Zombie mafia - Zombies win!

[mykonian]

drunk is out of it.

[bird1111]

Aren't set-ups usually balanced on the assumption that town is slightly more likely than would happen randomly to win? And therefore playing randomly as town is almost never a good idea?

[elvis_knits]

I put a second vote on you, not even realizing it was second. L-1 is two votes. You're being overly cautious and scared.

[Kmd4390]

Who thinks we should let the game play out randomly and let the dice choose our lynches?

that was random. why do you think this is a good idea?

Anyone good at quick maths - does this set-up favor town or scum if played out randomly?

Actually...town.

But random ruins the game.

[ZazieR]

Hoopla, do we get our answers about your plan?

[Jahudo]

drunk is out of it.

your right

[Hoopla]

Who thinks we should let the game play out randomly and let the dice choose our lynches?

that was random. why do you think this is a good idea?

Anyone good at quick maths - does this set-up favor town or scum if played out randomly?

looks swingy to me, but depends on if town drunk has positive or negative powers i guess.

town drunk has been dropped.

hoopla, don't have the time now, but I would say that it is quite town sided.

really - this was done with time in mind. it's just a simple dice roll and some votes. if people deem it town-sided random lynches seem perfectly viable.

[Kmd4390]

Aren't set-ups usually balanced on the assumption that town is slightly more likely than would happen randomly to win? And therefore playing randomly as town is almost never a good idea?

Actually playing random is a bad idea because it ignores any chance of scum losing for actually being scummy.

[mykonian]

I put a second vote on you, not even realizing it was second. L-1 is two votes. You're being overly cautious and scared.

hoopla and Jahudo voted me, you are third, liar

[bird1111]

Seriously though. Does Myk need to claim for random votes? really?

Depends if anyone is willing to hammer, I'd say.

(I'm not btw)

PPE:

But random ruins the game.

QFT.

[bird1111]

Aren't set-ups usually balanced on the assumption that town is slightly more likely than would happen randomly to win? And therefore playing randomly as town is almost never a good idea?

Actually playing random is a bad idea because it ignores any chance of scum losing for actually being scummy.

That too.

[Kmd4390]

Unvote, Vote Hoopla

I don't like the random lynch idea.

[Kmd4390]

Depends if anyone is willing to hammer, I'd say.

Neither am I.

[bird1111]

Unvote, Vote: Hoopla

Most scummy thing that's happened so far.

[elvis_knits]

I put a second vote on you, not even realizing it was second. L-1 is two votes. You're being overly cautious and scared.

hoopla and Jahudo voted me, you are third, liar

I didn't even realize. We're all cross posting.

[mykonian]

unvote vote KMD

voting for someone that dares to start discussion about random lynching.

FoS Bird, Elvis

(lurking already?)

[Hoopla]

Aren't set-ups usually balanced on the assumption that town is slightly more likely than would happen randomly to win? And therefore playing randomly as town is almost never a good idea?

Actually playing random is a bad idea because it ignores any chance of scum losing for actually being scummy.

fair enough gang. was merely as suggestion - my logic with this was, how un-random will voting reasons be after 30 minutes of talk? if anything it makes it simple for clever scum to orchestrate lynches when people are searching for reasons.

[ZazieR]

Can someone explain to me why suggesting to lynch randomly is scummy?

[elvis_knits]

FoS Bird, Elvis

(lurking already?)

Nice try

[Jahudo]

suggesting random doesn't sound that scummy to me. but this game should be about playing the game. thats what makes it fun

[bird1111]

How have I been lurking?

[Kmd4390]

unvote vote KMD

voting for someone that dares to start discussion about random lynching.

I voted for who I think is scummy. Why is this vote worthy?

FoS Bird, Elvis

(lurking already?)

Bird is lurking?

[mykonian]

KMD hasn't said a thing about others, involved in theory discussion, and plays the obvious towny. Points at scum trying not to look active lurking.

connection fell away, sorry.

[elvis_knits]

Can someone explain to me why suggesting to lynch randomly is scummy?

It's not the point of the game. We're here to pick up on who is scummy and scum hunt. If we're lynching randomly you take out the human element and scum have better chance of survival.

[bird1111]

Can someone explain to me why suggesting to lynch randomly is scummy?

I don't find it that scummy, but its something, unlike anything else.