NY 169: The EPIC XD Mafia Game of Greatness (Game Over)

Empire · Post Post #6875 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 4:05 am

Day 5, Votecount 4

Titus (2)

-

Prophylaxis, Norlkaz

Ser Arthur Dayne (2)

-

Sakura Hana, pieguyn

Prophylaxis (2)

-

zMuffinMan, Titus

Not Voting (7)

-

geists, Casso the King of Seals, Ms Marangal, F-16_Fighting_Falcon, KoreanBBQ, goodmorning, Ser Arthur Dayne

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch! Deadline is on February 12th at 7:35 AM EST or in (expired on 2014-02-12 08:35:22).

Mod Notes

-

N/A

Prodding Casso the King of Seals.

Sakura Hana · Post Post #6876 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 4:07 am

Does anyone wanna do anything other than sit here and fiddle our thumbs the whole day phase?

KoreanBBQ · Post Post #6877 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 4:47 am

Here's my post that shows Bert pushing on SSK but not committing to said wagon and his reaction.

In post 6241, KoreanBBQ wrote:Is this Bert sum or Bert town?

In post 3986, KoreanBBQ wrote:
In post 3912, Bert wrote:
In post 3909, Generic wrote:That's a point. SSK claimed doc by lived through the night? When does that EVER happen?

vote mafiaSSK
Never seen it happen.
hedging. Agree with Gens "point" so it gives him the flexibility to hop on a SSK wagon if it happens.

In post 3924, Bert wrote: also, SSK's tone and wording of claiming rings off. "I'm not getting lynched this time, no I'm not" and then "I am the doctor" - hard to explain, a tonality thing. However, he sounded like his claim was full of gold medal peepee in Ace Attorney and he was scum there, and evidently he is a lurker everywhere - see that Title thread where he got nommed for lurkerscum...
still pushing the idea that SSK is scum but not committing to the wagon.

In post 4916, Bert wrote:
In post 4323, KoreanBBQ wrote:Bert is scum 'cause he was pushing on the SSK wagon but didn't join it.
How very annoying lol

And here's Gen's post (I misremembered he used "damning stuff" and not "smoking gun"

In post 6251, Generic wrote:Did he refuse to claim even at L-1? I don't remember it going down like that, but if that's true SC are fucking morons.

But that's for post game. As to your bert case, I already have my concerns about the slot, but you are in luck with the replacement. He is someone I have a decent amount of experience playing in games with on MTGS and have also hydra'd with him. If Proph has inherited a scum a lot I will know. And part of it will be if he stays quiet for long periods of time...

So with regards to your post I can see where you are coming from although
it's not exactly damning stuff
, but I have my eye on what Proph goes from here.

Sakura Hana · Post Post #6878 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 4:52 am

I'm still leaning on Titus-scum, and also Proph-scum, and indeed SAD-scum as well. Hey that's prob. all of them!

Sakura Hana · Post Post #6879 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 4:53 am

I just realized those 3 are the current 2 vote wagons on the VC

Titus · Post Post #6880 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:37 am

Sakura, if you believe I am scum with Prophy, call my "bluff" and help me "bus".

That being said, there is no logical way Generic and I are scum together. If Generic got his lynch through and I was scum it would bone his team. Respond to that or quit pushing me as scum.

Ms Marangal · Post Post #6881 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:58 am

In post 6880, Titus wrote:Sakura, if you believe I am scum with Prophy, call my "bluff" and help me "bus".

That being said, there is no logical way Generic and I are scum together. If Generic got his lynch through and I was scum it would bone his team. Respond to that or quit pushing me as scum.

I say, that is the kind of WIFOMic bus Generic lives for.

Sakura Hana · Post Post #6882 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 8:19 am

In post 6880, Titus wrote:That being said, there is no logical way Generic and I are scum together. If Generic got his lynch through and I was scum it would bone his team. Respond to that or quit pushing me as scum

That looks a lot like the cross bus we did on Duck Duck Goose tbh.

Titus · Post Post #6883 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 8:40 am

Generic would have a plan if his "bus" worked. If he actually gets me lynched, he loses. It's one thing to say wifom. It is quite another to leave his team with no out.

