Mini #381-Werewolf: Cancelled

[conflux]

Don't replace me, I'm going to be away till Sunday evening, about 19-21 GMT.

[Atticus]

Nah,

Unvote; Vote StallingChamp.

[Atticus]

Wait a minute, you think

CoolBot and Jack

could

be good guys?

Hmm, why wouldn't you be sure, if you're the scum?

Maybe covering up your buddy.

FoS: CoolBot and Jack.

[CoolBot]

unvote: Lowell
vote: StallingChamp

He basically just asked to be lynched. I'm not sure why he pointed out me and Jack. He's probably hoping we get lynched after he is, but I'm not sure why he thinks that's an advantage.

[Elias_the_thief]

I sure hope youre joking stalling champ...
please tell me you were joking.

[StallingChamp]

I was indeed joking. It was merely to see the reactions to my post, and I think a few of the people who actually voted for me for such an obvious false are scum trying to get an easy lynch.

FoS: Atticus, Coolbot, Jack

Note that I was telling the truth about Coolbot and Jack giving good vibes.

[Echo419]

That was odd... I dunno, I guess it's justified, but I don't think that was the best trap you could have laid. Anyone saying they are scum is going to get voted anyway, either because they're a target or because of a LAL type interpretation. I don't think you would get too accurate results.

[Elias_the_thief]

I agree it was pretty scummy play in the first place. But to vote for him without confirming he was serious and not just being an idiot is scummy too. oh well. no need to make a big deal of it this early.

[Jack]

Dude, how can you call it an obvious false when last game you posted the mod's pm identifying the mafia?

[StallingChamp]

Well this time i didnt post any PM, I said i found some people seemed good, I didnt say any other people's names.

I did it to start discussion, and it seems to have worked pretty well.

[Elias_the_thief]

he seriously did that? wow. Your vote makes a lot more sense now.

[StallingChamp]

No I did not. My brother infiltrated my account and did that after I quit. Now that I have more time, I made a new (safe) account.

[CoolBot]

I did it to start discussion, and it seems to have worked pretty well.

Yeah, this game really was starting to die from lack of discussion.

My brother infiltrated my account and did that after I quit.

So you have quit before. And I've been on the internet long enough to distrust the "My borther did it" excuse. What game did all this happen in?

[StallingChamp]

Mini 383 iirc. Kelly Chan made a thread about this in the Mafia Discussion topic. Please refer to that topic for further information and leave that sort of discussion out of this topic.

[Jack]

What game did all this happen in?

Mini 373: doomsville.

All water under the bridge really, but I was reminded of it right away when he claimed mafia.

[Green Crayons]

Unvote: trabony

. Curious how that read through is taking forever, though.

Vote: StallingChamp

. I always vote people who say that they're scum. Always. I can't count the number of times scum have done it, and it has become a golden rule for me to put my vote on whomever does it. Congradulations, there's your conversation starter.

[StallingChamp]

I did it to start discussion, and it seems to have worked pretty well.

Yeah, this game really was starting to die from lack of discussion.

Well, I felt that the game could use a shake-up and so that is precisely what I did.

[Atticus]

Unvote; Revote: Elias The Thief.

StallingChamp's a complete idiot, or he's scum. He could be a complete idiot scum, or complete idiot town.

Elias is just scum. He's either Stalling's partner or he's just scum trying to casually look like he trusted someone we were, at that point, to lynch. He's too casual. He's scum. What else can I say?

[Echo419]

Meh. Elias could be overplaying/opprotunistic scum, or he's, uh, something else... I dunno. It doesn't seem hugely compelling. I think Lowell's odd plans and maybe SC's scumclaim are worse.

[Elias_the_thief]

or maybe i could be town who got lynched day 1 in my last game because someone pulled something like that and was joking. But I placed major suspicion on them because of it and somehow got lynched. Now I'm not so quick to rule a play as scummy if its just plain stupid.

[Echo419]

Gah. Metagaming is annying. Which game?

[Jack]

Unvote: trabony

. Curious how that read through is taking forever, though.

Vote: StallingChamp

. I always vote people who say that they're scum. Always. I can't count the number of times scum have done it, and it has become a golden rule for me to put my vote on whomever does it. Congradulations, there's your conversation starter.

You have any past games to back that up? I'm guessing yes but I'd like to be sure you're not just making that up as an excuse to put the 4th vote on.

[Green Crayons]

Though it's happened more than this instance, I don't feel like dragging up older games than this, as I only pop in here every few months or so.

From Mini 266:

~yawn~ Someone say something, please.

dragyn_mage, are you scum?

@mith- yes, why? doh!

Those who have been lost to the siege:
....
draygn_mage, mafia goon and fanatic enslaved

Am I saying that, 100 percent without a doubt, Stalling is scum? No. But, he managed to get himself several scummy ticks beneath his name in saying that he was, and seeing as how he is currently in the lead of scummy marks at the moment, he's getting my vote - and I'm more than comfortable with it being the fourth.

Point being, I'm not dead set and inflexible, merely that I don't see a better place - at the moment - for my vote.

[trabony]

Oh yeah Stallingchamp blamed his brother lmao. Well he mightn't scum this game because "his brother" hasn't revealed it yet but I'm not ruling him out, notice that Atticus (who I think is human because he hasn't done anythng particularly scummy) votes Stallingchamp then FOSes Coolbot and Jack, then Stallingchamp FOSes Coolbot and Jack. AND Atticus. That to me is very defensive in a scummy way, almost like he's trying to make it look like Atticus is trying to distance himself from fellow scum but in fact Stallingchamp is trying to distance himself.

Stallingchamp

Feel free to say "Trabony you're making no sense".

[Atticus]

Trsbony, you make sense. Even though I'm not willing to vote Scagain right now.