Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Legacy (Game Over)

[Cheery Dog]

I'm not the messenger, you can worry about whoever they are later.
I think I can go with a zab vote, he was my probable next target earlier in the day. (before that post in which ap decided he was town)
UNVOTE:
VOTE: zab

[AngryPidgeon]

ersonally, I'd prefer the messenger to target Aco, anyway.

This is what I mean...

Cheery, you were going to target me after that?

VOTE: Yates

[mastin2]

Okay. Plan time.

Lynch:

Our options for today are zabriel and Yates.
"Why not PeregrineV?" If for no other reason, because Cheery Dog has a cryptic result on him.
"Why not AngryPidgeon?" Look at his play right now and tell me it's scum.
It aint. He's town, and I do NOT want that lynch.
"Why not jason?" Too much resistance and not enough support for a flashwagon. If he's scum, we can deal with him on day five, but we can't lynch him today.
"Why not myk?" Don't be stupid.

Messenger:

Targets Aco. No questions asked, or I will bust their ass.

Cheery Dog:

Use your role however you see fit, but I request for you

not

to target Aco.

[Cheery Dog]

ersonally, I'd prefer the messenger to target Aco, anyway.

This is what I mean...

Cheery, you were going to target me after that?

No I hadn't decided on anyone else yet, though at one stage you were going to be tomorrow's night action after I misread one of your posts.

I'm actually going to go ask the mod something, but based on the 'die sometime during the game' and not straight away, I think I may still be a better option to use.

[AngryPidgeon]

Ya Jason could be too. Although I think the only wagons that are going to happen atm are me, zab, PV. Of those, Ill end up on PV.

Jason is coasting really hard and could easily be scum. His early game flavor-slip was BULLSHIT too.

And I guess Im stupid because I dont see how Mykonian is obvtown by annnnnny stretch of the word.

P-edit: Why are you a better option?

[AngryPidgeon]

Because if you are town, you should want someone who may not be town and who ACTUALLY has a confirmed useless role to do it.

[Cheery Dog]

If it were instant, yeah, but we still don't know when the person that targets him will actually die, or if each scum member has a different kill flavour when commiting their kills.
I'll wait for the answer to come back from the mod, but since I know my role, and have been told how the kill would probably happen, my logic circuits have pointed me this direction.

[AngryPidgeon]

TIL Cheery is a robot.

[Yates]

Our options for today are zabriel and Yates.

Uhh... why exactly? Because I won't tell you/scum my list of suspects?

[MagnaofIllusion]

No because you are useless sack of nothing ...

[MagnaofIllusion]

@Kise

– You need to address the following question put forth by Peregrine … it’s pretty important you do so before Night.

Where in the thread does Nero say what he told Tammy in their QT?
Not only that, but where in the thread does Nero say something that shows he is "PLAYING TAMMY IN THE QT?"

Failure to do so will be … unwise …

@Peregrine

– You do understand the implications of what your questions mean in regards to Nero’s alignement, correct? I understand the implications on Kise.

--

sigh, you don't get to talk about MoI without him calling you scum I guess. Ain't this game fun.

For the amount of impact you are making there are surprisingly little people following you.

I’ve been consistently calling you scum since I replaced in. Because you are obv-scum and people are just too stupid to see it. But yes, pretend I haven’t :roll”

--

Wrong. If it's pro-town, I don't see why town-MoI would NOT do it.

Since I don’t have endless time tonight Peregrine let me just say the following –

You are wrong. Leashing ANY kind of SK is not Pro-Town. Suffice it to say I say I disagree with your stance in totality and the point you bring up are not meaningful or swaying in the leash. Tomorrow in the AM I will devote a post to point by point
explaining why.

I've never seen any "policies" put forth by MoI.

The good fucking read the links I made earlier if you are Town. Because I didn’t make the for my health and you saying “I don’t understand why Town-MoI would do this” and then “I didn’t read them as I assumed they said claimed they said” makes me want to hang you.

Especially when both examples you bring forth to ‘show’ I make plans are PoE plans predicated on either mass-claims and in no way, shape or form similar to leashing a Serial Killer.

@Peregrine – Please claim whether you are Harry Potter or MGS in your next post. It is fairly important if I am parsing Cheery’s claim correctly.

--

@Mastin

– Post 3387 is stupid. It’s not VCA it is what you expressly called bad VCA analysis in your rather long work in progress.. You aren’t looking at motivation and context just arbitrarily assuming scum are in a specific place when you acknowledge that you have experienced mislynch wagons that were all Town.

And frankly finding that link reminds me that you seem to have broken a large number of your own “good play” guide points and makes me really question whether I should be reading you as Town.

[Acosmist]

ersonally, I'd prefer the messenger to target Aco, anyway.

This is what I mean...

Cheery, you were going to target me after that?

No I hadn't decided on anyone else yet, though at one stage you were going to be tomorrow's night action after I misread one of your posts.

I'm actually going to go ask the mod something, but based on the 'die sometime during the game' and not straight away, I think I may still be a better option to use.

This seems like a good idea.