Generic plus 1 mafia alive (best for them that is plausible).
You've then got four heavy likely town that are not likely to be lynched. (masons, geists, cowbell)
That leaves 8 plausible lynch targets.

Generic's team cannot kill Cowbell, bc if they do Generic is lynched.
The scumteam need to get kills. They have to kill right damn near everynight to make it near lylo.

Duck duck goose is a setup Sak. Also, tbh implies you have not been honest. What game are you referencing?

Titus · Post Post #6884 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 8:41 am

In post 6876, Sakura Hana wrote:Does anyone wanna do anything other than sit here and fiddle our thumbs the whole day phase?

Yeah, lynch Proph scum.

Sakura Hana · Post Post #6885 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 9:17 am

Check the link?

In post 6705, Sakura Hana wrote:
In post 6701, Titus wrote:you really think Generic and I can be scumbuddies
Yes
Even tho the question wasn't asked to me.

Empire · Post Post #6886 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 1:14 pm

Prodding Prophylaxis and Ser Arthur Dayne.

pieguyn · Post Post #6887 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 1:18 pm

pdodge

Prophylaxis · Post Post #6888 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 1:50 pm

^

I'll post more soon.

goodmorning · Post Post #6889 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 2:24 pm

In post 6880, Titus wrote:That being said, there is no logical way Generic and I are scum together. If Generic got his lynch through and I was scum it would bone his team. Respond to that or quit pushing me as scum.

Look, you keep saying this, but with 1 or 2 other people on the team it doesn't exactly ruin anything. Just makes it slightly harder and leaves open the possibility that Gen isn't lynched.

Prophylaxis · Post Post #6890 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 6:29 pm

In post 6832, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:
In post 6830, Prophylaxis wrote:
In post 6829, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:
In post 6825, Sakura Hana wrote:Actually

Unvote
Vote: SAD

that L-1 vote was bad.
You're quite terrible at this.
Answer me.
Is my answer actually supposed to be "me" or do you have a question for me that I missed during my selective reading.

I want you to explain this:

In post 6789, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:
In post 6787, Prophylaxis wrote:
vote Titus
Bzzzzt. Nope, he's not scum. Try again.

More to the point, who do you want to lynch toDay and why?

Not a huge fan of "You're quite terrible at this" from SAD - it's a potshot, with no attempt at trying to discern Sakura's alignment.

zMuffinMan wrote:it's not actually as rare as you're making it out to be, especially in large games (i've seen much larger wagons that were entirely town on a townie - and games lost because of poor VCA like this).

Might need to take a look at D1 votals from this site - it's fairly effective on my site.

Looking at the last five Normals, with Day 1 lynches:

Apocalypse Mafia (townlynch) - TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN

WWE Mafia (scumlynch) - MAFIA, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, MAFIA

Chime Mafia (scumlynch) - TOWN, TOWN, SK, TOWN, MAFIA

FHF Mafia (scumlynch) - TOWN, MAFIA, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN

C&B Mafia (scumlynch) - TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN

Gotham Underground Mafia (townlynch) - TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, MAFIA, MAFIA

This site:

NY 167 (townlynch) -

MC Maraca

,

orcinus_theoriginal

,

Cephrir

,

PeregrineV

,

JacobSavage

NY 166 (townlynch) -

dopog, Concombre, The Purple Rose, notscience, Fegelein

NY 165 (townlynch) -

Rift Adrift, Zdenek

,

KingCrabd

,

Shadi1337, Baby Spice

NY 164 (townlynch) -

Desperado, Kublai Khan, Syryana, Nachomamma8

,

Cephrir

NY 163 (scumlynch) - ugh, can't be bothered to go through the weird votals for this one

NY 162 (townlynch) - greygnarl - 10 [L-0]

Human Destroyer

,

Bacde, Nobody Special, PeregrineV

,

petapan

...So yeah, it's really not as poor as you're making it out to be. The only town on town lynches are fairly rare.

Titus wrote:Prophy, "nice" in that context was used similar to nice try.

