Post 0 is terrible and Fate should be lynched for it.
Post 8: Seraphim is being ridiculously silly here. Particularly if he meant "serious vote"
Post 19: OK. No, seriously, Seraphim is being really silly. This is dumb.
I'll note page 1 has four Nacho posts. Three guesses as to how many have content. The first two zeroes don't count.
The flow on the LLD issue makes a bit more sense in context.
Post 48: So this is A) I'm going to ignore points I can't answer (because KDub had a point), and B) I'm not going to provide any reasoning for my "serious" vote ever. How win/win for you.
OK. I'm going to start a Useless Post count for Nacho.
Useless Nacho Posts: 6/6
HOLY GOD NACHO MADE A HALFWAY DECENT POST WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE. It's still mostly IIoA though.
Post 67: LLD, this is still a terrible vote.
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 7/8
Nacho's next post is...decent, I guess.
As I said, I'm not judging CES today. But I see why people hate on him :V
...holy shit I get it. I understand what CES is doing now.
Post 83: This bugs me. It looks like a good post on the surface but it's not a lot of original thought, particularly from a player who hasn't provided much original thought so far. Further, a fair amount of the post isn't exactly necessary because it's kinda explaining joke votes and such.
GI's waffling thing is actually not that great in retrospect. To be honest, his 77 isn't NEARLY as good as I initially thought it was.
/me pets Past Kitty for observing the Seraphim thing.
Post 105: GI continues the "waffle" thing. And doesn't react to *ANYTHING ELSE*
Post 116: Seraphim being terrible again. Yay, you finally explained the reinforcement of your vote. TOO BAD YOU STILL HAVEN'T EXPLAINED WHY YOU MADE IT IN THE FIRST PLACE! And STILL haven't. Slippery bastard. Oh, and the misrepresentation of GI is pretty impressive too.
GI comes out looking better than Seraphim in the initial skirmish. This is unsurprising.
Post 123: Why did you post this, GI? It contributed nothing.
GI continues to beat the bloodily murdered horse on waffling. I know Jahudo asked but the point's been reiterated a bajillion times at this point.
Seraphim doesn't make himself look better with his next two posts. They focus on GI's weakest point ignoring the rest. Classic case breaking technique.
Post 130: Toasty, what the hell are you on about? Are you allergic to explaining your suspicion?
Post 135: Yes, really. Hell, she telegraphed that damn vote. What's your issue?
Post 140: Yes, everything that makes you look bad is a joke. Bravo. :clap clap:
Seraphim continues to dig his pit. He's done nothing to counter LLD's points
Post 153: This post is fucking terrible, Nacho. I know why you did it, but THE SITUATIONS WERE DIFFERENT. LLD actually TELEGRAPHED her damn vote. You just did that for the lulz. This goes in your useless post count.
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 8/9
GI 154 makes more sense if you figured out what Nacho was doing. With the Nacho town read from that post. Though I am beginning to disagree.
Post 167: Oh look another terrible Seraphim post. Yawn. The misrep is obvious, and was explained to you no less than twice.
Seraphim 184: "IT WAS A JOKE! ALSO, GAIZ, I'LL GET SERIOUS NOW BY STILL POSTING TERRIBLY!"
Post 188: Jahudo, why the fuck are you still encouraging the waffle thing? It's DEAD at this point. Latter half of your post is OK, I guess.
Post 196: This post is a useless distraction. It's very HEY GAIZ I'M TOWN, SO LET'S LYNCH SOMEONE WHO'S NOT ME!
Post 203: What in the nine hells is THIS, UT? Explain yourself! And do you have any OTHER reasons for voting Toasty?
Post 205: "HOLY SHIT LOOK AT THAT I'M TOWN TECH, LEMME GET IN ON THAT SHIT GREYICE!" Also bussing doesn't exist!
You know what? Vi, remember Bamboo Forest Mafia? With me and Kilga? Apply that to Seraphim and GI. They both need rope. BADLY
I'm redoubling my Hmm on Toasty for 105.
Post 214: This is not a good post. Granted, the Jahudo thing needed to be explained. The vote on you going to a town read basically means GI can A) Never random vote or B) Never change his mind. And you made posts between GI's vote and list. Same on UT.
Post 220: Ad hom and failure to advance anything new. This post is useless.
Post 224: You must have rolled below a 20, cause this is hypo-critical out teh ASS
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 9/10
Post 232:
Paragraph one: "Oh shit, Vi's on to me. Hey buddy, you aren't as bad as I thought, thanks for the contributions, we should have tea sometime, see ya!"
Paragraph two: OK, this one is all right.
Paragraph three: "Oh, hey LLD, you're town so I want you in my pocket too. Also I'm going to ignore the people that HAVE commented on the LLD wagon and pretend I'm being original"
Rest of it is fine, though feeds my Bamboo Forest theory.
Post 234: Yeah, it'd be a shame to push your buddy's wagon too far.
Post 240: SHIT BOSS GOTTA LOOK BUSY!
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 10/11
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 11/12
Now, I'm sure people are wondering why I don't have a useless post count on CES. As I said, I see what he's doing now. I think.
Post 269: >Completely not explaining the Rhinox change.
>Implying Vi isn't actually doing a pretty good job with a lot of content.
GI wrote:Well given you're focusing about TEN TIMES the attention on LLD as you are on Seraphim, I'd have said you gave fucking good indication you did.
[[Citation Needed]]
Post 272: This is hilarious in retrospect
Vi 283: SHIT, I'M SORRY! I WAS BLIND! I SEE THE LIGHT NOW!
Post 285: THIS is how you do a fucking town scum list, assholders. LEARN.
Post 288: Uh, what?
Post 303: Why the living FUCK was Nacho EVER GOD DAMN TOWN to you?
What POSSIBLY inspired that?
HOLY SHIT NACHO IS POSTING CONTENT FOR ONCE. Fair posts, really. Though they ignore a ton of OTHER issues. Some very important ones.
Post 313: I can just IMAGINE you typing "designated mislynch CES" in the scum QT right now. Why is Nacho town? WHY?
Post 326: "MotherFUCK, scumbuddy is being seriously pushed. Better get on here if I want the Bamboo Forest gambit to be realistic."
Post 333: Uh huh. I LOVE your blurb on Nacho there.
LLD: I think we might be on the same wavelength here. And I can understand why you wouldn't want to push it yet if I'm right.
Post 355: Nevermind, guess you aren't thinking what I'm thinking. How is GI town again?
Toasty 367: Problem with Jahudo is that that was a mistake. Rest is fine.
Post 374: HEY LOOK ANOTHER TERRIBLE GI POST. WHO HERE IS SURPRISED!?
Post 375: Way to gloat Seraph.
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 12/15?
Seraphim is amazingly disingenous on this page. Particularly the pressing LLD for her scumbuddy reads while saying you can't actually do that.
!!USELESS NACHO POST!!: 13/16?
Vi 399: So I'm not allowed to call out bad logic when I see it? There are lots of good reasons to vote GI. The ones provided by most people weren't.
Another rare useful Nacho post. And holy shit he's following my logic. Mayhap I underestimated him :O!
LLD 409: Again, done it before as scum offsite. Vi can tell you. It was ludicrous. I went on to win the game, by the way.
Post 411: Um, you DID call CES scum. When questioning why everyone thought him town. Thanks for playing though. Antitown I'll cede. Already said why your "setting up lynches" point is shit.
Bah, I'm on page 18 and honestly don't see my scum team changing.
tl;dr post forthcoming.