Paint Mafia! - Game Over!

[Papa Zito]

No worries.

In the interests of transparency, since I totally get that my lack of contribution to date makes me basically unreadable - Enough people have said his name (and we have an actual vote now) that I'm anticipating a wagon of some sort to form, especially given the malaise that we seem to be experiencing atm. So my iso dive and subsequent questions are gonna serve 2 purposes, one to get a solid read on an apparently controversial slot and two to evaluate how others are approaching said slot.

FWIW I have a few of townreads based on how mechanics have played out and how some players are attempting to solve the game but I'm not sure how valuable it is to share those rn.

[Aristophanes]

No worries.

In the interests of transparency, since I totally get that my lack of contribution to date makes me basically unreadable - Enough people have said his name (and we have an actual vote now) that I'm anticipating a wagon of some sort to form, especially given the malaise that we seem to be experiencing atm. So my iso dive and subsequent questions are gonna serve 2 purposes, one to get a solid read on an apparently controversial slot and two to evaluate how others are approaching said slot.

FWIW I have a few of townreads based on how mechanics have played out and how some players are attempting to solve the game but I'm not sure how valuable it is to share those rn.

Cool, this is appreciated and probably the towniest thing you've said yet.
I look forward to your eventual attempt at sorting people

[Davsto]

People I forget are playing unless I read their posts: Xtoxm, Davsto
People who are memorable in the game, but I forget their posts: Lilith
People who could be scm for lack of contribution: Zito

So

All of your scumreads are based on lack of memorability etc
Rather than their actual, you know, play? Doing scummy things?

Can you see why I feel that is awfully convenient?

[lilith2013]

No worries.

In the interests of transparency, since I totally get that my lack of contribution to date makes me basically unreadable - Enough people have said his name (and we have an actual vote now) that I'm anticipating a wagon of some sort to form, especially given the malaise that we seem to be experiencing atm. So my iso dive and subsequent questions are gonna serve 2 purposes, one to get a solid read on an apparently controversial slot and two to evaluate how others are approaching said slot.

FWIW I have a few of townreads based on how mechanics have played out and how some players are attempting to solve the game but I'm not sure how valuable it is to share those rn.

I would like to hear them.

People I forget are playing unless I read their posts: Xtoxm, Davsto
People who are memorable in the game, but I forget their posts: Lilith
People who could be scm for lack of contribution: Zito

So

All of your scumreads are based on lack of memorability etc
Rather than their actual, you know, play? Doing scummy things?

Can you see why I feel that is awfully convenient?

Scumreads?

[Aristophanes]

People I forget are playing unless I read their posts: Xtoxm, Davsto
People who are memorable in the game, but I forget their posts: Lilith
People who could be scm for lack of contribution: Zito

So

All of your scumreads are based on lack of memorability etc
Rather than their actual, you know, play? Doing scummy things?

Can you see why I feel that is awfully convenient?

I knew someone would say that.

However, I have townreads on Elbirn and Spiffeh due to roles claimed and play.
I have townleans on Fire and Hiplop from play.

If it were simply that I was scumreading those with little contribution, wouldn't Hippy and Fire be there too?

The 4 I gave are in the Null and Null-scum categories, which is where I'd like to start sorting people.

[Davsto]

Scumreads?

Spiffeh (null about him playwise, but his role sounds a tad like a scum role, being able to conceal scum partners' colours, for example).
Zito is just eh and has basically done fuckall so I'm fine with him dying thank you very much

Xtoxm, I need to read through his and AA's things because I honestly can't say anything about them
hiplop seems to be a popular scumread choice but I'm not entirely sure I see that so I'm gonna need to read that too

[Papa Zito]

I would like to hear them.

Hmm. Why?

[hiplop]

dav is town

VOTE: spiffeh

[lilith2013]

I would like to hear them.

Hmm. Why?

To quote marquis.. ~reasons~

[Papa Zito]

To quote marquis.. ~reasons~

Not terribly convincing.

---

VOTE: spiffeh

Ok I'd love to hear the reason behind this.

Also

i assume i thought bbt was scum and thought i voted him

well

When you said "I mentioned it earlier" what were you referring to?

[lilith2013]

Are you not going to say unless I give a reason?

[Spiffeh]

@mod V/LA until Monday the 7th

Also hiplop's a bitch and probably scum

[Papa Zito]

Are you not going to say unless I give a reason?

What benefits do you see.

[hiplop]

zito, why are you focussing on something from so long ago

[Papa Zito]

zito, why are you focussing on something from so long ago

Are you implying it doesn't matter?

cuz if it doesn't matter what's the harm in answering :3

[lilith2013]

Are you not going to say unless I give a reason?

What benefits do you see.

I'm trying to figure out whether I'd want to lynch you still.

[hiplop]

zito, why are you focussing on something from so long ago

Are you implying it doesn't matter?

cuz if it doesn't matter what's the harm in answering :3

I literally can't rememberis the issue

[Papa Zito]

zito, why are you focussing on something from so long ago

Are you implying it doesn't matter?

cuz if it doesn't matter what's the harm in answering :3

I literally can't rememberis the issue

:/ Ok.

you know what? fuck it

lets get him spiff
VOTE: bbt

Prior to this post you were quite emphatic that Davsto was scum. What prompted this move?

[Elbirn]

VOTE: Hiplop

[Davsto]

I'll read through those ISOs I said I was going to tomorrow, because it'll be a saturday then so I'll have more time to do anything other than rush through hoping for it to end so I can do something more interesting.

[Firebringer]

dav is town

VOTE: spiffeh

I agree with hiplop
VOTE: Spiffeh

[Firebringer]

@mod V/LA until Monday the 7th

Also hiplop's a bitch and probably scum

Happy Birthday SPIFFEH!!!!

[Aristophanes]

How is Spiffeh scum??
I don't see it at all from a role spec perspective.

[Firebringer]

How is Spiffeh scum??
I don't see it at all from a role spec perspective.

Never town read someone on roles.
I have been kicked around for that too many times.

You either town read them or you don't. Then vote them.

[Papa Zito]

Can you explain:

1. Why you aren't town-reading him from a play perspective; and
2. How his role works in a scum context


TIA