Hm, making a mental note of this later.

---

Going to put some more work into this game, now that I've read through. I may or may not read through the rest of the thread.

Prophylaxis · Post Post #6891 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 6:37 pm

In post 6818, Titus wrote: Prophy, nice made up stats. Day 1 has a high proportion of town, so town would have to cluster at somepoint. That's why VCA is a starting point but not an endall be all. If it was, the group would lynch Casso and Sakura no questions asked.

I feel like what you mean by vote count analysis doesn't sync with my version of vote count analysis

And see my Normal stuff if you think they're made up. I can provide you with more examples if you wish.

In post 6823, Titus wrote:Nice projection Prophy. I never said that vca isn't a vital tool. In fact, I am still annoyed with you for just cherrypicking one point. That's not vca. I am not strawmanning. Defending is not making a strawman. You are strawmanning my responses.

KBBQ, you may not agree with my analysis but being wrong doesn't mean scummy and you know it. You thought geists being scum was also ridculous.

I'm not cherrypicking; it's simply just basic votal analysis, and it's key to how I scumhunt.

As for why you're strawmanning, my reasons as to why I think you're scum are:

- "Yep, you got me" - Cephir's 154. It indicates self-consciousness.
- "safe" interactions with Cephir and MafiaSSK around the 50-page slot
- Cephir's #1036 fencesitting
- The early wagon on Stuffed Crust, and Cephir's vote on it

..while your response is:

Titus wrote:Funny how Prophy comes on and just picks the one VC where Cephir looks bad rather than doing the VCA he promised.

You choose to focus on my votal analysis, and you dismiss/discredit it. That fits the definition of a strawman to me.

Prophylaxis · Post Post #6892 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:03 pm

At the moment, my reads are:

Stuffed Crust
Tammy
Desperado
DOMO
RadiantCowbells

Prophylaxis

Ms Marangal
geists
goodmorning

pieguyn
KoreanBBQ

Casso the King of Seals
Norlkaz
Sakura Hana
zMuffinMan

F-16 Fighting Falcon
Ser Arthur Dayne

Titus

Generic

MafiaSSK

/really/ want to sort out that Not Town pile, but then I would have to slog through this thread. I'll see if I can develop a better read on Casso/Norlkaz/Sakura/zMuffin at some point.

Are we dealing with a five or four man scumteam? On MTGS it would be five, or four + SK; not sure about 'Scum standards.

