Scummies 2016 Nomination Thread

[chamber]

what?

[RadiantCowbells]

Just a joke, dw about it.

[T-Bone]

Alright let's get some nominations going!

Going to nominate DiamondSentinel for

Rising Star

. I have played two games with him, one in which he gave an extraordinary performance as my scumbuddy in MGSV: The Phantom Pain Mafia and one in which he replaced late and got things down to 3p LyLo in Guild of Dungeoneering Mafia. In the Guild he replaced in late to a questionable slot, and while the game didn't turn out well for the town (and lost cause of things beyond his control), he was very attentive in catching up and playing the game currently. Not a lazy replacement in the least. In MGSV he helped me lead our scumteam to a flawless victory. In our scum topic he was very active and always ready to enact every plan we came up with. In the game he took some bold stances that while got him some weird suspicion, kept the majority of the town off of him (to the point where my soft bussing was the only real pressure on him). I'm not going to let some arguments at the ends of those games obscure nominations that should come out of them. I think he'll preform well as 2016 continues and is a player you want on your team.

[fferyllt]

second DiamondSentinel.

[pirate mollie]

thirded

I really liked him in guild.

[Scummies]

PLEASE USE THIS FORM TO NOMINATE SCUMMIES!

We will be adding this to the OP whenever UT stops playing The Witness.

[Gorkington]

PLEASE USE THIS FORM TO NOMINATE SCUMMIES!

We will be adding this to the OP whenever UT stops playing The Witness.

fun game

[Kmd4390]

Nominate Aneninen for best 3rd party

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=64668

As SK, he chose 1 shot BP which he lost N1. With 2 town vigs and a scum team to dodge, he managed to stay under the radar and survive at night until Day 3 where he led the charge to get the last scum lynched, securing a spot in 3p LYLO where he set up 2 townies who suspected each other. When one of those two townies was replaced, he kept his cool and posted more analysis and research than either of the two townies and obvtowned his way to SK victory. What I found most impressive was his ability to fake revelations about what must have happened with the NKs even though he was responsible for some of those kills. Those revelations, including the a vig suicided, came off very genuine and were a big part of why he won. He also fooled me with an "I thought I could coniffirm myself with something but never mind" type post that would have never worked if he hadn't baited me into asking for it anyway. He didn't end up needing my vote though because RC voted me before I officially decided, but I think it's safe to say I probably wasn't going to both vote Anen AND convince RC to follow me. I've played a shit ton of mafia over the last 8 years (I estimate it at roughly 300 games between alts and off site games) and I can't immediately recall a better SK victory than this.

[hiplop]

hey scummies do we still post in this thread our nom or just use the sheet

[Psyche]

post the nom too!

[shos]

THE NOMINATION FORM HERE

Posts in this thread will NOT count toward nominations

It wouldn't count, but it will assist others to 2nd and nth

[SleepyKrew]

except seconds and nths are pointless

[Psyche]

do it in thread so that you can celebrate achievements that would otherwise only get recognized in

like a year

by the scummies committee

if

you're lucky

[RadiantCowbells]

Just for the record, nomming Ranger for best town play for her peformance in Blitz 21 and elsewhere.

[Alchemist21]

Nominate Aneninen for best 3rd party

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=51&t=64668

As SK, he chose 1 shot BP which he lost N1. With 2 town vigs and a scum team to dodge, he managed to stay under the radar and survive at night until Day 3 where he led the charge to get the last scum lynched, securing a spot in 3p LYLO where he set up 2 townies who suspected each other. When one of those two townies was replaced, he kept his cool and posted more analysis and research than either of the two townies and obvtowned his way to SK victory. What I found most impressive was his ability to fake revelations about what must have happened with the NKs even though he was responsible for some of those kills. Those revelations, including the a vig suicided, came off very genuine and were a big part of why he won. He also fooled me with an "I thought I could coniffirm myself with something but never mind" type post that would have never worked if he hadn't baited me into asking for it anyway. He didn't end up needing my vote though because RC voted me before I officially decided, but I think it's safe to say I probably wasn't going to both vote Anen AND convince RC to follow me. I've played a shit ton of mafia over the last 8 years (I estimate it at roughly 300 games between alts and off site games) and I can't immediately recall a better SK victory than this.

I feel like he should get an award all its own just for convincing people that a vig shot itself (on top of the SK nom).

[Marquis]

do it in thread so that you can celebrate achievements that would otherwise only get recognized in

like a year

by the scummies committee

if

you're lucky

tbh this is the most effective portion of the scummies process

[Davsto]

I'd say announce it in thread with further reasoning, if only because otherwise the Anti-Nom option would be literally entirely pointless since how can you oppose a nomination that you don't know exists.

[hiplop]

I pre-emptively anti-nom'd davsto for everything =]

[3dicerolling]

I pre-emptively anti-nom'd davsto for everything =]

Second

[Davsto]

I pre-emptively anti-nom'd davsto for everything =]

I get the award for fewest scummy nominations at -12

yay

[Antihero]

Just for the record, nomming Ranger for best town play for her peformance in Blitz 21 and elsewhere.

i nommed ranger for rising star but i think there's a good case there for paragon if she keeps it up

[Firebringer]

I get the award for fewest scummy nominations at -12

yay

Damn Davsto gets all the luck!
And "Anti Scummies"
Sounds aweosme too ;(

[Firebringer]

Since the award is gone anyways:
I nominate

Firebringer for White Knight

Yay!

Judes have decided:

This was a difficult for us to review, since there was no competitors, and the award is gone because Judges hate Firebringer, but the winner of White Knight is.....:

Davsto!

[Aristophanes]

Since the award is gone anyways:
I nominate

Firebringer for White Knight

Yay!

Judes have decided:

This was a difficult for us to review, since there was no competitors, and the award is gone because Judges hate Firebringer, but the winner of White Knight is.....:

Davsto!

Hahaha!
This is awesome!

[OceanWind]

Is there a way people can view who have been nominated? It's better to do this sort of thing in public.