Mini 399 - Meets His Maker Mafia - GAME OVER!

[klebian]

well, you didn't put a headline day 1 either... I don't know what you mean when you explain the lancaster dying of stab wounds thing...

So you have the ability to give 2 headlines, and to investigate something that happened at night? And today, the first day out of the hospital, you investigated a death... and got nothing?

Hmm.
I don't see everything, but with the 2 headlines day 2, it does seem reasonable, and IH thinks you're innocent...

However, another inconsistency is that you were apparently actually reading the game while in the hospital, but as soon as you came out, you made a nonsensical vote on the claimed tracker and you said " I have no clue what the hell is going on. " Not only is it really stupid to come in day 3 after sitting out the first 2 days and make a random vote, but it's stupider that you have now seemingly claimed to have been reading the game, and had a feeling that Pooky was scum, which obviously doesn't happen unless you were paying actual attention to the game.

An interesting question you asked that was overlooked at the time:

...Hey can anyfind out if Yamahako as a weapon or not. ...

What was this for???
After this point, we got entangled in yama's claim, and your contributions of "I'm here, vote pots".

Which is also needing answer: Why have you been so persistent in voting Pots without giving any reason? Your initial reasoning was something like 'Atticus, IH, and Klebian seem innocent. This leaves Yama and Pots, so vote: pots'. (Possible yama+panzer connection here) You later clarified this a bit more: 'Scum is either yama or pots. We can lynch pots today, and yama tomorrow. We win!' Did you even think through what scenarios can happen tonight? We are at 6 people, and chances are there are 2 evils left. If we guess randomly between pots and yama, and we lynch the innocent one (assuming one is evil, one is innocent) then chances are we lose.

Yama responds to that similarly:

First of all, there could be 2 scum left, or a scum and an SK. You say the scum as if there definitely only one left - as if you know the number of scum in this game. Next you're basically calling out the next two lynches - like you already know Pots would come up innocent and then you'd "know I was scum"

and your brilliant (and completely irrelevant) response:

No, i think you and Pots are good actors.

Then, pots votes you, and you self voted. First off, you have a seemingly provable role. Second, Pots didn't even vote you for bad reasons, so it's not like you were so frustrated that you self-voted. So, answer me: WHY DID YOU SELF VOTE???

My vote stays.

[Penguins of the Serengeti]

Mmmmm... Panzer's been playing pretty scummy, but I think I have to believe his claim. IH is some sort of tracker/watcher. Not sure about klebian, giving Yama the benefit of the doubt for now.

At this point, is there a reason not to vote Atticus? I looked at all his posts in this game, and I have a sinking feeling he might be scum. All those short posts, spreading doubt and accusation, instead of raking his brains looking for scum...

[PJ.]

Because last nights death was by strangulation.

[PJ.]

And I voted because I thought i wasn't allowed to claim.

[Yamahako]

Because last nights death was by strangulation.

So if a gunsmith had checked me out and said I didn't have a gun, then I was guilty? I think very few people would have guns, well does that mean if I had a gun I would be innocent?

I think there's something scummy going on here - I can see mafia having a reason to want to publish stuff at the beginning of the day without any recourse to who said it more so than town - so I find this claim to be oh so convenient. A Townie wouldn't need to post it at the beginning of the day, they would just say it during the day when it provided the best help for town.

I think you've put up too many 'one or the other' scenarios - which in my experience is a huge scum tell. I'm going to wait for IH to come back to report since he's the only one that's pretty much clear in this game, and he said there might be something correlating you two - but I'm pretty much going to vote you unless he gives a good reason not too.

[Atticus]

At this point, is there a reason not to vote Atticus?

Only if Yama can verify my role, which I am not feeling inclined to reveal.

[klebian]

And I voted because I thought i wasn't allowed to claim.

But IH had claimed! Did you miss that too?

[IH]

Well, all I know is that in my role I have phone numbers to call, and the newspaper is one of them, along with the doc and the morgue.

[PJ.]

I did miss that. And what do you mean Yama, I don't get it. The posting the headlines is my night ability. So I have to send the headlines at night and they appear in the mourning so I don't get what you mean.

[Yamahako]

Well, all I know is that in my role I have phone numbers to call, and the newspaper is one of them, along with the doc and the morgue.

Do you think Panzer is confirmable then? That's very interesting...

[klebian]

Don't see what that's giving. Scum can make headlines as much as town, as someone has mentioned.

[Penguins of the Serengeti]

At this point, is there a reason not to vote Atticus?

Only if Yama can verify my role, which I am not feeling inclined to reveal.

What do you mean, "Only if Yama can verify my role"???

[klebian]

Ah, yeah, I forgot to respond to that. Atticus, yama cannot verify your role. All he knows is your role NAME. And you're saying the only reason not to vote you is if someone else can verify your role? You don't think you're not scummy in this game?

[Atticus]

Oh, see, I thought he knew what my role was.

Well, then, there really isn't a reson not to vote me at this point I guess.

[klebian]

... Well if you're not going to defend yourself, you can at least claim.

[PJ.]

umm

Unvote

I would love a claim.

[klebian]

Hey, man, you're twisting the issue. You're still at -1, and even if atticus has randomly decided that he can't defend himself, you're still the scummier one. I'm definitely keeping my vote on you.

[Atticus]

I'll wait for a third to ask for a claim, half the people asking seems fair.

[Penguins of the Serengeti]

Claim please.

[Atticus]

I am a lyncher, or at least I used to be.

My lynchee was Pooky, but since he's dead, I win with the town as a vanilla townie.

[Penguins of the Serengeti]

Flavor please.

[Atticus]

I'm a Hormonal teenager who was jealous of Aaron Banister. At the time of the role, when draygn originally got the role, he did not know who Aaron was. But I'm hoping it became obvious to him when the claim came of the three mason group and Pooky choosing to see which mason.

This is at least what I'm assuming.

[klebian]

So basically dragyn was a lyncher, but he didn't know who the lynchee was, and the lynchee couldn't even name-claim that would tell dragyn that he was the lynchee?

[Atticus]

Succinctly, yes.

[klebian]

But I'm hoping it became obvious to him when the claim came of the three mason group and Pooky choosing to see which mason.

Reword this please.