Mini 865 -- Evil Eyes (Over)

[tubby216]

This game is incredibly dead. Tubby, you're lurking, actively.

stop being lame there is far more scuminess afoot then what i am doin.

is your intention reck to wagon everyone untill someone gets lynched?

cause right now you are pretty fail my friend

[Nuwen]

This game is incredibly dead. Tubby, you're lurking, actively.

stop being lame there is far more scuminess afoot then what i am doin.

This is good. You've confirmed that you believe other people in this thread are more scummy than you are. Names and why?

If you could shoot anyone in the thread

right now

, who would it be?

[Nuwen]

right now I think that xRECKONERx is pretty sketchy with his wanting to just policy lynch me for no reason, but that might be a bit of OMGUS

What about my policy vote on Zaz? Is that summy, or do you find Reck "sketchy" simply because he wants

you

dead? That's something called OMGUS.

[xRECKONERx]

This game is incredibly dead. Tubby, you're lurking, actively.

stop being lame there is far more scuminess afoot then what i am doin.

is your intention reck to wagon everyone untill someone gets lynched?

cause right now you are pretty fail my friend

So, who's scummy?

So, what about Symbol's vote on you?

So, do you not think wagon hopping until I find scum is a good strategy? Why?

[tubby216]

i would shoot zaz in the head out of frustration.

symbol and suave are far more summy than me, suave cause i don't think his posts are town motivated, and symbol is trying to hard to be town.

wagon hopping on day one is lame, but competeing wagons are good. d1 thought needs to be consolidated instead of scatter brained

wait symbol voted me? hmm ,, yah still don't care

[HowardRoark]

Vote Count (D1)

tubby216 (1) -- Symbol
Hoopla (1) -- MrSuave
MrSuave (2) -- julienvonwolfe, MacavityLock

geekalicious

(4) -- iamausername, ekiM, xRECKONERx, tubby216
ZazieR (3) -- ZazieR, Nuwen, Hoopla
iamausername (1) --

geekalicious

Not Voting (0)

With 12 alive it takes 7 to lynch.

Deadline: 12 NOV 2009 at 5:15 pm UTC (Countdown)

ZazieR has been prodded (1st)

Still seeking a replacement for geekalicious.

[ekiM]

I don't think we should lynch geek while his player slot is empty (no claiming opportunity). Let's lynch tubby or MrSuave for astounding lack of scumhunting.

Unvote; vote: MrSuave

[MacavityLock]

Things I'm waiting for

Geek to get replaced.
Symbol to explain why he thinks that the threat of "List of suspects or die" is equivalent to random fishing.
Reck and tubby to explain why they wagoned Geek after it was stated that he was getting replaced.
Zaz to give a pro-town reason for anything he's done so far.

symbol and suave are far more summy than me, suave cause i don't think his posts are town motivated, and symbol is trying to hard to be town.

Re: Symbol, how is "trying hard to be town" a scumtell?

[tubby216]

Things I'm waiting for

Geek to get replaced.
Symbol to explain why he thinks that the threat of "List of suspects or die" is equivalent to random fishing.
Reck and tubby to explain why they wagoned Geek after it was stated that he was getting replaced.
Zaz to give a pro-town reason for anything he's done so far.

symbol and suave are far more summy than me, suave cause i don't think his posts are town motivated, and

symbol is trying to hard to be town

.

Re: Symbol, how is "trying hard to be town" a scumtell?

no your twisting

[MacavityLock]

symbol and suave are far more summy than me, suave cause i don't think his posts are town motivated, and

symbol is trying to hard to be town

.

Re: Symbol, how is "trying hard to be town" a scumtell?

no your twisting

How is that twisting? You said that Symbol is far more scummy than you, and the reason you cited is that he is trying hard to be town. So how does that make him scummy?

[Symbol]

I wasn't randomly fishing, Mac, but that's what I assumed it may have looked like, hence my curiosity at your response. The death threat was a joke.

(Irrelevantly, your reply to my followup satisfied me.)

I did a really quick meta of Tubby. I just skimmed a few games (ongoing and some towns, no mafias to be honest), but he looks like he gives even less reasons here than usual. *wonders if there's a jester in the setup*

[tubby216]

symbol and suave are far more summy than me, suave cause i don't think his posts are town motivated, and

symbol is trying to hard to be town

.

Re: Symbol, how is "trying hard to be town" a scumtell?

no your twisting

How is that twisting? You said that Symbol is far more scummy than you, and the reason you cited is that he is trying hard to be town. So how does that make him scummy?

no mac no matter how many times you misquote me you ard getting it wrong

SYMBOL IS SCUM BECAUSE HE IS TRYING

TOO HARD TO BE TOWN

now go away and do something useful or bug nuwen i am sure nuwen has more patieance for you than I do.

