Mini 1871 - Town of Whispers - Game Over

[Human Sequencer]

Damn you slipped it in there just before I beat you to it.

[podoboq]

Official Vote Count 2.02

Lynching

With 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to lynch.

Dunnstral

(1): Ser Arthur Dayne

Nobody

(7): SlySly, BlackVoid, shannon, Misère, Dunnstral, Human Sequencer

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-02-15 22:20:00)

[Human Sequencer]

slysly posted something in the PT that makes me think they're town but also makes me question their sanity

misere is still silent

VOTE: Misere

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Human Sequencer

[shannon]

@HS if you've got something that makes you think Sly is town, I'm eager to hear it!

[podoboq]

Ser Arthur Dayne has been prodded a third time and is being replaced.

[shannon]

Nooooo we are neighbours I will miss him

[podoboq]

Misère has been prodded.

[podoboq]

Official Vote Count 2.03

Lynching

With 7 votes in play, it takes 4 to lynch.

Misère

(1): Human Sequencer

Human Sequencer

(1): Dunnstral

Nobody

(5): SlySly, BlackVoid, shannon, Misère,

Ser Arthur Dayne

Deadline

: (expired on 2017-02-15 22:20:00)

[BlackVoid]

Hoping Arthur comes back or we get a good replacement. I'm also really hoping for more content from HS and SlySly at this point since those are my other two townreads. If I can feel comfortable about those three, I can figure out which two of Misere, Shannon, and Dunnstral are scum. Right now, I'm not comfortable with my reads yet.

[Human Sequencer]

Hi bv.
Shannon is town.
Vote misere kthx.

[Dunnstral]

Why do people think misere is scum when they were obvious town yesterday? Let's lynch HS

[podoboq]

hapahauli replaces Ser Arthur Dayne

[podoboq]

SlySly has been prodded

[Dunnstral]

HS why do you ignore me??

[hapahauli]

Hello world. I'll need a bit of time to catch up. I probably won't use the "neighbor" threads all that much, so if you live next door, just talk to me here.

[shannon]

Nooooo I love the neighbourhoods @hapahauli you gotta talk to me!

[hapahauli]

Can someone explain to me why the neighborhoods matter at all? The way I see it, talking there just hides critical information from the town. For example:

slysly posted something in the PT that makes me think they're town but also makes me question their sanity

misere is still silent

VOTE: Misere

It would be lovely to have records of what slysly posted.

[shannon]

Hoping Arthur comes back or we get a good replacement. I'm also really hoping for more content from HS and SlySly at this point since those are my other two townreads. If I can feel comfortable about those three, I can figure out which two of Misere, Shannon, and Dunnstral are scum. Right now, I'm not comfortable with my reads yet.

Can you walk me through how you'd see any of us as teams? me + mis, me + dunn, dunn + mis?

I would also like to talk a bit more about HS and Sly. Sly scum read HS all yesterday and tunnelled him no end. When I called him out, he basically said he's sticking to the tunnel because he's sure he's right. (This was in 345). So one of your town reads is adamant the other is scum. How do you reconcile that?

[shannon]

Can someone explain to me why the neighborhoods matter at all? The way I see it, talking there just hides critical information from the town. For example:

slysly posted something in the PT that makes me think they're town but also makes me question their sanity

misere is still silent

VOTE: Misere

It would be lovely to have records of what slysly posted.

Why not ask Mis or Sly what was said?

I think neighbourhoods can be useful for town sharing information in a way that might make it tricky for scum to get a lock on the game. If you're in a situation like me and don't town read either neighbour particularly strongly, it's probably best to keep quiet. But if you are 110% sure your neighbour is town, you could share your results or targets with them. They can share the results in the main thread and take the night kill (unless they are protected), while you live to investigate/protect another day.

There's also the possibility of coordinating fake results in order to take pressure off of actual PRs. I think that's why the number of PRs in this game is unknown and why we also have neighbourhoods.

I have just come off a game where the designer's intended strategy was for the neighbours (there were only two, one was a PR) to use exactly the strategy above. Instead, we mucked it up and scum read both of them at various points, they scum read each other, and we lynched the PR because it seemed implausible. So let's not do that here. Use the neighbourhoods to work out who can be trusted and use that trust to our best advantage.

[SlySly]

Fortunately for me and my kids, I have recently acquired a life. Unfortunately for my mafiascum presence, that life has been vacuuming up all of my time. Though I'm still in the middle of a lot, there is a break in sight. I'm still here. I'll be catching up on this and my other games tonight and tomorrow. I'll tackle the shorter ones first.

[SlySly]

Sly early on you said scum was in Dunn, HS, or BTD, because anyone who took Jin seriously needs rope. How do you feel about that in retrospect? Obviously you were wrong about BTD, but what's your vibe on Dunn and HS now? You basically tunnelled HS all D1, have you had any change of mind about him? Or still the same?

BTD pushed it the least.

There was scum here...

nn30 (5): BTD6_Maker, Dunnstral, Ser Arthur Dayne, shannon, Misère

I'm good with lynching Dunn still. HS hasn't done anything to improve in my standings. Dunn's recent buddying of Misere is noted.

VOTE: Dunn

[Misère]

I've been much busier than I expected to be lately. If that continues to be the case, I'll replace out.

I really have nothing to contribute right now. I still don't think HS is Mafia but I'm not sure why the continued push on me now. For that matter I don't

[Misère]

For that matter I don't

...finish my posts before fat-fingering Submit, apparently.

I was going to say I don't really understand what makes Dunn so sure I'm town now.

[shannon]

Dudes I feel like I'm mostly playing this game on my own, come on, let's do this.

@Dunn what makes you think Mis is town now?

@Mis why shouldn't Dunn think your'e town? What's suspicious about his change of mind?