KoreanBBQ

(6) - Brian Skies,

Tammy

,

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals, Sakura Hana,

pieguyn

Stuffed Crust

(2) -

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

MC Maraca

(1) -

pitoli

Casso the King of Seals (1) - F-

BROseidon

geists

(1) -

Generic

goodmorning

(1) - talah
F-

BROseidon

(1) -

Stuffed Crust

Tammy

(1) -

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

Generic

(1) -

goodmorning

Not Voting (5) -

roflcopter

,

Desperado

,

geists

,

MC Maraca

,

DOMO

MafiSSK

(5) -

KoreanBBQ

, Sakura Hana,

Cephrir

,

DOMO

,

pieguyn

KoreanBBQ

(4) -

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals,

Generic

,

roflcopter

MC Maraca

(1) -

pitoli

Casso the King of Seals (1) - F-

BROseidon

Tammy

(1) -

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

Generic

(1) -

goodmorning

Not Voting (7) -

Desperado

,

geists

, zMuffinMan,

MC Maraca

, Brian Skies,

Stuffed Crust

,

Tammy

Stuffed Crust

(5) -

pieguyn

,

Desperado

,

DOMO

,

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

(4) -

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals,

Generic

,

roflcopter

Casso the King of Seals (1) -

geists

DOMO

(1) - F-

BROseidon

Cephrir

(1) -

Stuffed Crust

MafiSSK

(1) - Sakura Hana

roflcopter

(1) -

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

MC Maraca

(1) -

pitoli

Generic

(1) -

goodmorning

DOMO

(5) - F-

BROseidon

,

Desperado

, Sakura Hana,

Stuffed Crust

,

Generic

KoreanBBQ

(3) -

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals,

roflcopter

Stuffed Crust

(3) -

pieguyn

,

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

Casso the King of Seals (2) -

geists

,

DOMO

roflcopter

(1) -

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

MC Maraca

(1) -

pitoli

Generic

(1) -

goodmorning

Not Voting (4) - zMuffinMan,

MC Maraca

, Brian Skies,

Tammy

Stuffed Crust

(5) -

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

, Sakura Hana,

DOMO

,

Desperado

DOMO

(3) - F-

BROseidon

,

Generic

,

pieguyn

KoreanBBQ

(3) -

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals,

roflcopter

Desperado

(1) -

Stuffed Crust

roflcopter

(1) -

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

MC Maraca

(1) -

pitoli

Generic

(1) -

goodmorning

Not Voting (5) - zMuffinMan,

MC Maraca

, Brian Skies,

Tammy

,

geists

Casso the King of Seals (5) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

pieguyn

,

Generic

,

Bert

Stuffed Crust

(4) - Sakura Hana,

DOMO

,

Desperado

,

Cephrir

zMuffinMan (3) -

Ser Arthur Dayne

, Brian Skies,

KoreanBBQ

MC Maraca

(2) -

Tammy

, F-

BROseidon

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(1) -

MC Maraca

Desperado

(1) -

Stuffed Crust

Not Voting (4) -

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

,

geists

, Casso the King of Seals

Stuffed Crust

(6) - Sakura Hana,

DOMO

,

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

,

geists

,

Desperado

Casso the King of Seals (4) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

pieguyn

,

Generic

MC Maraca

(3) -

Tammy

, F-

BROseidon

,

Stuffed Crust

Bert

(1) - Norlkaz
Sakura Hana (1) - Casso the King of Seals

geists

(1) -

Bert

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(1) -

MC Maraca

Not Voting (3) -

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(6) - F-

BROseidon

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

,

DOMO

,

MC Maraca

, Casso the King of Seals,

Bert

Stuffed Crust

(4) -

Cephrir

,

Desperado

, Sakura Hana,

KoreanBBQ

Casso the King of Seals (3) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

pieguyn

Sakura Hana (1) -

geists

MC Maraca

(1) -

Tammy

goodmorning

(1) - Norlkaz

MafiSSK

(1) -

Generic

Not Voting (3) -

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

,

Stuffed Crust

(6) -

Cephrir

,

Desperado

, Sakura Hana,

KoreanBBQ

,

geists

,

pieguyn

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(6) - F-

BROseidon

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

,

DOMO

,

MC Maraca

, Casso the King of Seals,

Bert

Casso the King of Seals (2) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

MC Maraca

(1) -

Tammy

goodmorning

(1) - Norlkaz

Not Voting (4) -

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

,

Stuffed Crust

,

Generic

Sakura Hana (8) -

Tammy

, Casso the King of Seals,

DOMO

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

, Sakura Hana,

geists

,

Desperado

,

KoreanBBQ

Casso the King of Seals (3) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

Generic

Stuffed Crust

(2) -

Cephrir

,

pieguyn

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(1) - F-

BROseidon

goodmorning

(1) - Norlkaz

Not Voting (5) -

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

,

Stuffed Crust

,

MC Maraca

,

Bert

Sakura Hana (10) -

Tammy

, Casso the King of Seals,

DOMO

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

, Sakura Hana,

geists

,

Desperado

,

KoreanBBQ

,

MC Maraca

,

Bert

Casso the King of Seals (3) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

Generic

Stuffed Crust

(2) -

Cephrir

,

pieguyn

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(1) - F-

BROseidon

goodmorning

(1) - Norlkaz

Not Voting (3) -

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

,

Stuffed Crust

(11) (LYNCH) -

Cephrir

,

geists

,

Tammy

,

Desperado

,

Bert

, Sakura Hana,

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

, Norlkaz,

pieguyn

,

KoreanBBQ

Casso the King of Seals (3) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

Generic

MafiSSK

(2) - Casso the King of Seals,

Ser Arthur Dayne

F-

BROseidon

(1) -

MC Maraca

Sakura Hana (1) -

DOMO

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(1) - F-

BROseidon

Not Voting (1) -

Stuffed Crust

This is all of the five vote wagons on Day 1, where the most benefit can be had to votal analysis.

