Newbie 827 - Store Katana (Scum Win!)

[Wysp]

Yes, that was a slip on my part but I got lucky...XP

Any idea who the other scum was? I'd like to hear your accusations.

[Wysp]

Oh, and also, I was telling the truth about playing in another forum. We're a buttload more informal and we like to play loose and fast with the rules.

[RayFrost]

Yes, that was a slip on my part but I got lucky...XP

Any idea who the other scum was? I'd like to hear your accusations.

obv, it was orph.

[NewAgeWarrior]

So now you are confuse about who you investigated night 1?
How could you be confused about who he replaced? Your saying everyone in the slot of N1 was suspicious so you investigated, ye your saying that a totaly different player (rayfrost/orimarui) is innocent?

I basicly called it out right there, but i also misread page 1 in thinking AR replaced in day to whne HE was replaced, which overall made me look dumber/scummyer.
I was sad that our IC didn't catch on to the fact that a cop "forgot" who was innocent. but hey, live and learn.

and JVW, i am an SE in another newbie game, but i also am in another mini game and im going to sign up for a themed game as soon as one that i like pops up (i also just died in a game i replaced into)

[julienvonwolfe]

I was sad that our IC didn't catch on to the fact that a cop "forgot" who was innocent. but hey, live and learn.

Oh man, I feel bad.

[RayFrost]

I was sad that our IC didn't catch on to the fact that a cop "forgot" who was innocent. but hey, live and learn.

Oh man, I feel bad.

obv scum

[NewAgeWarrior]

[quote[Oh man, I feel bad.[/quote]
Don't. Im the jackass who made the perfect fake claim target for wysp.

[Messiah]

Hey, good game everyone. I'm sad that you guys lynched NAW, I had a fairly strong town read on him for the way he responded to my pressure D2. I'm not one to talk, though; of the 3 scum reads I had throughout the game, I let the only correct one pass off as newbish behavior.

Also, I'd like to thank Tenchi for his moderating. I don't have much to compare it to, but I felt like he did an excellent job.

[Wysp]

Yes, he was quite good. The replaces were really weird...do you guys do that normally?

[Tenchi]

Congratulations...

julienvonwolfe (Mafia Scum) and Wysp (Mafia Scum)!

you both have won Newbie 827!

julienvonwolfe and Wysp use the keys they had an move on to an uncharted chamber in the store. Together, they drag all the bodies through the musky passage to serve them in a forever unknown purpose.

Nobody has solved the mystery of Store Katana...

---

See all their nasty planning and night talks here! http://www.quicktopic.com/43/H/tXwnABMvSPmK

---

NIGHT ONE

Excedrin protects Juilienvonwolfe
Julienvonwolfe stabs Excedrin

NIGHT TWO

Wysp stabs Messiah

[NewAgeWarrior]

oh. well then, that sucks. i had a slight feeling that JVW was scum but i probably would have picked orph over JVW.

GG scum, and damn you wysp. i learned my lesson to never write anyone off again

[Wysp]

Good game to you ask well. Messiah gave me a run for my money at the start...I hadn't expected anything so intense. XP

And I'll make sure not to make the same mistake when I play town.

[orphevs]

GG guys. I would have had a real hard time finding the scum in this one even if I was in from the start, I think. Time for another newbie game to see how things go if I'm in from the start. Thanks for a great game, everyone.

[julienvonwolfe]

A quick note - all of the things I said as IC in this game were true, even if I applied them in ways to suit my own purpose.

Other than that, good game indeed. We really got lucky when we killed the doctor on night one - that was pure luck.

It worked out OK in the end but I'm kicking myself for not getting Wysp to bus me (or vice versa). This would've been an easy and very elegant win on day 4. As it was, it was a bit touch and go.

[julienvonwolfe]

Oh - and if I was town, I would've lynched Wysp on day one. Even in newbie games, you should lynch new people for playing like scum. You can see that I tried to lead a Wysp lynch but backed off when I saw that it was unnecessary.

[Tenchi]

For everyone, try to read Wysp's posts in isolation. It is funny now that you know that he is scum. Wysp has been obvscum for the early part of the game, and everybody just wrote him off as a nervous newbie. They didn't know that he was a nervous, newbie scum! Early on, Wysp was very defensive and was very sensitive to his lynch. He also lacked the early questioning abilities and curiosity of who is scum. Wysp only started questioning other player's actions by his 30th post.

Also, note Wysp's lack of frustration when nobody believed his Cop claim, despite strong proof against NAW. In his later posts, he was more confident rather than scared of being in a LyLo situation.

I was waiting for somebody to do a PBPA of Wysp and nobody did it.

[Tenchi]

Also, it was a pleasure hosting you all and thank you for replacing in and keeping this game as active as you can. Learn from this game and I wish you all luck in your future games!

[julienvonwolfe]

the PBPA thing might be due to my posts against them - I stand by that even now. But yeah, I'm glad people didn't look at Wysp too closely.

[Excedrin]

GG, I thought that JVW was possibly scum after purple princess lynch, but obviously didn't while I was alive. I'm not sure how NAW could have gotten out of that except that it looked too perfect (#1 suspect of both Excedrin and purple princess is alive AND cop has guilty on him, but only after night 2).

Posts 60 and 64 stood out in my notes, but they both fit noob town as well as noob scum. Uhhhhh, oh, for some reason I thought that XScorpion was town on day 1 (because he was at least thinking about the effects of lynching various players, which seemed like a town-tell since scum probably doesn't care) but I wasn't willing to defend him beyond this... I really hoped that he'd improve his behavior.

Aite, gl in future games, cya on the forums.

Tenchi thanks for modding!

[RayFrost]

For everyone, try to read Wysp's posts in isolation. It is funny now that you know that he is scum. Wysp has been obvscum for the early part of the game, and everybody just wrote him off as a nervous newbie. They didn't know that he was a nervous, newbie scum! Early on, Wysp was very defensive and was very sensitive to his lynch. He also lacked the early questioning abilities and curiosity of who is scum. Wysp only started questioning other player's actions by his 30th post.

Also, note Wysp's lack of frustration when nobody believed his Cop claim, despite strong proof against NAW. In his later posts, he was more confident rather than scared of being in a LyLo situation.

I was waiting for somebody to do a PBPA of Wysp and nobody did it.

I worked off the first 10 pages of reading or so >.> I didn't read early stuff.

Thanks for your moderation, tenchi~ if you ever need another replacement, hit me up

[XScorpion]

This game totally sucked for me...it's just chance that people wrote Wysp off as the nervous newbie and not me. I guess I just have the kind of attitude that bothers people...

[julienvonwolfe]

That, and I kind of manipulated your lynch. I always feel bad about mislynching people, but you have to be ruthless as scum.

One person we haven't heard from is purple princess. She shows potential - she was on to me as scum - but she just needs to work on the execution a bit. By not replying to my arguments, she just dug her own grave. I hope she hasn't given up playing mafia.

[Wysp]

Naw, I saw her playing another game a few weeks ago.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Last post.