Beast Charizard:
#42- You agree that Banakai's post isn't good, you would be willing to vote Bankai... and yet your vote is on Daniel Bryan? Which was a random vote? You claim it's because you want to wait for Banakai to explain themselves... but it's not like Banakai would be in any danger from a single vote. Why not add some pressure?
#69- BC says that he wants an explanation for Banakai's comment. Banakai then explains the comment in #62. Yet this warrants no comment? Why is Banakai still scummy? Why is Rational suspicious?
#94- Both RM and Banakai are on beastcharizard's "scum radar", yet neither are worthy of a vote? Why? Can't you vote them as pressure and then see how they react? Your refusal to back up your suspicions with a vote makes them feel very fluffy and weak.
#109- Now beast finally votes Banakai. What changed? Oh! BwBurke and RM voted for Banakai! Am I the only one that thinks that Beast just voted because a wagon had started up?
#114- Feels like a loaded trap question meant to paint people as scum rather than actually sort them.
#131- BC says that he thinks that RM is scum due to his playing and yet doesn't vote them. Or FOS them. Or explain why RM is even scummy.
#146- Suddenly Burke is scum! Why? I'm not sure. Beastcharizard doesn't bother to explain. And then beastcharizard takes one of RM's posts as a scum claim... and yet Banakai is still more worthy of a lynch? Huh?
#207- Now TvK is also scum? Why? Beast doesn't give the town any kind of explanation. He also doesn't explain his reads on Burke or RM, except for the latter "claiming scum". Am I the only one that feels like BC's reads are incredibly erratic and fake?
#214- There we go, here beast actually explains a scumread! It isn't an awful piece of analysis, but he attacks Banakai for only saying that RM claimed scum. This feels kind of feels hypocritical... given how the only part of the read on RM that Beast has explained is how RM claimed scum. Still waiting for more content in that regard. Also he explains an inconsistency and the explaination isn't awful, but I'd want more on exactly HOW TvK is defending RM, and why the way TvK is defending him makes them buddies. Beastcharizard is content to throw out a bunch of reads, but never explains them.
#261 feels a bit weird. There's nothing... incredibly wrong with it, but his read is crazy vague with no elaboration behind it. And apparently the only wagon he considers joining is Burke? Despite the fact that he seems to have felt that RM is scum for longer, and feels that RM CLAIMED SCUM? Man this feels fake.
Between Rainbow and charizard I would say rainbow comes across a good deal better in their conversation. Rainbow is correct, instead of actually engaging Rainbow on the reasons why charizard is scum, Charizard just goes "Oh, you're finding a lot of people scummy, so it doesn't matter." Such blatant discredting. Sure, charizard asks for an explanation, but feels the need to add in an unnecccesary jab about the amount of players Rainbow has as scummy while at it. Is this scummy? If not, then why bring it up? Does this make Rainbow's arguments weaker somehow?
#281 feels kind of OMGUSy- suddenly Rainbow is scummy too, after Rainbow does an attack on Charizard. (Interestingly, Rainbow is the fifth player that charizard has called scum! While we're talking about people who have a large scumlist...)
#316- Suddenly Team 9 is scum too! Why? No explanation. What happened to TvK? You haven't mentioned TvK in forever. Are they still scum? If not, why not? After all, you suspected him due to associative links with RM, who is still alive.
#324- I hate how bc shifts from "Well, RM is scummy" to "Well, RM makes a good policy lynch too" at the end of the post. It feels like an excuse for when RM flips town.
#383- At least this isn't an awful case on greygnarl. I'd say that this is actually the most decent rationale he's provided all game.
#390- Suddenly he attacks JD of being scum as well! This feels really omgusy. Oh, and remember when BC attempted to discredit Rainbow by saying that Rainbow had too many suspects? Here are the people that BC has suspected this game (Often giving little to no reason):
Team 7, RM, TvK, Burke, Rainbow, Banakai, JD.
*Whistle* You might want to practice what you preach, BC.
Also, BC mentions taking a stand... but the only people BC has really prodded thus far with actual votes and pressure have been relatively easy targets; Bankai and RM. He'll have more controversial reads- Team 7 being scummy, Rainbow being scummy, etc. But he never backs this up with votes. Or even FOSes.
#401- And now Bubba is scum! (Note: this is the eighth person BC has suspected this game It feels like whenever somebody starts turning their head towards BC, he comes out swinging. It's interesting how many of BC's soft scum reads happen right after a player puts pressure on him. Also, he says that he will vote Bubba... and doesn't do it. Instead staying on the greygnarl wagon. And what happened to the other 5 people you've suspected. Why is bubba scummier than them?
#423- What happened to your bubba suspicion, BC? What happened to your saying that you would be okay voting them? Suddenly you are fixated on easy-lynch Grey again.
#454- Yet another OMGUS suspicion from beast with no explanation! Cooo~oool.
#463- After talking so much about how the optimal play is to lynch the other werewolf... bubba suddenly states that he would also be willing to lynch bubba? Huh? Not to mention that his case on bubby is crazy weak.
#475- This is one of the few non-scummy posts I feel like bc has made. This whole "you think I'm scummy, lynch me!" Doesn't feel like it would come from the mafia when they have an advantage over the other scumteam. Given that charizard wasn't under all that much pressure at the time, though, it could just be posturing. In fact, that's relatively likely.
#494- Why do you need to wait until tomorrow to make your case? This feels like stalling.
#508- After all that saying that you are "100% sure bubba is scum" and that bubba is the user you want to lynch today if we don't lynch the WW... you vote Mindgamer? What??? And the case is hardly great.
#566- Why is Mindgamer suddenly above your "100% scum read" bc?
#584- A few townpoints for noting that by the logic utilized you yourself could be considered scummy. You lose those townpoints for that badly explained Team 7 read suddenly materializing again, and then not following through with a vote. Why is Mindgamer more scummy than Team 7, somebody you've been suspecting for much longer?
#589- All this random talk of your own lynch is really the only reason I'm slightly hesitant about my scumread of you; I'm still not convinced that it isn't posturing though, since you've never come under all that much pressure.
#593- So... basically... your main reason for suspecting Mindgamer is WIFOM/Gut. And this trumps your "100% scum read" on Bubba? Or how about that Team 6 read you've had since yesterday?
#627- Suddenly mindgamer is less scummy than bubbajack? And you're pushing for a bubbajack flash wagon when you've been talking about how scummy Mindgamer is all day?
#660- After all that confidence that bubba is scum the last couple days, to the point of pushing for a deadline flash wagon on them... suddenly you're all hesitant and don't want any votes on them? I suppose that this could be legitimate townie paranoia... it just doesn't feel like all that pro-town a thought process.
#709- This post gives me bad vibes. Is it because he seems to be saying "You must really believe I'm scum" to the scumread he's been badgering for most of the game, thereby implying that the scumhunting is genuine, and that thus the player is town? Probably.
#740- Wow. That is such an incredibly weak reason to not vote bubba. So what if he's active? How does that make him more likely to be town? If you're so positive that he's scum, in a situation where if we lynch we need to lynch scum... you aren't willing to vote the scumread you've been pushing most game just because he's vocal? Wha?
... So all that is said in done: BC's suspicions have not felt genuine all game. They feel really omgusy and often feel like they're attacking players of convenience, and he never votes his more controversial scumreads and attempt to make waves. The scumhunting just doesn't feel genuine, and so many of BC's posts just feel fake/scummy.
