this is news
I think that just makes you thief from my perspective
how so
cheese disappeared at 1
mallow and silverclaw both have two vouches they weren't there at 1
dragoneater and skygazer both correctly claimed a paired time without partner help
In post 71, DragonEater70 wrote:
I admit that I fucked up there, I actually realized I should've asked you to claim last but it was too late.
@Math basically this is my first time playing this and I am more or less figuring out the strategy as I go along. So yeah you are 100% correct that people you know when they woke up should claim later, that's also part of my suspicion of Mallo popcorning me.
I do now think mallow is the likely partner to ccs
As much as I think it would be rad if Snivy and Math were theatering and Math was the thief, I felt Math's reactions to my pushes were too organic so I don't think that's the case.
I mean if you think that I lied about my wake claim that also means Sky also lied. And we have someone awake at 1am (when the cheese was stolen, supposedly) who can confirm we were not there?
In post 63, NDMath wrote:
Also, I peaked at Silverclaw and saw the 6 so I know he can't be cheese thief, and it seems unlikely for skygazer to be cheese thief either since they claimed before silverclaw.
I guess this logic doesn't completely hold for skygazer since with the plan we used skygazer is allowed to either tell the truth or lie so it doesn't matter what they say as cheese thief.
But I do think saying the truthful option is much more logical for a sleepyhead there since no point lying when the person they woke up with is the only one left to claim.
If Skygazer were the Cheese thief with only their follower unclaimed, it would make perfect sense for them to choose an unoccupied slot, knowing that the follower would back them up. That's the same logic behind thief!snivy claiming 4 AM and popping mallow.
However the fact that you peeked at Silver beforehand does make it unlikelier.
Anyway it's good we have eliminated both mallow and Silverclaw as Cheese Thiefs completely, so we're never voting any of them. I am obviously not voting myself and Mallow can vouch for me not being Thief (though mallow could be lying for me).
So it's skygazer, snivy and math (FMPOV).
Skygazer I earlier dismissed as townie but I'll admit calling themself a cleared sleepyhead while being cheese thief is definitely not beyond their capabilities (I think).
Snivy I think it makes perfect sense to be the thief.
Math I thought made perfect sense to be the thief, but his reactions felt like they came from a place of genuinely believing what he said.
Also I am 99% sure Math and Snivy are not ever aligned, based on interactions.
Honestly I don't like how snivy reacted when others called him potentially suspicious, but I'm not sure if it's because snivy isn't sure how to react or if he's worried people are catching on.