(ignore the username mangle, going to look at this in my next post to keep them separate)

Sakura Hana · Post Post #6893 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:11 pm

Nice to see someone see things in an unbiassed way.

Ser Arthur Dayne · Post Post #6894 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:36 pm

In post 6890, Prophylaxis wrote:More to the point, who do you want to lynch toDay and why?

Scum:
Prophylaxis
pieguyn*

Town:
Ms Marangal
Casso the King of Seals
Norlkaz
goodmorning
Sakura Hana
Titus
KoreanBBQ

Have to look over:
F-16_Fighting_Falcon
geists
zMuffinMan

*Generic-Pie interaction looks so staged. So, so staged.

In post 6890, Prophylaxis wrote:Not a huge fan of "You're quite terrible at this" from SAD - it's a potshot, with no attempt at trying to discern Sakura's alignment.

It probably has to do with that fact that I already think she's town.

Prophylaxis · Post Post #6895 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:39 pm

KoreanBBQ

(6) - Brian Skies,

Tammy

,

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals, Sakura Hana,

pieguyn

This wagon is worth revisiting, though I do believe it was mostly compromised of RVS votes?

Going to use Brain Skies as an excuse to talk about Llamarble.

Honestly surprised that I don't have a read on Llamarble yet, since I got a healthy respect for his game after avidly following Cross Town shenanigans. His scumteam prediction is three town (me/goodmorning/Tammy) and I don't know the alignments of Cephir and Casso.

Looking at his ISO, he defended MafiaSSK pretty hard, but my main problem with Llamarble is that he's just consistently wrong. I'm not exactly sure how it translates to alignment, though. He locked down the scum pretty hard in Cross-Town 2, IIRC. He's just throwing down conclusions and doing stuff without reasoning, and I can't really read someone who doesn't show me his thought processes. Is this how Llamarble usually plays?

Is it too much to ask for:

Llamarble wrote:I have plenty of towntells I am aware of but cannot fake.

?

MafiSSK

(5) -

KoreanBBQ

, Sakura Hana,

Cephrir

,

DOMO

,

pieguyn

KoreanBBQ

(4) -

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals,

Generic

,

roflcopter

This wagon is why I have a townread on KoreanBBQ, plus the fact that he was the counterwagon to MafiaSSK. I'd expect one scum bussing, and Cephrir is the most likely candidate.

All of the scum were on Korean's wagon.

Stuffed Crust

(5) -

pieguyn

,

Desperado

,

DOMO

,

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

(4) -

MafiSSK

, Casso the King of Seals,

Generic

,

roflcopter

Casso the King of Seals (1) -

geists

Wagon that scumfirmed Titus's slot, IMO. The Day 1 end of vote wagon also doesn't bode well for Titus.

DOMO

(5) - F-

BROseidon

,

Desperado

, Sakura Hana,

Stuffed Crust

,

Generic

Doesn't tell me much, because Generic was at the tail end of this wagon.

Stuffed Crust

(5) -

Cephrir

,

KoreanBBQ

, Sakura Hana,

DOMO

,

Desperado

Cephrir/Sakura probable scum, on this.

Casso the King of Seals (5) - zMuffinMan,

goodmorning

,

pieguyn

,

Generic

,

Bert

Stuffed Crust

(4) - Sakura Hana,

DOMO

,

Desperado

,

Cephrir

Again, can't get much out of this, considering Generic was voting Casso.

Second wagon is much the same.

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

(6) - F-

BROseidon

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

,

DOMO

,

MC Maraca

, Casso the King of Seals,

Bert

Stuffed Crust

(4) -

Cephrir

,

Desperado

, Sakura Hana,

KoreanBBQ

Gut says that Stuffed Crust is the town!counterwagon to scum!F-16, though that just might be confirmation bias.

