Exception - A Game That's Slightly Like Spyfall - Game 3

[DragonEater70]

And the answer is...

Spoiler:

Items of luxury

[DragonEater70]

This means that the

town

other players win!

Roles:

Sky - A jet
Snivy - A BMW
bianco - A bottle of champagne
SC - A watch
Adorable - A bicycle

[DragonEater70]

So, I would like some feedback from you guys if you don't mind:

1. Did you enjoy? Would you like to play another round?
2. Did you feel the game was balanced?

[camelCasedSnivy]

lmao i thought it was just cars

[Skygazer]

hahaha and i thought i was being sneaky with my first question

would play again

[DragonEater70]

Well I have to say, normally there's more info shared during the question phase rather than just arbitrary ranking by number, so you get a better idea of what other players are.

Also considering how little info there was, I think Adorable didn't even realize she was the exception and the copying StrangerCoug thing was a complete coincidence. Am I correct about that, @Adorable?

[DragonEater70]

hahaha and i thought i was being sneaky with my first question

would play again

Yeah I laughed when I saw that question

[Adorable]

So, I would like some feedback from you guys if you don't mind:

1. Did you enjoy? Would you like to play another round?
2. Did you feel the game was balanced?

1. Yes, I had fun. The questions the players were asking some of the words I did not know what they mean like for example I did not know what did bourgeose and celebratory mean and I ended up having to look it up in a dictionary and I would be getting multiple different definitions.

2. Being the exception is hard because they don't even know their own alignment. I don't know how to explain this well and if all the categories are based on locations just like the game spyfall the exception would have a better chance on figuring it out. To test this game out again if it is balanced or not, we would need to see another players point of view who gets the exception role on what did they think about being the exception if it was easy for them or hard.

[Adorable]

Well I have to say, normally there's more info shared during the question phase rather than just arbitrary ranking by number, so you get a better idea of what other players are.

Also considering how little info there was, I think Adorable didn't even realize she was the exception and the copying StrangerCoug thing was a complete coincidence. Am I correct about that, @Adorable?

I wasn't copying StrangerCoug on purpose. The first question Stargazer asked, I looked up bourgeose from the dictionary in the morning before I left and I posted my number and then I realized I made a mistake with my answer and I was supposed to post a higher instead of a middle rated number. I got bourgeose mixed up with the word expensive thinking and I was thinking in my head bicycle is not all that expensive and I wrote down a 6.

[DragonEater70]

Well bourgeoisie means upper class so I get why you were confused. And yeah people here used some hard words

Thanks for the feedback. Part of the fun is trying to figure out your own alignment, but sure I could try to limit it to a location next time and see how it goes. Would you play another game?

[Adorable]

Yes, I would play another game.

[DragonEater70]

Alright, I think I will just host it in this thread. Anyone is welcome to /in.

(I think we should do another run before we change the rules, so for now they will remain unchanged)

[Skygazer]

/in

[camelCasedSnivy]

/in

[biancospino]

/in

[camelCasedSnivy]

i would change something like making the exception have a multiple choice answer or making the categories easier to guess? i do agree that it needs more testing

also you can edit the title to let people know youre accepting players again

[camelCasedSnivy]

2.1916

also would like to say that this was an emergency crumb because bmw was founded in 1916

[DragonEater70]

RE: categories being easier to guess, usually when I play with friends the exception survives multiple rounds so on the third round it becomes sort of obvious what the category is but not really. Also usually the questions and answers have more information than just a ranking by number. Example questions would be "what color are you?" or "what size are you?"
I am not saying you HAVE to use this kind of questions but I think you could maybe try it out.

[DragonEater70]

But yeah let's do one more game and then try to balance it.

[StrangerCoug]

/in

[Adorable]

/in

[Not_Mafia]

/in

[DragonEater70]

Oh yeah I'll start this tomorrow probs, I need some free time to think about cool roles.

[StrangerCoug]

Mod: Please note sig.

[DragonEater70]

Noted. Do you think you will be able to keep up?