: 2birds1stone

Since he hasn't cleared yet.

This is actually really bsd

[droog]

Okay, since I apparently skimmed over why I thought I had read, I'll say this:

1. Math's townslip doesn't seem too suspicious to me. I look at it as a mistake he made accidentally and it eliminates one person on my scumlist.

2. I'm still trying to figure out Dragon's math.

3. I have a feeling Grey is subtly communicating to his scum partner how he or she should go about playing.

4. As for Egg, I'm wondering if his leave is a cover his lurking as scum and trying to stay out of the limelight.

With all that said, Grey seems the scummiest to me based on his advice to scum. Therefore...

VOTE: Grey

Math fink made a big deal out of astonished town slipping here
By suspecting grey ice for giving advice to scum

[Riddleton]

VOTE: riddleton

Sorry bro
It's makes sense associatively
And 2birds seems to agree

You're wrong mate

[droog]

yeah?

[Heartless]

Most of droog's catch up is nonsensical.

[Voidedmafia]

Votecount 3.02:

Riddleton - 2birds, droog
2birds - Riddleton

Not Voting - beast, Heartless, dragon, guille, droog, riabi

With 8 alive it takes 5 to lynch and 4 to no-lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-12-25 23:31:48) or by 9:30 PM on December 25th, 2014.

[droog]

Most of droog's catch up is nonsensical.

what about it did you not understand

[Heartless]

that's what I thought but it makes no sense to me. With mafia dead there is no need to investigate. And while I don't know whether it's the same for this games but most games I've played a scum pr can't use their ability and do a night kill at the same time it would be their partner who has to make the kill. We know that there was a kill.

this whole report claim isn't making any sense to me. It's making me suspicious of bird when I would otherwise not be. It makes no sense to lie about a report. Nor does it make any sense for an investigation to have occured

If I had to guess, it was to sew suspicion. It sounds too incredible for 2birds to have made up and thought it would pass. If he was making something up, I would expect him to have claimed results on someone else.

[Heartless]

Most of droog's catch up is nonsensical.

what about it did you not understand

The case on Astinus and why your vote isn't on the Astinus slot even though you're pointing out what you're saying are better associatives than the ones on Riddleton's slot.

[droog]

Tbh I wasn't done with my reread
When I got called away

But if you think I can't scumread the riddle slot
Then start nuking over adtinus
I don't expect you to believe me

[droog]

*thinking over

[Heartless]

It's not a matter of if I "believe" you or not. The fact is, only one of those two can be scum.

[droog]

therefore...?

[Heartless]

You're either wrong about beastcharizard or Riddleton. Which one is it?

[Heartless]

Spoiler:

Okay, since I apparently skimmed over why I thought I had read, I'll say this:

1. Math's townslip doesn't seem too suspicious to me. I look at it as a mistake he made accidentally and it eliminates one person on my scumlist.

2. I'm still trying to figure out Dragon's math.

3. I have a feeling Grey is subtly communicating to his scum partner how he or she should go about playing.

4. As for Egg, I'm wondering if his leave is a cover his lurking as scum and trying to stay out of the limelight.

With all that said, Grey seems the scummiest to me based on his advice to scum. Therefore...

VOTE: Grey

Math fink made a big deal out of astonished town slipping here
By suspecting grey ice for giving advice to scum

I actually have to take that back, I think I get the gist of your post here. You're saying that she was soft defending MathDino by validating the "town slip." The problem here is that the content of the post you quoted was a direct response to Fink's Post 45. The "defense" wasn't unprovovked, leaving the decent chance that she just happened to misread him as town.

My issue with scumreads on the Astinus slot is that she doesn't seem like the most conscientious player and that's probably the root of most suspicions of her. Her anemic posting coupled with self-destructive behavior seemed to have gotten her into trouble in the first round of this game and it doesn't look like she made much of an effort to change between the first and second round. Other supporting evidence includes the fact she refers to herself as a "shitposter" in her signature and a few of the answers to questions in her GTKAS.

[Heartless]

I still think it's droog.
VOTE: droog

[dragonspawn]

By PoE the majority of the scum is probably in Fink-or-guille, Riabi, Egg, 2birds, and NJAC's slot.

So yeah, would be down with a Riabi lynch for not doing much, but not really interested in getting people to switch over with 4 days to the deadline.

Change 'Fink-or-guille' to 'Fink, guille' because multiball and there's your scum.

Oh yeah I just realised I forgot TGS in there.

Since 2birds and droog are leaning into gut townreads, I'm going with scum in Fink, guille, Riabi, Egg, TGS.

This is interesting
Since Dino town read me and 2birds
He was most likely bussing in his scumreads

so because he was town reading you and birds he was bussing his partner? Why can't either of you be his partner?

[droog]

My issue with scumreads on the Astinus slot is that she doesn't seem like the most conscientious player and that's probably the root of most suspicions of her. Her anemic posting coupled with self-destructive behavior seemed to have gotten her into trouble in the first round of this game and it doesn't look like she made much of an effort to change between the first and second round. Other supporting evidence includes the fact she refers to herself as a "shitposter" in her signature and a few of the answers to questions in her GTKAS.

dont generally look at out of thread behavior
should i for astinus?

[droog]

By PoE the majority of the scum is probably in Fink-or-guille, Riabi, Egg, 2birds, and NJAC's slot.

So yeah, would be down with a Riabi lynch for not doing much, but not really interested in getting people to switch over with 4 days to the deadline.

Change 'Fink-or-guille' to 'Fink, guille' because multiball and there's your scum.

Oh yeah I just realised I forgot TGS in there.

Since 2birds and droog are leaning into gut townreads, I'm going with scum in Fink, guille, Riabi, Egg, TGS.

This is interesting
Since Dino town read me and 2birds
He was most likely bussing in his scumreads

so because he was town reading you and birds he was bussing his partner? Why can't either of you be his partner?

youre right i completely forgot the possibility that im dinos partner


birds isnt the partner because he's pretty much cleared

[Heartless]

My issue with scumreads on the Astinus slot is that she doesn't seem like the most conscientious player and that's probably the root of most suspicions of her. Her anemic posting coupled with self-destructive behavior seemed to have gotten her into trouble in the first round of this game and it doesn't look like she made much of an effort to change between the first and second round. Other supporting evidence includes the fact she refers to herself as a "shitposter" in her signature and a few of the answers to questions in her GTKAS.

dont generally look at out of thread behavior
should i for astinus?

I usually do. If someone has a GTKAS, I usually go look at it just to get a sense of their personality, other things. It gives a rough baseline.

[Heartless]

Why is everyone so anally fixated on bussing and looking for bussers. I thought we already established that bussing is a suboptimal strategy for this setup and that's borne out by GreyICE-Fink dynamics.

If you go search through MathDino's ISO for droog, you see they're pretty chummy. There's also this (bolded line mine for emphasis):

Oh yeah, that's a good point, forgot this was multiball. Found Fink's jumping on guille's wagon to be indicative that they weren't on the same team but totally derped on setup.

NJAC is now droog. We're not lynching him unless something goes seriously wrong in the next 4 days with his slot.

On 2birds, I'm treating him as a null mostly because while he has been different from last game, I'm not getting overly townish vibes yet. But yeah, wouldn't lynch him, just saying he's in the PoE'd out of the townpool list.

Edit: Written before mastin's wall.