Mountainous Mafia (77)

[discer]

I'm going back thru the thread to see if I missed something but not really expecting to find much (probably why I won't find anything......tisk, tisk). Something someone said about pride has

really

got me thinking so I'm primarily doing battle in my head.

[mathcam]

As far as the night kill patterns go, I think they implicate all of us for one reason or another.

See, I'm not sure this is true, at least if ignore the really hypothetical arguments. If we just look at in terms of who was most most suspicious of who at the end of yesterday (with mathcam, Tigris, discer, and Prizm alive), I would think that

Prizm would kill discer, most confirmed innocent (or maybe even me, since I voted for Prizm yesterday)
mathcam would kill discer, most confirmed innocent
discer would kill someone other than discer, and I suspect it would be Tigris for reasons I've mentioned in previous posts.

But perhaps most important is the fact that it's just hard for me to believe that Prizm would intentionally lead us to this endgame. Surely killing Leo can't have been the right play for him two nights ago. But to someone more though to be innocent, it doesn't matter nearly as much who gets killed.

Any chance you're going to up the participation, Prizm, or should we just start voting at will?

Cam

[Werebear]

5 days, 6 posts... hey, I'm willing to let this linger. *laugh* No deadline yet.

[Prizm]

Ok, I'm willing to participate.

vote mathcam

. Going with my gut.[/b]

[discer]

Prizm wrote:

Ok, I'm willing to participate.

vote mathcam

. Going with my gut.

Sorry Cam, but a good mafia would never let this go.

Vote: Mathcam

I'm sure there will be an endgame discussion, which I look foward to.

[mathcam]

Oh, you bastards. Prizm, that's not at all what I meant by participate. Sigh. I really wanted to win that, too.

Cam

[Werebear]

So Prizm and Discer summarily kill Mathcam, and again burn the body. They had previously searched the body, and found a key secreted on it...

After a few hours searching, they found a safe for use by the vacationers, and in it... knives! Guns! Incriminating evidence! Mathcam must have been the last mafia.


...The next day, a helicopter shows up, and lands. The pilot gets out, looking confused. "Hey! You!" discer runs towards the pilot, yelling and waving.
"We hadn't heard from anyone for days, is everything OK, sir?"
discer told the pilot the sad story of so many dead, but how in the end the killers were vanquished.
"Well, hop in, Mr. Discer. I'll lift you back to safety. Any other survivors?"
"None."

...and as they left, Discer looked down at his victory site, that only yesterday had a pit of ashes and bone, and now looked as clean as could be...

DISCER, mafia scum, wins the game!!!

[Werebear]

Woo hoo! Quite a long and winding road. Many thanks to the players who didn't drop out, and especially the ones that the mafia (and lynchers) allowed to live to the end of the game.

I still question what would have been the result if 12 seasoned mafia players had entered... the newbie mistakes day 1 and 2 cost the town quite a bit, but then, we did have a good mafia in here too.

I'm planning to run a sequel some day, "Investigations of a Mountanous Crime Scene". I have a nasty little twist planned for it... *evil cackle*

[Prizm]

Pleh. Sorry mathcam, but I really did think it was you, and I figured if I was wrong and didn't vote, discer wouldn't make any glaring errors that would make me change my mind. Given that I had the most suspicious record, I'd probably end up getting lynched, so I voted. Oh well.

[Tigris]

Very nicely done discer and to think I was the one pushing your innocence the most. Oh well, next game if I agree with someone, I will know they are scum. ^_^ 'vote: random person, because he/she/it agrees with me, so they must be evil.' That'll go over well. ~_^

Thanks for modding oh bearish one, it was quite a lot of fun.

[Mojo]

That was a great game, thanks for modding Werebear.
I must say discer, you are one hell of a mafia. You know, I was surprised that JereIC didn't mention the lists after my death, but oh well.
Again, GREAT GAME, mafia wins, woohoo.

[Dasquian]

Aha, nicely done discer I was betting on mathcam being the last mafia too, but I

did

correctly guess that he'd be lynched..

This was a fun game, I'm sorry I got killed night 2, I would've liked to have been around for the mind-bending last few day's discussion. I guess that's what twilight accusations get you

[Leonardo 007]

This was a great game. Thank you, Bear. My first Mafia game and I really got into it, and enjoyed following it after my expected death.

Discer was a helluva good mafia! I suspected Prizm all the time. I couldn't understand why did they lynch mathcam. But Discer? I don't think I ever suspected him. Mojo hated me, and knowing I am innocent, it was pretty obviously to me that he's a mafia. But Discer? Good, old, polite Discer? A real scum indeed!

/in for your next game

[Mojo]

I didn't hated you, I just didn't play very well...

[JereIC]

Wow, great game all! I never for my life suspected discer, although I was feeling like there may have been something else going on. As for the lists, I really don't think they helped, unfortunately; we would have lynched Mojo eventually anyway. So, I didn't think to mention them after we got mojo.

[Leonardo 007]

You know, I'd really love to play again with this game's participators.

[Mr_Gnome_It_All]

I just didn't play very well...

YOU didn't play well? Look what happened to me!

[Werebear]

Modding was my pleasure. It was fun to see the tides turn. One thing I was VERY surprised about was that nobody kept track of who voted for whom... especially "scum spots" 3 and 4 on a bandwagon. Take a look back. I was watching, but then I knew who was mafia the whole time.

[Werebear]

And Mr. Gnome-it-All? All told, the newbies in the game did what any other player does as a newbie. It happens. That's why the three or four warnings before you signed up, but of course you don't know that when you're a new player. I'm glad we had some newbies in here, I just hope that all of you continue playing more "normal" games.

[discer]

This was a great game and I rather enjoyed watching people state EXACTLY what I was doing but blaming everyone else. I love it when a plan comes together! One possibly altering moment occured when we found out Mathcam was replacing Yanqush after we made our night kill selection. I'm not big on experienced players returning to a game (when I'm scum) but am glad I kept Cam around for the extra excitement. Tho I'm sure I'd feel differently had I gotten lynched. Thanks to everyone for playine and again to Werebear for modding a great game.

[mathcam]

Given that I had the most suspicious record, I'd probably end up getting lynched, so I voted. Oh well.

I was trying to go out of my way to make it clear that discer was my leading candidate...that the night kills just didn't make sense for you to have made them. But as you say, oh well. A (slightly bitter ) congrats to discer.

Cam

[discer]

Cam, I'll give you credit for not giving credit to Prizm. Better luck next time. (teeheehee)

[mathcam]

Why you little....



Cam

[Yanqush]

Geez..... what a twist.....
Shame I had to go, but I guess I would of died anyway.... oh well...

Tigris: Regarding how you said I am a bit more talkative?... I was just trying to participate more (not too successfully I might add since exams decide to come along half way through) as I found that in the last few games being "sheepish" and staying a quiet was not very productive and at kinda detrimental overall to the game.... but I am glad anyway, that someone notice some change... hehe

Anyway, can't stay, hope I get home soon and can start playing again~

[MeMe]

last post