Stam, I do think we should state who we think should be lynched (especially our confirmed innocents should state their top 3), but I'm disinclined to set a "lynch order" for them now, as on future days scum might avail their responsibility to their vote by simply following a predetermined lynch order. In any case, here is my post review:
Our innocents:
Bamboomancer the wealthy businessman
LoudMouthLee the innocent child
'Nuff said.
Our suspects:
Coron the townsperson
Was suspicious of the cops. Only ever voted for Assasin. Out of anyone. Ever.
PeaceBringer the townsperson
Voted Assasin, StD and Crola. Unusual comment, though, here:
PeaceBringer wrote:Oh and nonchalance, I hate this since you townie and all but you SHOULD NOT BE PMING PEOPLE PRODS TO VOTE. VIOLATION OF THE RULES AND SHOULD GET YOU MOD KILLED!
I have no problem with the yelling for severely violating rules, but the use of the wrd "townie" here is striking. He's presuming her innocence. Guess where my vote's going to end up?
Mastermind of Sin (replacing BabyJesus) the townsperson
Mastermind of Sin wrote:vote: crola
I haven't really liked the way Nanook has been playing, so I think his reasoning for the Jerry vote was to perhaps protect scumbuddy crola, so I think I'll go with that.
Votes Crola earlier (not on the lynching of Crola) instead of Nanook (where his justification expects a vote for Nanook), but does so in a way trying to clear JerrytheBean.
Mastermind of Sin wrote:lol, my activity won't help you... look at the last two newbie games I finished. I was an über lurker, and I won them both as scum.
???
Isn't that a potential pattern? Seems like trying to preemptively steer us away from looking for recent patterns in his play.
Also, re: his predecessor, BabyJesus voted for JerrytheBean right off the bat, then moved to be on the FD2 lynch. Voted Assasin (to the lynch) and Peacebringer (at an off time). Has posted many, many excuses for lack of participation/contribution, despite being a replacement player.
Thesp (replacing sycko999) the townsperson
It's not me.
PookyTheMagicalBear the townsperson
Was on FD2 lynch and Assasin lynch. Voted StD, and has been adamant about lynching excons throughout game. Given both our excons were scum, I'm thinking Pooky is unlikely as scum.
Stam (replacing HairyMezican) the townsperson
Lurker hunted at start of replacement. Wanted to lynch Crola pretty fiercely.
His predecessor voted FD2 not caring if he was mafia or not, and voted assasin.
In retrospect, I don't know why I bothered saying anything about anyone's votes on Assasin, as he was obviously guilty and obviously everyone voted for him.
In any case, since we have three lynches left, I'm inclined to think right now that our best bets are with PeaceBringer, Mastermind of Sin, and Coron. I think it's highly probable our last scum is with them. The quote from PeaceBringer disturbs me the most, and I think he's most likely to be scum.
Vote: PeaceBringer
.
I also think setting up an "order of lynches" will be unhelpful for figuring things out on future days, should we not hit today. I hate to say this, but I will need a day or two to re-read our living players' posts and voting patterns.
