Mini 517: Tree Stump Mafia: Game Over

[Mastermind of Sin]

Funny that DGB tries to attack me for an argument I didn't make, since Adele was the person who brought up false dichotomy, not me. It's always fun to poke at the heap and see what pops out...

Cya monday, peeps.

[Thok]

Official Vote Count

d3sisted (2): (JDodge, scotmany12)
scotmany12 (2): (d3sisted, Korlash)
DrippingGoofball (1): (Aimee)
Korlash (1): (Mith)
Adele (1): (DrippingGoofball)
JDodge (0):
Aimee (0):
Mith (0):
Mastermind of Sin (0):

Not voting (2): (Mastermind of Sin, Adele)

Prodding Aimee

[Aimee]

Yes, but out of everyone on the wagon, he looks like the one who bussed.

This is flat out wrong and ultimately concerning.

I'm having trouble considering how you could argue that d3sisted seemed like bussing more than both Korlash and Max.

Care to explain?

[Aimee]

PS: I shall be posting more later today and tomorrow. Aimee is back.

[d3sisted]

We need a mass stumpage up in here, starting with scotmany.

[d3sisted]

In fact, scotmany I'll make you a deal: if you stump right now, and turn up town, I will immediately stump myself.

[JDodge]

We need a mass stumpage up in here, starting with scotmany.

Why do you want to drastically lower the number of town?

Oh, right, you're scum. I almost forgot.

[mith]

I don't like d3sisted's post myself, but it reads more like bad play from a pro-town player than scummy.

I need to read/re-read some more later. Had to catch up on nano, bleh.

MoS and Adele: I would very much like to see you both place votes. I don't think we are in much danger of a quick stumping at the moment.

[d3sisted]

Right. Scum is sacrificing himself to take out 1 town. Nice...

[JDodge]

Right. Scum is sacrificing himself to take out 1 town. Nice...

assumes you were actually going to stump

[DrippingGoofball]

I don't like d3sisted's post myself, but it reads more like bad play from a pro-town player than scummy.

Me here in full agreement.

[d3sisted]

Right. Scum is sacrificing himself to take out 1 town. Nice...

assumes you were actually going to stump

Then policy lynch me if i refuse to stump.

[JDodge]

Right. Scum is sacrificing himself to take out 1 town. Nice...

assumes you were actually going to stump

Then policy lynch me if i refuse to stump.[/quote

Because you want your buddy to be able to kill another townie

[DrippingGoofball]

Because you want your buddy to be able to kill another townie

How would that work exactly?

[JDodge]

Because you want your buddy to be able to kill another townie

How would that work exactly?

We lynch due to refusal to stump, scum gets a NK

[mith]

...er, are you seriously arguing that it's a *bad* thing for us to lynch scum who refuse to stump?

[Korlash]

Well at least I am not the only one who thinks Scot should stump. I myself almost said the same thing a while ago but thought about the ramifications it would imply. So I do believe it is just a bad pro-town act seeing as how I almost did it myself.

We lynch due to refusal to stump, scum gets a NK

We have to lynch the scum and so they HAVE to get another NK to win. Trying too hard to appear pro-town scum? I think so...

I'm having trouble considering how you could argue that d3sisted seemed like bussing more than both Korlash and Max.

Yeah how can you say anyone looks like they are bussing more then me? Come on Scot... Why is no one else voting him besides me and D? And why do I only have 1 vote? Come on I would think me and Scot are the best choices right now...

[JDodge]

...er, are you seriously arguing that it's a *bad* thing for us to lynch scum who refuse to stump?

No. I'm not.

I'm arguing that he could have - feasibly - been trying to trick scot into stumping.

[Korlash]

And? How is that bad for us? we get one of the most suspicious players to stump, we then get a priority lynch on someone unless they stump, and if they both stump then we get two of the most talked about people proven town. Of course this hurts us by losing two town but overall we are still in the clear. In fact if we had to waste all our stumps i would love to see Scot, D3, JD, myself, and.. well lets just say those four. Because if all of them are

proven town

then it of course eliminates the most obvious people we would have lynched.

Now, I am not for a mass stump! I do not want Scot to stump until he gets more votes.. (Come on people, just a couple more XD) And I do not want to stump myself because I need my vote on Scot!!!! However if it is necessary I would just to prove I am town.

As for Aimee... I believe i saw something earlier I wanted to comment on but now I have forgotten it! XD It was nothing big but I wanted an answer... I will try to find it... Back later!

[scotmany12]

Um, because I don't necessarily view you as scum korlash. I'm following my gut on you, and right now I'm viewing you as a stubborn and misguided town. In fact, you are playing quite aggressive, and most of the time(at least through my experiences) the most aggressive players turn out to be town.

[DrippingGoofball]

...and most of the time(at least through my experiences) the most aggressive players turn out to be town.

Your response is singularly non-aggressive. What you say 'bout that?

[scotmany12]

What's your point? I never said that non-aggressive players are scum. I said that people who are playing as aggressive as khorlash tend to turn up as town, at least through my own experiences. I would also say I have been pretty aggressive towards desisted as of now.

[Korlash]

This has nothing at all to do with the game but why do you keep putting a "H" in my name??? It's been bugging the crap out of me Schot...

[scotmany12]

Why do you keep putting one in my name?

[Korlash]

Cause you kept putting one in my name and I felt I should return the favor...