Mini 916 ~ Brrr Mafia. GAME OVER

[camn]

BLOCKED

[The1fifi]

Weighing in on the whole flavor thing, the problem with the word "multiple" is that it's not a clear number of shots. It's hard to accept that as proof that it indicates a vig and mafia kill under the logic that each got a shot, when multiple is not clearly two shots, but could be more than two shots.

That's just the issue I'm seeing with using the flavor either way.

The question is.. can you read that flavor as a TOWN VIG, with ONE BULLET killing regfan.. whilst the scum attempted to kill Wacky? Cuz I can't.

Single scum kill? yes.
Multiple kill? YES.

But none of these options has Wacky as a target, or Wacky as scum.

This is true, and if jasper is indeed one-shot vig, we can't say wacky is blocked scum

[The1fifi]

But i agrew with Seven about waiting for Mcz replacement.

[Zachrulez]

I noticed that you decided to vote Jasper afterall Fifi. Did you change your mind about your belief that he's town?

[The1fifi]

Two things made me vote him:

-First, i realized i was believing him too much. this is mafia, fifi, you dolly -.-

-Second, after all the claims, and not-claims, and claim fishing.. He is the best person to be lynched in terms of info. The thing is: There is a strong probability of him being scum. If he isn't, it can also be considered a policy lynch. I think it really is our best option

[Sotty7]

14th Vote count of day two

Jasper 4: (Wacky, Seven, jbernier93, The1fifi)

Seven 1: (Jasper)

Not Voting 5:

McZombie, jasonT1981, Nikanor, Zachrulez, Camn

-McZombie is being replaced
-With 10 alive it takes 6 to lynch
-Deadline is 3/8 @ 8am CST

[Sotty7]

Incognito replaces McZombie. Much love.

[camn]

HAHAHA!

PBPA, please!

[Incognito]

Hi.

I've run out of replacement lambs' tails so now I just read threads in three flutters of a kitten's heartbeat (

translation:

I should have this read by, uh, tomorrow? especially if I have a snow day...).

Actually, I offered to replace in awhile ago cuz I wanted to play with camn. HI CAMN! <3 and HI ZACH AND NIKANOR! For those of you who don't know me, I'm Incog. I'm a Libra who enjoys short walks on the beach, candledim dinners, and duck. Lots of duck.

Apparently, I'm so cool that I also cause Critical Errors to the site. Clearly, the scumz are already terrified.

[jasonT1981]

Incognito, welcome to the game.

[jbernier93]

PBPA

I keep seeing that and wondering what the hell it means?

Anyway, as Jasper is continuing to basically ignore the accusations of him and say "I'm a oneshot vig, don't lynch me!" or say nothing at all, I continue to be happy with my vote.

[jasonT1981]

PBPA

I keep seeing that and wondering what the hell it means?

Anyway, as Jasper is continuing to basically ignore the accusations of him and say "I'm a oneshot vig, don't lynch me!" or say nothing at all, I continue to be happy with my vote.

PBPA - Post by Post analysis... I think Camn is just playing though.

As to your point on Jasper, I am gonna do an Iso on him tomorrow... sorry I had my appeal I mentioned earlier in the game today, and am mentally drained... had to start travelling at 6am for a meeting at 10am, then didnt get back home until 4pm.

@JT: Whether there is a Jasper&Fifi scumteam doesn't really matter. Jasper is scummy independently of Fifi, how does this affect your vote? (Or does it, even)

I'll answer this quickly, as I said I am unwilling to lynch Fifi today, given the infomation he provided did prove to be correct... I had a long think about that last weekend as I already had mentioned.

Jasper, I am gonna look at closer as I said tomorrow. Though the fact he was found to have a gun, and admitted to killing Reg is something I can not ignore. even with the drunkenly insane amount of WIFOM involved.

[jasonT1981]

For those of you who don't know me, I'm Incog. I'm a Libra who enjoys short walks on the beach, candledim dinners, and duck. Lots of duck.

