Mini 1473 - Super Smash Bros. Mafia (Game Over!)

[Seanald]

and it's not Kthx. That leaves 5 names.

out of the 5 names, who do you think most likely to be the scum? and what makes you think Kthx couldn't be scum, now that we have only had town deaths.

Also what is the arguement that mass claiming right now is a good idea? I've only ever seen it not work in towns favor so could someone please explain that to me.

[Seanald]

Votecount 1.17

Keybladewielder

(7) - Zdenek, Mr Subliminal, DCLXVI, Seanald, FakeGod, Kthxybye,

pieceofpecanpie

(Lynch)
FakeGod (2) -

StubbsKVM

, d3x
Zdenek (2) -

Keybladewielder

,

Andrius

DCLXVI (1) -

Darthe

Votecount 2.2

Darthe

(5): Kthxbye, d3x, Zdenek, Seanald, DCLXVI (LYNCH)
Mr Subliminal (1):

Andrius

FakeGod (1):

Darthe

Seanald (1): Mr Subliminal

Not voting (1): FakeGod

This is really all we should be looking at today.

FG, Sub, and Zdenek are probably my best bets on who is scum.

[Seanald]

eh shit, re-thinking it maybe DCL is ATE-ing the hell outta us.

also quite honestly DeX, your not excluded from being scum, your the only one off that day 1 wagon not confirmed to be town. that looks pretty fuckin suspicous to me.

[Seanald]

also DeX with you being a pretty pivotal player in this game, why hasn't the scum killed you yet? your basically one of town's leaders why arn't they threatened by you?

[FakeGod]

Massclaiming at LyLo is protown, since:

Massclaiming gives setup information to the town at the cost of outing town PRs.

At LyLo, outing town PRs is no longer an issue, since lynching right is the only thing that matters at that point.

[FakeGod]

Seanald, claim your role and popcorn the next player please.

[d3x]

out of the 5 names, who do you think most likely to be the scum?

See...

It would make a whole lot of sense for FG to be Scum {or 3rd P} with his on1 off1 as well. Consider my Vote here.

what makes you think Kthx couldn't be scum

I have my reasons. I'll let him discuss them if he wishes.

quite honestly DeX, your not excluded from being scum

From my POV, I'm obv excluded. I don't believe in marking myself green, though as I'm not confirmed to anyone but myself. What exactly do you hope to gain by pointing out to me that I'm not ConfTown?

also DeX with you being a pretty pivotal player in this game, why hasn't the scum killed you yet? your basically one of town's leaders why arn't they threatened by you?

I'm assuming it lies in my Tunnelling on Darthe and DCL. I'm willing to bet I'm probably also wrong on that account. Mostlt it has to do with his Targetting me N1 {I don't see a ScumMotivation to Track me}, though I do hold some reservations. I think they're are probably banking on me going after DCL Today because of the Hammer and my previous inclinations.

[d3x]

And ftr- I'm against MCing until after DCL posts. If he comes back Tracking someone to the Kill, there's no reason to out the rest of the Roles and hand Scum a roadmap.

[FakeGod]

I disagree. DCL claimed a town PR and did not die last night.

I see no reason to blindly trust him at this point, especially since scum_DCL could simply frame a townie for instant win.

MassClaiming is the correct strategy.

[d3x]

Hmm... I need to rethink my FG-Scum position. AntiTown, sure, but Scum...? The only way that would work is if they had 2 Kills N1 or he Claimed the ScumKill as Scum.

FG- Congrats on disagreeing.

[FakeGod]

I detect sarcasm. d3x, are you against a mass claim?

Unless you have some way of knowing that town is not in

LyLo

right now, your move is incredibly

anti-town

, since mass claim is one of the strongest moves town could employ at

LyLo

.

[d3x]

I'm against MCing until after DCL posts.

Umm...

[Seanald]

lol

[FakeGod]

I don't understand. Why are you waiting on DCL's post?

DCL claiming a tracked kill means nothing, as I already mentioned.

[Seanald]

then by extension so does you claiming your vig who shot popp.

[FakeGod]

By what extension?

I'm Un CC'd Vig with a confirmed kill.

Scum_DCL lying about a tracked kill can instantly win a LyLo.

How are these two scenarios even remotely similar?

[FakeGod]

I'm frustrated.

Day one

, town player apparently lied about his role for no good reason.

Day two

, when the lie's revealed by the town backup, he's quicklynched in case he's lied about lying.

Now,

Day three

, with town almost certainly in LyLo, people are refusing to mass claim.

I shouldn't have to pull teeth to get town to do the obviously protown move.

I'm going to go cool off before I start hurling profanities at internet strangers.

[Oversoul]

Yesterday's Lynch VC has been corrected.

[d3x]

I don't understand. Why are you waiting on DCL's post?

DCL claiming a tracked kill means nothing, as I already mentioned.

And as I've already mentioned, I have a TownRead on the unCC'd ConfTracker. So I'll thank you to settle down. Not everyone will agree with your line of thinking for the most proTown course of action.

[DCLXVI]

I targeted andrious, I didn't like his reaction to darthe. I do know who he visited and I may choose to reveal that information later, It's something I need to think about.

Seriously annoyed by KBW's apparent lying about his role, I do wonder thought if it is possible that he didn't understand it and took singing to equal role blocking caused it seemed logical to him.

I am slightly concerned with d3x, I know for a fact that he is a pr as he visited me, he can't be a roleblocker because my action succeeded, the issue is I am having a hard time seeing more town roles in the game.

Also, I believe the vig claim by FG.

[DCLXVI]

I know I am town.
I think it is reasonable to conclude that FG is town, he is not 100% confirmed by any means but he is certainly more likely to be town.
I am having a hard time figuring out a scum role which d3x would have targeted me with. Can't be a roleblocking role, not killing, if he was a tracker/rolecop I have to wonder why I was not killed because I could have gotten a guilty last night which would have made things much more complicated for scum, thinking this through, I'm rather certain he is town.

Also, my ability is 2-shot which I may or may not have said earlier, the fact that it is x-shot does open the possibility for more town power roles.

So that leaves open a group of the four remaining playrers (3 of whom are scum), I like our odds of getting a scumflip today.

[Seanald]

its probably subliminal then.

[DCLXVI]

honestly this is just confusing, I'll back tomorrow and think about it.

[Magua]

Seanald, we're massclaiming. It's not really up for debate at this point. So go get your fakeclaim from the mod and tell us what it is. plznthx.

[FakeGod]

Seanald, please claim your role and popcorn the next person.