[MacavityLock]

no mac no matter how many times you misquote me you ard getting it wrong

SYMBOL IS SCUM BECAUSE HE IS TRYING

TOO HARD TO BE TOWN

OK, I need clarification then, because your wording sucks. Do you mean:
a) He's trying too hard at this game, therefore he cannot be town.
b) He's trying too hard to look townie, therefore he cannot be town.

If (a), how is putting forth effort in a game scummy? Also, what is he "trying too hard" to do?

If (b), how is trying to come off as townie as possible scummy?

[Symbol]

I normally hate linking to the wiki, but this is just retarded. Too Townie. One second I'm scummy as hell with my unexplained attacks, the next I'm trying too hard to be townie?

[julienvonwolfe]

Things I'm waiting for

Geek to get replaced.
Symbol to explain why he thinks that the threat of "List of suspects or die" is equivalent to random fishing.
Reck and tubby to explain why they wagoned Geek after it was stated that he was getting replaced.
Zaz to give a pro-town reason for anything he's done so far.

symbol and suave are far more summy than me, suave cause i don't think his posts are town motivated, and

symbol is trying to hard to be town

.

Re: Symbol, how is "trying hard to be town" a scumtell?

no your twisting

Replying in more than three words is generally courteous.


Suave hasn't replied to my last post so my vote stays.

[tubby216]

no his link is fail cause that is not what i am talkin about,

symbol replaced into flaked/suspect scum slot,

then he posts some crap, attacks some people then starts to be more agreable, more townish and i am not buying to me he is trying too hard at being town.

I do not mean he is too townie to be town.

[Symbol]

I don't remember ever being very disagreeable in this game, and as far as I remember SophisticDoctrine was not widely suspected. I didn't post crap; it was quite obvious what I was trying to do and if a mafioso wants to blend in he typically won't go through the motions I did when he could immediately post some sort of case.

And no, there's barely a difference, if any at all, between "too townie" and "trying too hard to look town." They both stem from your basic perception that my approach is pro-town in theory.

[Nuwen]

*wonders if there's a jester in the setup*

... why would you post that? What possible town benefit could come from introducing speculation about rarer-than-live-cow role with

zero

reason to believe it exists.

I don't want to hear anyone's thoughts on whether or not Tubby is a jester. I don't want anyone to even think about the word jester. It's one of those unbalanced, almost bastardly roles that has no place in a real game. The suggestion that anyone is or might be a jester is a step towards saying the town shouldn't lynch anti-town players, a scummy precedent to set up.

Tubby, why is replacing out of a game scummy? Flaking tends to be alignment neutral, except in very specific personal metas. Ether, for example, gets into a pattern of lurking and flakish behavior

without fail

as scum).

If replacing out is always a scumtell to you, why was Geek not on your top suspects list a few posts ago? Your scumtells aren't consistent with each other, which implies that you're trying to force cases where available but aren't actually hunting for scum.

[MacavityLock]

AAAH! Answer my questions! (a) or (b)? What the hell does "trying too hard at being town" mean?

(And you don't have patience for me?)

[Symbol]

FFS, Nuwen, there's no jester. Calm the hell down.

[Nuwen]

"That's scummy."
"LOL JK GUYZ"

[Symbol]

Are you serious, Nuwen? The point was that Tubby is scummy as hell, but that it made no sense he'd consciously play so recklessly as either alignment. Stop leaping on whatever snippets you don't like. Scum-hunt. Your vacillation is yecch.

[tubby216]

soph was scummy to me

vote MrSuave

.

I am jealous of his suavity.

so you put him at l-3 for bs reasons?

did you read the thread or do you crave the attention?

vote MrSuave

.

I am jealous of his suavity.

so you put him at l-3 for bs reasons?

did you read the thread or do you crave the attention?

for this and lurking

vote: SphistricDoctrine

see i suspect soph kept my vote on him/symbol even after symbol replaced in.

then i did the following

fine reck i'll follow

unvote, vote geekalious

i thought reck might have a hunch and wanted to help persue it. to later find out reck is simply wagoning for the sake of wagoning,

but for now i am lazy and i want geeks replacement to have the proper motivation not to blow this off and to post real thoughts and other things as soon as humanly possible.

so to sum up.

i am ignoring mac for his failure to read

symbol is still very scummy to me

i will likely switch my vote back to symbol once a replacement is found for geek.

[xRECKONERx]

Tubby, did you just say you suspect Symbol because he's "too townie"?

[tubby216]

:face palm:

daykill RECK

no symbol is not townie at all, symbol is trying too hard to act like a townie and failing at being town.

for each one of his posts i see them as scum motivated, however at first glance they(his posts) appear townish, upon further review they are scummy