You sound perfect, we have beach in my home town under mountains with lots of intimate restraunts that serve duck, we also have lots of duck pools if you mean feeding them and not being fed by them...

Wait MS is not a dating site...

[Incognito]

Wait MS is not a dating site...

It isn't? I guess I've been wasting my time kicking it to camn then.

-~-~-~-~-~

Just to give an update to you guys as to where I am: I'm up through about page 15/16.

I really like The1fifi's claim, and I think he's very likely a town Gunsmith. In my experience, I've found that newer players have a tendency to claim prematurely out of enthusiasm or excitement with a particular role, and my general feeling is that's probably what The1fifi did when he entered the game at the start of Day 2 up through the point that he claimed. His vote on Jasper makes perfect sense looking at it through that perspective, and I really don't think a player of his experience level would have the cahunas to fakeclaim a Gunsmith role the way he did (I can't even think of a logical reason for him to do it -- a wagon wasn't on him at the time so it's not like he was forced to a claim, and if he was scum, I'd think he'd want to AVOID attention rather than draw it to him with a claim). Also, he just feels really genuine to me, and I think that's something that's really difficult to fake.

On the opposite end of the spectrum, I really don't like Jasper's reaction to the claim at all. If Jasper was town, I really don't think his natural response would be to vote the person who would have essentially "proven" to have role-based info on the type of role he had. I'd think he'd probably ask The1fifi how he knew about his supposed role or even to just outright claim or hint SOMETHING rather than knee-jerkingly vote the guy.

@Jasper:

have you ever had experience with a Gunsmith role prior to this game?



I'll post my thoughts about the other players once I've completely finished my read. I'm more of an "in the moment" kind of player though, so I felt like jumping in and trying to get more of a feel for the players right away.

[Jasper]

No, Incognito... I had never encountered the gunsmith before.

[The1fifi]

No, Incognito... I had never encountered the gunsmith before.

You are not gona adress anything else?

[The1fifi]

And welcome Inc!! Good luck.

[Incognito]

Jasper: I guess the better question is had you ever

heard

of the Gunsmith role prior to this game?

[Seven]

On the opposite end of the spectrum, I really don't like Jasper's reaction to the claim at all. If Jasper was town, I really don't think his natural response would be to vote the person who would have essentially "proven" to have role-based info on the type of role he had. I'd think he'd probably ask The1fifi how he knew about his supposed role or even to just outright claim or hint SOMETHING rather than knee-jerkingly vote the guy.

I'm not sure yet if I agree with his stance on Fifi, I'm still wavering on that and will wait to see if Jasper flips but I love this part. This is exactly why I love replacements. I hadn't thought about this, they tend to bring something new to light. Good feel on him so far.

@Jasper: Are you ever going to bother addressing anything I said in the ISO I did of you? You asked me what you could do, and you haven't done anything except respond to the occasional question. I'm starting to think you don't want to say too much in case you slip up and leave hints about your scum-buddies.

[Jasper]

Jasper: I guess the better question is had you ever

heard

of the Gunsmith role prior to this game?

No, I hadn't.

[Seven]

@Jasper: Are you ignoring because you think I'm scum or because I'm sexy and it makes you nervous?

[Jasper]

Maybe a little of both?

[Jasper]

Right now, I haven't had the time to go to that post and quote every point and say things about each one. But if I believe you to be scum (as I do), it wouldn't make a difference because you already know me to be town.

[The1fifi]

Right now, I haven't had the time to go to that post and quote every point and say things about each one. But if I believe you to be scum (as I do), it wouldn't make a difference because you already know me to be town.

Really? What about the other players? You sort of need to prove us your alignment, or share your toughts. Thats what a town player would do, not just give up. Which makes me more confident we gona see you flip scum.

[Seven]

You don't know if I'm scum, though. I'm claiming town just as you are. I'm already voting for you anyway, what do you have to lose?