[pappums rat]

Votecount 4.13

"This reminds me of when we first met." -Solid Snake
"I was the one inside the locker that time. We're equal now, huh?" -Otacon
"Not unless I wet my pants." -Snake
"That's a low blow, Snake." -Otacon, Metal Gear Solid 2

AngryPidgeon - 4 (Kublai Khan, Acosmist, Nero Cain, PeregrineV)
zabriel - 4 (MagnaofIllusion, jasonT1981, mykonian, Cheery Dog)
PeregrineV - 2 (zabriel, Kise)
Yates - 2 (mastin2, AngryPidgeon)
mykonian - 1 (pidgey)
jasonT1981 - 1 (Yates)

Not voting -

Nero Cain is V/LA.
MagnaofIllusion is V/LA until Thursday.

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 4 is 2 AM EST on December 15, 2012.

[Cheery Dog]

Mod's reply says it's a bad idea and not going to work. (PGO being passive)
therefore it is a bad idea and therefore we would still have to wait for me to die.

[mykonian]

sigh, you don't get to talk about MoI without him calling you scum I guess. Ain't this game fun.

For the amount of impact you are making there are surprisingly little people following you.

I’ve been consistently calling you scum since I replaced in. Because you are obv-scum and people are just too stupid to see it. But yes, pretend I haven’t :roll”

You'd almost think I've been accusing you of being a lot of bark and very little bite all game as well

Just take this post for example. That's a huge ass posts which does just one thing: ask perv for a roleclaim. Oh, and barking some more at people.

Okay. Plan time.

Lynch:

Our options for today are zabriel and Yates.

Surprise surprise, I like this plan.

HEY PIDGEY STILL AWAKE?

[Kise]

WTF Mag?

Also, I do need to confirm this because I'm not sure what I think about it, and whatever you think about me I've honestly been searching for mafia since the time the game started. I don't know why you were so suspicious of me when I was honest with my reads.

But, Nero Cain neighborized me last night. We didn't talk about much but he asked me for my four suspects with reasoning. I'm not sure what to think about it and thought I'd hold onto it while I figured it out.

He didn't give many suspects just said he thought Jason was onto something with Kise and thought that Snifit was suspicious too.

I gave him all the thoughts I had on players up to that point, but I do kind of find it weird that he wanted to know my 4 suspects with reasons because he wanted to keep track of suspects. Anyway, do with that what you want.

[Kise]

o nevermind, I see what you thought happened. NOPE no slips from me.

Town in this game make statements, make stuff happen. Scum do not. Which is why Jason, Cheery, MoI, Yates, Kise, zabriel and to a certain extend Acosmist all should be on the top side of people's scumlist. There are things excusing them from it somewhere, and it'd be silly to assume they were all scum, but they are making too little things move, stepping on too few toes, taking too few risks.

This game is boring since we have a group of zab-Yates-PV etc waiting til deadline to make their votes useful. I'm tired of talking in circles or looking - yes, looking - for someone else to slip up for the sake of switching suspects & trying to look productive.

Here's the deal. People get lynched & killed. Ok, we have flips... we don't have anyone with guilties or anything similar coming out to lead us, so what is the point of dragging things out instead of moving on to our next suspects? Oh WAIT some of us DO MOVE ON, but we have to go through the same tired ass motions of 3 weeks before others get up and join a cause.

I said I wouldn't let this game try my patience. Haven't lied about that part, just haven't found anything worth putting my nose in.

Kise

and MoI

are under revision still but are currently on the town side of null.

Good. We can talk about people now without you thinking I have ulterior motive?

[Kise]

http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 2#p4541222

THIS WAS FOR YOU MAINLY, PV

[MagnaofIllusion]

So why instead of ignoring it before did you not just do that in the first place? Frankly I'm fucking sick to death of Acosmist's stupidity this game and you getting in on the act also when I have actual scum suspects doing the same (Nero NEVER addressing his "MoI knew I had three shots" lie for example) thing makes my blood boil.

Frankly this game is getting as close to making me actually do a replace out as I have ever gotten on MS. And that's saying something since I have never, ever done it even when dealing with the likes of Fate and Chessderp.

[Kise]

Ooooo boy. We had to have a fight at some point....

I took a jab at PV's coasting. Didn't care/consider that he wouldn't have his answer. I can't remember how I felt at the time but I may have been thinking he'd do his own research.

This game is nerve-racking if you allow it to be. Lighten up, Mr. Zilla?

[pidgey]

Prod received. Been a busy seek, im movimg all my stuff out of apartment (no longer with internet) and i had my grad party yesterday. Going back to hometown today; will post there tonight.

Also hangover as fuck

[zabriel]

Yates is within my list of acceptable lynches for today.

VOTE: Yates

[mykonian]

ok, someone mind explaining me what that last post by MoI is about? I think it is a reply to kise but I don't know what kise replies to.

And yes, it would be zab. Yay choosing between a wagon with MoI and one with zab!

[mykonian]

who am I kidding

vote Yates

[Acosmist]

MoI's post rings extremely false