Would look at SAD then Casso in this, or it's possible that all the scum just piled onto SC.

More of the same with the next.

Sakura Hana (8) -

Tammy

, Casso the King of Seals,

DOMO

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

, Sakura Hana,

geists

,

Desperado

,

KoreanBBQ

Why is Sakura voting herself?

Would want to burn SAD for this, alone.

Sakura Hana (10) -

Tammy

, Casso the King of Seals,

DOMO

,

Ser Arthur Dayne

, Sakura Hana,

geists

,

Desperado

,

KoreanBBQ

,

MC Maraca

,

Bert

...Yeah, that's a ton of town on this wagon, besides SAD.

Stuffed Crust

(11) (LYNCH) -

Cephrir

,

geists

,

Tammy

,

Desperado

,

Bert

, Sakura Hana,

MafiSSK

,

F-16_Fighting_Falcon

, Norlkaz,

pieguyn

,

KoreanBBQ

SCUMMY, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN. Lynch ittttttttt.

I would expect at least two scum in this wagon, including SSK, probably three.

I'll go ahead and do Day 2 soon.

Ser Arthur Dayne · Post Post #6896 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:40 pm

In post 4693, Generic wrote:Also DOMO, you need to get the geists paranoia out of your head.

In a game this size what are the chances you hit the only role you feasibly will read a scum player as town with?

Interesting...

Ser Arthur Dayne · Post Post #6897 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:42 pm

VCA doesn't really work when you already have reads then go in and twists things so they can fit your reads

Ser Arthur Dayne · Post Post #6898 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:45 pm

Example:

In post 6895, Prophylaxis wrote:
Stuffed Crust
(11) (LYNCH) -
Cephrir
,
geists
,
Tammy
,
Desperado
,
Bert
, Sakura Hana,
MafiSSK
,
F-16_Fighting_Falcon
, Norlkaz,
pieguyn
,
KoreanBBQ

SCUMMY, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN, TOWN. Lynch ittttttttt.

I would expect at least two scum in this wagon, including SSK, probably three.

Well not shit you expect "at least two scum in this wagon, including SSK, probably three", you already told us you think ceph and f-16 are scum. You have 2 of your scumreads on the wagon, and then claim there are 2 (+mafiassk). Fascinating analysis!

Prophylaxis · Post Post #6899 (ISO) » Fri Jan 31, 2014 7:45 pm

In post 6893, Sakura Hana wrote:Nice to see someone see things in an unbiassed way.

Can you get more noncommittal than this?

Because when I last checked your read on me was:

In post 6878, Sakura Hana wrote:I'm still leaning on Titus-scum, and also Proph-scum, and indeed SAD-scum as well. Hey that's prob. all of them!

In post 6894, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:
In post 6890, Prophylaxis wrote:More to the point, who do you want to lynch toDay and why?
Scum:
Prophylaxis
pieguyn*

Town:
Ms Marangal
Casso the King of Seals
Norlkaz
goodmorning
Sakura Hana
Titus
KoreanBBQ

Have to look over:
F-16_Fighting_Falcon
geists
zMuffinMan

*Generic-Pie interaction looks so staged. So, so staged.

In post 6890, Prophylaxis wrote:Not a huge fan of "You're quite terrible at this" from SAD - it's a potshot, with no attempt at trying to discern Sakura's alignment.
It probably has to do with that fact that I already think she's town.

In post 6890, Prophylaxis wrote:More to the point, who do you want to lynch toDay and
why
?

Bolded for emphasis.

And then there's me wondering why you have me as a scumread, yet you're not voting me.

In post 6896, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:
In post 4693, Generic wrote:Also DOMO, you need to get the geists paranoia out of your head.

In a game this size what are the chances you hit the only role you feasibly will read a scum player as town with?
Interesting...

Why's it interesting?

In post 6897, Ser Arthur Dayne wrote:VCA doesn't really work when you already have reads then go in and twists things so they can fit your reads

I'm clearing people based on good reasons.

I go through my scumreads first, then lynch anyone that's a Not Town read that's hanging out with a town crowd.

It's worked for me in dozens of games.