Open 175 - Picking Simplicity (Game Over)

[Toro]

Are you 100% sure that yabbaguy is town?

[Scott Brosius]

I don't like the Wifom more than I did before, but I'm not as bothered by Iguana, and I don't think we'll get any farther.

Can you tell me why you were confused over Iguana's role?

Well, as Wifom is usually confusing...

She's insinuating that she could be a PR, trying to pull in NAs, but that she could be a VT attempting to pull in abilities to avert them from real PRs.

But she could still be scum attempting to confuse people/cause people to think that she is either a VT or PR, one or the other.

WHY DOES TOWN CARE IF IGUANA IS A VANILLA OR A POWER ROLE?

Anyone who is trying to sniff this out probably isn't town

[Col.Cathart]

Re-read in progress.

[skitzer]

Can someone tell me how the zwet in this game is different from the zwet in every other game? Maybe then I'll consider a vote.

Allow me to just speculate and elaborate on where you seem to be headed. Zwet is always useless/scummy. Due to that, he should never be lynched because statistically he is more likely to be town. I would actually argue someone who is ALWAYS dead weight and inherantly scummy should be policy lynched, and will explain why if you want me to.

So why are we lynching him if it's not a good idea???

no no no... thats what YOU seem to be saying. Not me. You are starting to wander down the "he is always scummy, lets not lynch" path. I am trying to point out that massive pit filled with spikes, those creapy yellow spiders, and tiny yappy worthless dogs that you are going to fall into if you go much farther.

I wouldn't have to keep asking it if someone just gave me a straight answer the first time.

[zwetschenwasser]

Warwound seems to be hiding behind his inexperience to gloat about his scum immunity from everyone calling him antitown.

[yabbaguy]

Brosius, I'm construing you as an active lurker right now. Please convince me otherwise.

WarWound-597 + 599 is now outright scummy. Gloating about merely surviving the game and then trying to drag me down with him over a REALLY random thing is not something to be overlooked.

The fact that zwets is going after WarWound is screwing me up a bit, but there are probably multiple explanations for that.

[WarWound]

alright alright, and im not trying to ring you down? he used the same logic like that for me and iguana, im just mocking him

[zwetschenwasser]

alright alright, and im not trying to ring you down? he used the same logic like that for me and iguana, im just mocking him

I rest my case.

[WarWound]

Warwound seems to be hiding behind his inexperience to gloat about his scum immunity from everyone calling him antitown.

ur case doesnt have anything to do with my above post?

[zwetschenwasser]

It sure does. Notice your sentence "im just mocking him". You show an arrogance and an immunity to any scumreads just because of your inexperience with mafia, and no one seems to care.

[Pomegranate]

@Semioldguy- I need to replace out due to certain RL situations.

[Pomegranate]

@Semioldguy- Actually, scratch that. I think I'll be able to continue.

[dramonic]

your RL issues sure solve themselves quickly 0-o

[Pomegranate]

I think I can manage. But if it needs to happen, I may replace out.

[WarWound]

It sure does. Notice your sentence "im just mocking him". You show an arrogance and an immunity to any scumreads just because of your inexperience with mafia, and no one seems to care.

it appears that i have been bested!

[Nikanor]

I'm happy with lynching WarWound. He's not even trying to scumhunt. I can see him being town if he were trying and failing, but he's not even making the attempt.

Unvote. Vote: WarWound.

[semioldguy]

Yankee replaces Hyl.

[WarWound]

hello yankee

[Yankee]

I am replacing in, dont have time to read the thread right now, but i will try to later tonight. Good to see some familiar faces too

[yabbaguy]

Just don't be too slow, Yankee. I know Macs can be like that.

[Yankee]

oh hush.... Reading now, will try to get as far as i can. And yes, i am on a mac, which is actually very fast thank you!

[Col.Cathart]

Ok, my current thoughts after re-read (sorry it took so long. I just got back from the Soccer tournament on my university, and I had rest for some time ):

12KB/Antihero - Complete null. One was inactive and unhelpful. The second one made a decent start and disappeared as well. Last post by him was made whooping 11 days ago.

Mod, please prod or replace Antihero

Blastinus - Still scummy reading. Going after opportunistic wagons, refusal to give us some more thoughts. I know he's new to mafia scum, and he don't know most of the unwritten rules/tells here, but I'm not going to give him the 'get out of jail for free' card because of this this.

Dramonic - Never played with him, but for some reason I'm assuming, that's his normal playstyle. Anyone who played with him can confirm that? If yes, then I guess he's somewhere on the line between neutral and slightly pro-town.

Flava Flave - Strong town read ATM.

Grimmy - Tough stuff. He is always at the verge of inactivity prod (oh, btw:

Mod, please prod Grimmy

), but I'm getting gut town read from his posts so far.

H_H - Gut + meta town read. I personally believe he has a better chance of being SK rather than Mafia (if any).

Iguana - Still don't see that case on her. Maybe she's pushing that zwet wagon a bit to hard, but I can see reason why she would do that. Town read.

Nikanor - again, can someone tell me if this is his usual behavior, regardless of alignment? Gut town read.

Pomegranate - Still strong scum readings, for reasons mentioned earlier. She did nothing so far to convince me otherwise.

Scott Brosius - One sentence every few pages of discussion is not enough. I think that Iguana called him town waaay too fast. Neutral reading, leaning toward the scum parts of the axis.

Brothetnature/Skitzer - Usually that kind of posts, he's making should make me think he's pro town, but my gut screams something is wrong in here, although for now I cannot localize the problem. I'll certainly watch carefully his posts in later game.

SpyreX - I like his play so far. Town read.

Toro - Strong town read, although he IMO spends too much time on WarWound, especially when he's already sure, WW is scum. If so, you can go look for his partners.

WarWound - Gut scum read, especially after his last posts. Learn to play this game properly, or be lynched. Seriously.

Yabbaguy - Gut town read so far. I like his contribution to the game.

YankCane - Good Lord, he's still in this game? O.o

Hyl/Yankee - Null read. Let's see what Yankee will bring to the table.

Foilist/ZazieR - He promised us the storm, but so far I don't see even a single cloud. He was pretty inactive in my other game with him too, but he lately picked up the activity there, so maybe we'll finally get to hear his revelations.

Zwet - typical zwet + one slip. Leaning scum.

My vote stays on Pom for now, although unfortunately her wagon lost all the steam, so in the face of the deadline I'll probably change the vote for zwet or WW.

[Nikanor]

Nikanor - again, can someone tell me if this is his usual behavior, regardless of alignment? Gut town read.

No, I'm usually not like this. This is really the first game in which I've tried this particular playstyle.

Dramonic - Never played with him, but for some reason I'm assuming, that's his normal playstyle. Anyone who played with him can confirm that? If yes, then I guess he's somewhere on the line between neutral and slightly pro-town.

Confirmed by Nikanor.

[zwetschenwasser]

Col, elaborate on said slip.

[Pomegranate]

WarWound - Gut scum read, especially after his last posts. Learn to play this game properly, or be lynched. Seriously.

Or replace out and join a newbie game.