BM's Mystery Mafia!! GAME OVER???

[somestrangeflea]

OK...
Oman speculated on the setup...
JDodge voted Oman for fishing...
GodOfWine voted JDodge for... I don't know. The posts seem to make out that JDodge was fishing, but I think it's a possible misinterpretation/miswording...

In conclusion... uh...

Unvote, Vote: JDodge

.

I would like some sort of clarification from GoW though...

[Albert B. Rampage]

Stop messing with JDodge. Leave him alone.

[JordanA24]

Stop messing with JDodge. Leave him alone.

Reasons?

[Albert B. Rampage]

The bandwagon on him is pretty baseless.

[JordanA24]

He only has 4 votes, I think the current amount of votes on him are proportionate to his actions so far.

[SirWario]

Unvote,Vote:Albert B. Rampage

why would you jump to defend jdodge?

I agree with Erg0's interpretation of GOW's statement. It seemed like he wanted Oman to keep fishing.Strange, but appears to be random.

[Albert B. Rampage]

His actions ? He made 3 posts so far.

First post:

Vote: Flea

Second post:

Unvote, vote: Oman

Quit fishing.

Third post:

Jdodge, I'm not fishing, I'm speculating. Of course, I also can't count, so if I was fishing, I'm pretty crap at it.

That's BS.

The second post was in response to this:

Remember, 10 votes required to lynch.

Is this, in fact, correct.

If so we must have a double voter.

Just a thought.

Xdaamno, thats three of ten, letting your 7 scumbuddies pile on? [/humour]

JDodge has not done anything scummy.

[Quinnster]

Unvote

FoS: Albert B Rampage

You seem pretty infuriated there, care to explain why you're so antsy when it's so many votes to lynch?

[Quinnster]

I meant a comma in there, it's unvote for Nelly, then the FoS for Rampage.

[JordanA24]

I'd disagree with you when you say JDodge hasn't done anything scummy Albert, I think he was exaggerated when he said Oman was fishing, that's the biggest scumtell so far I think.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Here are the facts:

1. Oman fished for a power role, in this instance a double voter.

Is this, in fact, correct. If so we must have a double voter.

2. JDodge called him on it.

3. Oman says he was'nt fishing. He blames his fishing on a numerical mistake, which in reality is unrelated to the fact that he was fishing.

Jdodge, I'm not fishing, I'm speculating. Of course, I also can't count, so if I was fishing, I'm pretty crap at it.

4. Generic idiotic vote #1.

unvote: Albert

VOTE: JDodge

Keep fishing.

5. JDodge says what Oman raised in point 3. is BS, which I explained the reasons why. Fishing is fishing, even were he to have made a mistake in the count, he shouldn't have said "we must have a double voter".

6. YagamiLight and pulsewidth correctly vote for generic voter #1.

7. Generic idiotic vote #2 on JDodge.

I don't think Oman was intentionally fishing, it was more speculation than anything IMO.

Unvote Vote: JDodge

8. Generic idiotic vote #3 on JDodge.

OK...
Oman speculated on the setup...
JDodge voted Oman for fishing...
GodOfWine voted JDodge for... I don't know. The posts seem to make out that JDodge was fishing, but I think it's a possible misinterpretation/miswording...

In conclusion... uh...

Unvote, Vote: JDodge

.

I would like some sort of clarification from GoW though...

And this one seems pretty scummy at that. He says he doesn't understand what GoW is trying to say, yet he follows GoW's lead without any explanation.

Look guys, speculating is nothing more than an euphemism for role-fishing. Even if you don't think so, speculating does the town no good. Its not going to make a claim more believable later. Its useless discussion. JDodge's vote is perfectly understandable,

and being still in the random voting phase

, I find it difficult to see that generic voters #1, #2 and #3 want to build a serious bandwagon based on nothing.

Unvote,Vote:Albert B. Rampage

why would you jump to defend jdodge?

I agree with Erg0's interpretation of GOW's statement. It seemed like he wanted Oman to keep fishing.Strange, but appears to be random.

Here's another wacko.

He thinks that GoW's wants Oman to keep fishing.

And then he votes for me. Right after calling GoW strange. Ridiculous.

FoS GoW, somestrangeflea, Jordan, Wario

[Albert B. Rampage]

I'd disagree with you when you say JDodge hasn't done anything scummy Albert, I think he was exaggerated when he said Oman was fishing, that's the biggest scumtell so far I think.

Way too early to build a bandwagon based on role-fishing for a

double-voter

...what Oman did was weird and a tad scummy. You guys are acting like JDodge deposed a case the size of the 5th amendment; he typed in 2 words. What, you think he was hoping for 9 other players to join him ? No!!

[JordanA24]

Oman was the one who commented on the possibility double-voter, I think JDodge streched it by saying Oman was fishing, it seemed like speculation rather than fishing to me.

[Albert B. Rampage]

There is a fine line between the two, and starting the day with such a lame bandwagon isn't going to get us to El Dorado.

[JordanA24]

Well we have to start somewhere don't we.

[Albert B. Rampage]

And you are entitled tp your opinion

On my part, I will fuel the other bandwagon which I find has more substance to it.

Unvote,

vote GodofWine

.

[Xdaamno]

I agree the jdodge, or more especially jordan wagon was pretty baseless.

[Oman]

I don't really think Jdodge was that scummy. I'm with Albert on this:

You guys are acting like JDodge deposed a case the size of the 5th amendment; he typed in 2 words

What he did was a tad scummy, as was what I did. I really don't think its worthy of a big vote like this.

[AlSleet]

The bandwagon on him is pretty baseless.

Bandwagons prompt discussion. It's not a bad thing to do early on.

[Albert B. Rampage]

The bandwagon on him is pretty baseless.

Bandwagons prompt discussion. It's not a bad thing to do early on.

Bandwagons on scummy players are good. JDodge is not as scummy as somestrangeflea, GoW, etc.

[Kison]

1) Oman was fishing, whether or not he made a mistake in the player count.

2) GodOfWine's "keep fishing" comment is doubly worse than JDodge's "stop fishing" comment.

FoS : GodOfWine

3) I don't like JordanA24's campaign against JDodge, seeing as JDodge is correct in what he said.

[AlSleet]

And you are entitled tp your opinion

On my part, I will fuel the other bandwagon which I find has more substance to it.

Unvote,

vote GodofWine

.

More substance? GodOfWine has 4 posts, only one of which is serious. How is there more substance there.

And, yes, I am aware that my random vote is still on him.

[Albert B. Rampage]

AlSleet, state your thoughts on JDodge, Jordan and somestrangeflea.

[SirWario]

SirWario wrote:
Unvote,Vote:Albert B. Rampage

why would you jump to defend jdodge?

I agree with Erg0's interpretation of GOW's statement. It seemed like he wanted Oman to keep fishing.Strange, but appears to be random.


Here's another wacko. He thinks that GoW's wants Oman to keep fishing. And then he votes for me. Right after calling GoW strange. Ridiculous.

I interpreted GOW's "keep fishing" remark as a joke. You, on the otherhand, decided to defend jdodge before he even had a chance to explain himself. Let him speak for himself.

Also, bandwagons can pressure people to make scumtells. Even baseless ones can serve a purpose.

[SirWario]

EBWOP: that last post was directed at ABR if I wasn't clear enough.